On Tue, 15 Jun 2004 09:37:56 -0700, Eldritch <[email hidden]>
Quoted message said:Alan said:
3. I don't agree with the general consensus that the 2
hour is the most important. For type 2 and IGT, my
personal opinion is that the one hour is equally, or
even more, important.
Of course, they're saying that because the 2-hour
test has been well correlated with death by heart
attack. Why do you feel the 1-hour is more
important?
E
Hi Eldritch
This is purely my own analysis and opinion based on the
little I've learned over the past two years about type 2
management.
The doctor and I use the test results in different ways. The
FBG and two-hour test results are indicators for the doctor
of the success (or failure) of my control and whether I need
changes in treatment - what I'd call macro-management. The
one-hour tests, again in my opinion, are a direct indication
of the effects of a specific meal or food and allow me to
make specific dietary changes, or micro-management.
Macro-management: The doctor, once we are diagnosed, can't
rely on the one-hour tests because they are too dependant on
what we ate, something the doctor can't control. The two-
hour test is more valid for them because our Type 2 system
has settled back from the peak by then. To the doctor,
consistently high numbers at two hours indicates that we
aren't improving and need to change treatment if we won't
change lifestyle, or are deteriorating with progression.
That is also why "the 2-hour test has been well correlated
with death by heart attack"; when I read those studies I
can't remember one which tested at one hour to discuss a
possible correlation there.
Micro-management: For me the one hour test is a much more
accurate indicator of whether I need to change something in
my diet or exercise regimen, for precisely the same reasons
that the doctor can't rely on
it: it is reflecting what I ate in the most recent meal and
the exercise I am doing.
Consequently, now that I have gained a degree of control, I
still regularly test at one hour, but I only bother with a
two hour test if the one hour was unusual.
Cheers, Alan, T2 d&e, Australia. Remove weight and
carbs to email.
--
Everything in Moderation - Except Laughter.