General fitness, health and nutrition · Public discussion

When good doctors go bad.

Started by Nick · · Last activity · 3 posts · 679 views

This thread is locked and is currently read-only.

Thread details

What we know about this thread

Original section
General fitness, health and nutrition
Published
4 January 2004
Last activity
6 January 2004
Original author
Nick
Posts
3
Discussion status
Public discussion
Total views
679
Views / 30 days
0

The navigation and discussion metadata provide context. Posts remain in their original chronological order.

Showing posts 1–3 of 3
Posts remain in their original chronological order.

Text size
  1. I've found a lot of good stuff on mercola's site, www.mercola.com but it
    seems that at least of late, he is not doing his homework. For example, a
    recent study found that calorie restriction enhances respiration, but
    mercola says:

    "A low metabolism is ideal for long life and good health. A high metabolism excites hormones in the
    body that eventually cause age-related diseases."
    mercola.comcarbohydrates age.htm

    He also claims (at that web address) that fruit is not healthy because: "Fructose causes insulin
    resistance as proven in scientific tests. Fructose is highly addictive and most people simply refuse
    to give up fruit no matter how sick they become. This is identical to lung cancer patients who
    continue to smoke cigarettes." Too silly to warrant a response.

    Here is the reality, though scientists like Ray Peat have been saying similar things for years:

    "Cold Spring Harbor Laboratory Date: 2004-01-01 MIT Helps Unlock Life-extending Secrets Of Calorie
    Restriction CAMBRIDGE, Mass. -- Shedding light on why drastically restricting calorie intake
    prolongs life span in some organisms, MIT researchers report in the Jan. 1 issue of Genes &
    Development that lowering the level of a common coenzyme activates an anti-aging gene in yeast.
    Calorie restriction extends life span in a wide spectrum of organisms, and has been shown to delay
    the onset or reduce the incidence of many age-related diseases, including cancer and diabetes. No
    one is sure why it works. MIT Biology Professor Leonard P. Guarente discovered in 2000 that calorie
    restriction activates the silenced information regulator (SIR2) gene, which has the apparent ability
    to slow aging during the low-calorie diet. This gene makes a protein called Sir2, which is normally
    activated by the coenzyme molecule NAD. Guarente has shown that SIR2 is integrally tied to extending
    life span in yeast and in the roundworm. Humans carry a similar gene. This latest study probes how
    Sir2 is activated by calorie restriction. The authors report that a coenzyme related to NAD, called
    NADH (nicotinamide adenine dinucleotide) inhibits Sir2 by blocking the action of NAD. During calorie
    restriction, levels of NADH decline in cells. This decrease in NADH allows NAD to better activate
    Sir2 and thereby extend life span. "These findings provide a simple model for activation of Sir2 and
    extension of life span by calorie restriction," the authors write. "Our findings suggest that the
    NAD/NADH ratio can serve a critical regulatory function, determining the life span of yeast mother
    cells. A reduction in this nucleotide activates Sir2 to extend the life span in calorie
    restriction." In previous research, Guarente found that rather than a slower metabolism leading to a
    slower rate of respiration, it turns out that respiration in yeast cells under calorie restriction
    goes up, not down. "A high respiration rate is intimately connected with calorie restriction in
    yeast," he said. "A high respiration rate activates SIR2. When respiration goes up, NADH goes down
    and SIR2 goes up. When SIR2 goes up, longevity happens." NADH, a coenzyme or enzyme helper, is
    present in all living cells. (An enzyme is a protein that works like a catalyst in the body to
    prompt chemical changes; for instance, turning food into energy.) NADH, an activated form of the B
    vitamin niacin, helps produce energy through a series of chemical reactions in the cell. In cells,
    NADH stimulates the production of ATP (adenosine triphosphate), a compound that represents chemical
    energy in cells. The more NADH a cell has, the more stored energy it has. It remains to be seen
    whether these findings about yeast and NADH will relate to the extension of life span in mammals by
    calorie restriction. "

  2. nick said:

    This latest study probes how Sir2 is activated by calorie restriction. The authors report that a
    coenzyme related to NAD, called NADH (nicotinamide adenine dinucleotide) inhibits Sir2 by
    blocking the action of NAD. During calorie restriction, levels of NADH decline in cells. This
    decrease in NADH

    NAD and NADH+H+ is the same molecule, in two different oxidation states. Not two nearly related
    molecules. Not understanding this, the rest of the article is pure nonsense.

  3. I think Mercola still does good work, but can make errors like everyone else. Fructose seems to be a
    controversial issue...some confuse it with high fructose corn syrup perhaps. But the fiber and
    pectin in fruit slow absorption. Plus I think fructose does not elevate insulin...

    James Wholesale health & fitness supplements: www.KiloHealth.com

    "nick" <[email hidden]> wrote in message news:<[email hidden]>...

    Quoted message said:

    I've found a lot of good stuff on mercola's site, www.mercola.com but it seems that at least of
    late, he is not doing his homework. For example, a recent study found that calorie restriction
    enhances respiration, but mercola says:

    "A low metabolism is ideal for long life and good health. A high metabolism excites hormones in
    the body that eventually cause age-related diseases."
    mercola.comcarbohydrates age.htm

    He also claims (at that web address) that fruit is not healthy because: "Fructose causes insulin
    resistance as proven in scientific tests. Fructose is highly addictive and most people simply
    refuse to give up fruit no matter how sick they become. This is identical to lung cancer patients
    who continue to smoke cigarettes." Too silly to warrant a response.

    Here is the reality, though scientists like Ray Peat have been saying similar things for years:

    "Cold Spring Harbor Laboratory Date: 2004-01-01 MIT Helps Unlock Life-extending Secrets Of Calorie
    Restriction CAMBRIDGE, Mass. -- Shedding light on why drastically restricting calorie intake
    prolongs life span in some organisms, MIT researchers report in the Jan. 1 issue of Genes &
    Development that lowering the level of a common coenzyme activates an anti-aging gene in yeast.
    Calorie restriction extends life span in a wide spectrum of organisms, and has been shown to delay
    the onset or reduce the incidence of many age-related diseases, including cancer and diabetes. No
    one is sure why it works. MIT Biology Professor Leonard P. Guarente discovered in 2000 that
    calorie restriction activates the silenced information regulator (SIR2) gene, which has the
    apparent ability to slow aging during the low-calorie diet. This gene makes a protein called Sir2,
    which is normally activated by the coenzyme molecule NAD. Guarente has shown that SIR2 is
    integrally tied to extending life span in yeast and in the roundworm. Humans carry a similar gene.
    This latest study probes how Sir2 is activated by calorie restriction. The authors report that a
    coenzyme related to NAD, called NADH (nicotinamide adenine dinucleotide) inhibits Sir2 by blocking
    the action of NAD. During calorie restriction, levels of NADH decline in cells. This decrease in
    NADH allows NAD to better activate Sir2 and thereby extend life span. "These findings provide a
    simple model for activation of Sir2 and extension of life span by calorie restriction," the
    authors write. "Our findings suggest that the NAD/NADH ratio can serve a critical regulatory
    function, determining the life span of yeast mother cells. A reduction in this nucleotide
    activates Sir2 to extend the life span in calorie restriction." In previous research, Guarente
    found that rather than a slower metabolism leading to a slower rate of respiration, it turns out
    that respiration in yeast cells under calorie restriction goes up, not down. "A high respiration
    rate is intimately connected with calorie restriction in yeast," he said. "A high respiration rate
    activates SIR2. When respiration goes up, NADH goes down and SIR2 goes up. When SIR2 goes up,
    longevity happens." NADH, a coenzyme or enzyme helper, is present in all living cells. (An enzyme
    is a protein that works like a catalyst in the body to prompt chemical changes; for instance,
    turning food into energy.) NADH, an activated form of the B vitamin niacin, helps produce energy
    through a series of chemical reactions in the cell. In cells, NADH stimulates the production of
    ATP (adenosine triphosphate), a compound that represents chemical energy in cells. The more NADH a
    cell has, the more stored energy it has. It remains to be seen whether these findings about yeast
    and NADH will relate to the extension of life span in mammals by calorie restriction. "

Active in the last 60 minutes

Active in this thread

0 users · 0 guests ·0 bots ·0 total

No signed-in users are active right now.

No known search crawlers active right now.