in article [email hidden], M-W at
[email hidden] wrote on 1/27/04 3:43 PM:
Quoted message said:Sheryl Rosen said:I still cringe when I hear people brag about what great food Science Diet and Iams is. It's a
step up from Purina Cat Show, but it's still mostly ground yellow corn.
If you read the label, Iams has the same amount of protien as MaxCat.
Yeah, I'm sure it does. It has to. That's a standard set by AAFCO.
Quoted message said:
By the way, you wrote that MaxCat doesn't have filler that bulks up the stool. Another word for
"filler" is "fiber." One would think, fiber is beneficial to cats for the same reasons it is
beneficial to humans.
No. I didn't say MaxCat doesn't have "filler". I said it doesn't have "ground yellow corn", and it
smells like chicken, not corn. You need to learn to read for comprehension.
MaxCat does use grain as filler (which is not necessarily the same as fiber), but it's rice, which
is more digestible and has more usable nutrients than corn. Corn is tasty, but it's not all that
nutritious. For humans or cats. Iams uses "ground yellow corn"--the entire corn grain. The only part
of the corn grain that Max Cat uses is the gluten. And that's the only part that has any nutrition.
As for protein, if you read the labels carefully, you will see that the first ingredient on the Iams
label is "Chicken". Sounds good, right? Wrong!
The first ingredient on the MaxCat label is "Chicken Meal".
Meat, as you know is predominantly water. Ingredients are listed in order of predominance, by weight
BEFORE PROCESSING. If you mix 1 pound of ground chicken meat with 1/2 lb of corn meal, and bake it
until it's DRY, you are evaporating all the water and what you wind up with is basically a chicken
flavored corn meal cookie. Only about 1/5 of the weight of the meat remains after cooking until dry.
If you start with 1 lb of dry chicken meal (It takes 5lbs of chicken to get one pound of chicken
meal), and mix it with 1/2 lb of corn meal... you are actually getting more chicken protein by
volume than if you start with an equal amount of meat.
Iams may have "the same amount of protein" as Max Cat, but there is an awful lot more filler, in the
form of ground yellow corn meal, that has to get processed by your cat only to wind up in the litter
box. Why pay for something that has no nutritional value and that only serves to make your cat's
little body work harder and create more [censored] for you deal with????
All fillers are not created equally. Some are just filler. Others do provide much needed soluble
fiber and some nutrients. Corn is just filler. Oats and rice provide soluble fiber and plenty of
nutrients.