Australia and New Zealand · Public discussion

Article in The Age

Started by Resound · · Last activity · 12 posts · 791 views

This thread is locked and is currently read-only.

Thread navigation

Jump through the discussion

Go to the original post, the replies on this page, or the latest preserved contribution.

Thread details

What we know about this thread

Original section
Australia and New Zealand
Published
25 August 2005
Last activity
27 August 2005
Original author
Resound
Posts
12
Discussion status
Public discussion
Total views
791
Views / 30 days
0
Topics

The navigation and discussion metadata provide context. Posts remain in their original chronological order.

Showing posts 1–12 of 12
Posts remain in their original chronological order.

Text size
  1. Found this this morning...
    http://www.theage.com.au/news/opinion/join-the-bike-nazi-party/2005/08/25/1124562975946.html

    I'm not sure who to be more [censored] at, Jim Schembri who seems to be
    determined to make ignorance a virtue, or the [censored] who do actually ride
    on footpaths, run red lights etc and as such actually do deserve this sort
    of rant. On the whole I think I'm rather more [censored] with the
    redoubtable Mr. Schembri...this article doesn't seem to serve any purpose
    other than to vilify cyclists as a group.

    Spit.

    Stomp.

    Swear.

  2. Sent a letter to The Age:

    Jim Schembri seems to be determined to make knee-jerk, reactionary vitriol a
    virtue. As (predictably enough, I suppose) a regular cyclist, I do find
    myself swearing at the odd pedestrian. Usually the ones that look straight
    at me prior to walking out in front of me from between parked cars. This is
    assuming that they look at all. Here's where I differ from the redoubtable
    Mr. Schembri though - I recognise the fact that these twits are most
    decidedly the minority. The bulk of pedestrians do the right thing by dint
    of taking some responsibility for their own safety. There is however, a
    small pecentage of pedestrians, motorists and, yes, cyclists who do stupid
    things on a regular basis. I see them daily as I ride to work and I swear at
    them at least as much as motorists do because it gives the self-satisfied
    prat sitting next to me in 2.6 tonnes of Prado an excuse to squeeze me into
    the gutter.

    I, as most serious cyclists, by which I mean someone who sees cycling as
    transport and not some poor substitute for a proper, fossil fuel burning
    form of transport, do in fact make a point of obeying the road rules. We do
    actually know what the road rules are, with particular regard as to how they
    apply to us.

    Jim Schembri's article is a pathetic attempt to appeal to the least
    thougtful section of the community by latching on to a currently fashionable
    bogeyman. There's nothing easier than whipping up a bit of scorn for a
    conveniently placed minority group, but there are also few things less
    responsible. As a direct result of this tripe, I expect to be harrassed on
    the road, despite scupulously obeying the law and being as courteous as
    possible.

    Grow up Jim, and if you can't find some serious issues to address try your
    hand at something else. Oh, and buy yourself a bicycle so you can address
    this topic from a position of knowledge instead of ignorance. Who knows. we
    might make a bike Nazi of you yet.

  3. good one 😄 (except that last sentence 🙁 )

    dont want that phrase sticking...

  4. He he, this is weird. He [censored] about bikes hung from the handrail in the trains. I was orderd by Connex staff, ticket controllers or WFT ever you call them, to put the bike there. So, now I do, by direct order from Connex. 🙂

  5. Resound [email protected] said:

    Sent a letter to The Age:

    Great reply. Have you seen his 'bio'?

    [....]

    "In his own time Jim loves to write, read, watch TV, catch mice, sing
    in the spa, talk on the phone and collect Star Wars toys."

    *vomit*

    http://www.jimschembri.com/Default.htm

    --
    ..dt
    1996 Diamond Back 'Expert Tg' Roadie (7spd DT shifters, favourite bike!)
    2004 Trek 2300 Roadie (9spd Ultegra)
    2003 DiamondBack 'Criterium' Roadie (8spd Sora, rain bike)

  6. Personally, I thought Schembri's effort was quite a good lark and probably
    wouldn't do much to damage the rep's of those of us who obey the rules. We
    all know the idiots he's talking about. I'm looking on the bright side and
    seeing it as a good bit of fun to poke at those of the biking
    fraternity/sorority we think of unkindly. Don't take it too personally but
    you have o consider that in many respects he is right. If we continue to
    obey the rules and do what we do, we earn the respect of those cagers and
    peds we see on our regular morning and evening commutes. To me, that's
    where it counts.

    --
    Bean

    Remove "yourfinger" before replying
    "Claes" <[email hidden]> wrote in message
    news:[email hidden]...

    Quoted message said:


    He he, this is weird. He [censored] about bikes hung from the handrail in
    the trains. I was orderd by Connex staff, ticket controllers or WFT
    ever you call them, to put the bike there. So, now I do, by direct
    order from Connex. 🙂

    --
    Claes

  7. Resound wrote:
    <snip>

    Quoted message said:

    small pecentage of pedestrians, motorists and, yes, cyclists who do stupid
    things on a regular basis. I see them daily as I ride to work and I swear at
    them at least as much as motorists do because it gives the self-satisfied
    prat sitting next to me in 2.6 tonnes of Prado an excuse to squeeze me into
    the gutter.


    <snip>

    Oooh, you singled out Prados. You rock!

    Tam

  8. Its the context.

    If the article appeared in a cycling magazine, you might take it to be a bit of an off-beat criticism/commentary on the more aggressive/badly behaved part of the cycling fraternity.

    In a mainstream publication, read by many who are either mildly anti-cyclist or totally anti-cyclist, the article merely feeds those irrational prejudices.

    Should Schembri be asked to write a similar "BMW nazi" or "Prado nazi" article for next week?

    SteveA

  9. Seems to me this is a pre critical mass vent - it is the last Friday of the month after all.
    To demonstrate the Power of the Pedal we often hold huge rallies, blocking roads and bridges and driving motorists nuts - but people just shrug their shoulders and go "Well, what can you do?" We once blocked an entire bridge. It was a stirring display of democracy in action. I still have no idea what the cause was.

  10. "Resound" <[email protected]> wrote in
    news:[email hidden]:

    Quoted message said:

    http://www.theage.com.au/news/opinion/join-the-bike-nazi-


    party/2005/08/

    Quoted message said:

    25/1124562975946.html

    Dear editor,

    Jim Schembri's article is an amazing
    piece of literature ("Join the Bike Nazi Party" The Age 26/8/2005).
    Despite his claim of an expensive bike purchase and his
    desire to join the "Bike Nazis", he obviously has never experienced
    the joys of narrow misses with the "Car Nazis". Nor has he experienced
    the joys of the "Parking Nazis" who insist that bike lanes are really
    parking lots. And of course cyclists being a much maligned minority
    why not give them another lot of good kicking while they are down?
    Given the numerous cyclicts killed in hit-and-run accidents, perhaps
    we should all resign from "Bike Nazis" party and join the
    "4WD Nazis"? Why not clog up our roads (can we clog them anymore?) and
    pour tonnes and tonnes of pollution into our cities? Keep them coming,
    Jim, mate! There is nothing like ignorance and prejudice to keep up
    your readership.

  11. The Doctor said:

    "Resound" <[email protected]> wrote in
    news:[email hidden]:

    Quoted message said:

    http://www.theage.com.au/news/opinion/join-the-bike-nazi-


    party/2005/08/

    Quoted message said:

    25/1124562975946.html

    Dear editor,

    Jim Schembri's article is an amazing
    piece of literature ("Join the Bike Nazi Party" The Age 26/8/2005).
    Despite his claim of an expensive bike purchase and his
    desire to join the "Bike Nazis", he obviously has never experienced
    the joys of narrow misses with the "Car Nazis". Nor has he experienced
    the joys of the "Parking Nazis" who insist that bike lanes are really
    parking lots. And of course cyclists being a much maligned minority
    why not give them another lot of good kicking while they are down?
    Given the numerous cyclicts killed in hit-and-run accidents, perhaps
    we should all resign from "Bike Nazis" party and join the
    "4WD Nazis"? Why not clog up our roads (can we clog them anymore?) and
    pour tonnes and tonnes of pollution into our cities? Keep them coming,
    Jim, mate! There is nothing like ignorance and prejudice to keep up
    your readership.

    Schembri:
    "Sometimes, as I'm hurtling down the footpath at Warp 7, I'll
    accidentally-on-purpose boot some hapless pedestrian in the bum as
    punishment for not looking behind them every few seconds and making way."

    He's obviously not a cyclist. No cyclist would bother to unclip for such a
    silly thing. Even among those that have occasion to want to kick a car for
    trying to kill them, if they have a moment, think: 'is it really worth
    unclipping...naw' LOL.

    -Wheels

  12. "The Doctor" <[email hidden]> wrote in message
    news:[email hidden]...

    Quoted message said:

    "Resound" <[email protected]> wrote in
    news:[email hidden]:

    Quoted message said:

    http://www.theage.com.au/news/opinion/join-the-bike-nazi-


    party/2005/08/

    Quoted message said:

    25/1124562975946.html

    Dear editor,

    Jim Schembri's article is an amazing
    piece of literature ("Join the Bike Nazi Party" The Age 26/8/2005).
    Despite his claim of an expensive bike purchase and his
    desire to join the "Bike Nazis", he obviously has never experienced
    the joys of narrow misses with the "Car Nazis". Nor has he experienced
    the joys of the "Parking Nazis" who insist that bike lanes are really
    parking lots. And of course cyclists being a much maligned minority
    why not give them another lot of good kicking while they are down?
    Given the numerous cyclicts killed in hit-and-run accidents, perhaps
    we should all resign from "Bike Nazis" party and join the
    "4WD Nazis"? Why not clog up our roads (can we clog them anymore?) and
    pour tonnes and tonnes of pollution into our cities? Keep them coming,
    Jim, mate! There is nothing like ignorance and prejudice to keep up
    your readership.

    And this is my contribution -

    In his article "Be a smarty: Join the Bike Nazi Party" (The Age Friday
    26/8) Jim Schembri writes one of the many anti-cyclist rants appearing
    in the media recently, typical of a petrolhead journalist.

    Yes, there are irresponsible cyclists, just like there are
    irresponsible pedestrians and drivers. Yes, the article is humorous,
    in a weird sort of way, but all it serves to do is to appeal to the
    lowest common denominator amongst drivers and incite them to show
    their aggression towards the average law-abiding and responsible
    cyclist - aggression which I experience daily as I commute to work on
    my bicycle even though I obey every law.

    Jim, quit writing make-believe articles, get out of your car, hop on a
    bicycle and ride safely and responsibly for a week - just as thousands
    of cyclists, myself included, do daily. Then you can write another,
    more serious article, and tell us what it's really like.

    Henry.

Active in the last 60 minutes

Active in this thread

0 users · 0 guests ·0 bots ·0 total

No signed-in users are active right now.

No known search crawlers active right now.