Cycling Equipment · Public discussion

Stiffness Issue

Started by spinner32 · · Last activity · 9 posts · 1,796 views

This thread is locked and is currently read-only.

Thread navigation

Jump through the discussion

Go to the original post, the replies on this page, or the latest preserved contribution.

Thread details

What we know about this thread

Original section
Cycling Equipment
Published
3 July 2008
Last activity
4 July 2008
Original author
spinner32
Posts
9
Discussion status
Public discussion
Total views
1,796
Views / 30 days
0

The navigation and discussion metadata provide context. Posts remain in their original chronological order.

Showing posts 1–9 of 9
Posts remain in their original chronological order.

Text size
  1. Ok, so last summer I bought a 2007 Specialized Tarmac Pro. Here are the specs:

    Fact 8 Carbon Stem/Handlebars/Frame
    DA Shifters/Rear Der.
    Ultegra Front Der.
    FSA K-Force Crankset
    FSA Mega-Exo BB
    Mavic Ksyrium Elite Wheelset

    I've been riding it for about half of the past year... and lately, it seems to have no "jump" whatsoever. When I initially bought it, the bike seemed stiffer than anything else on the market, but now feels completely dead when I go to ramp up in a sprint or climb. I'm wondering where the sudden "softness" in it is coming from - it seriously feels like a noodle under me when I really push it (and I'm not a heavy rider at 142 lb).
    I've read that the cranks and BB are suspect, as well as the wheels. I'm also curious as to how much this has to do with the frame/stem/handlebars. Basically - which components should I be looking at first? (Obviously, beyond the rider [img]cyclingforums.comtongue.gif[/img])

    Thanks

  2. spinner32 said:

    Ok, so last summer I bought a 2007 Specialized Tarmac Pro. Here are the specs:

    Fact 8 Carbon Stem/Handlebars/Frame
    DA Shifters/Rear Der.
    Ultegra Front Der.
    FSA K-Force Crankset
    FSA Mega-Exo BB
    Mavic Ksyrium Elite Wheelset

    I've been riding it for about half of the past year... and lately, it seems to have no "jump" whatsoever. When I initially bought it, the bike seemed stiffer than anything else on the market, but now feels completely dead when I go to ramp up in a sprint or climb. I'm wondering where the sudden "softness" in it is coming from - it seriously feels like a noodle under me when I really push it (and I'm not a heavy rider at 142 lb).
    I've read that the cranks and BB are suspect, as well as the wheels. I'm also curious as to how much this has to do with the frame/stem/handlebars. Basically - which components should I be looking at first? (Obviously, beyond the rider [img]cyclingforums.comtongue.gif[/img])

    Thanks

    You should be looking at the rider. There has yet to be any study that indicates that frame stiffness correlates in any way with performance. Frame stiffness does impact handling, but it is not a source of any energy losses that would decrease performance in any substantive way.

  3. I had the same feeling about my CAAD9 after I took about 2 months off to let some knee pain subside, and during which I time I spent lots of time in the weightroom. Turns out that I had gained ~12 pounds in that time off.

    I second Alienator - it's the rider, not the bike.

  4. saintsfan342000 said:

    I had the same feeling about my CAAD9 after I took about 2 months off to let some knee pain subside, and during which I time I spent lots of time in the weightroom. Turns out that I had gained ~12 pounds in that time off.

    I second Alienator - it's the rider, not the bike.

    Times 3..has your training program changed? Overtired, not been on the bike, weight changes??

  5. spinner32 said:

    I've read that the cranks and BB are suspect, as well as the wheels. I'm also curious as to how much this has to do with the frame/stem/handlebars. Basically - which components should I be looking at first? (Obviously, beyond the rider [img]cyclingforums.comtongue.gif[/img])

    To actually answer your query:

    • Swap your rear wheel for another one, first -- use a traditional, 32-spoke wheel as a benchmark -- and, see if that makes any difference.

    Is your rear wheel TRUE?

    • Check things like your brake pads possibly rubbing against the rim IF you run them close to the brake surface ... especially, if you STAND on the pedals when you want the bike to "jump" ...

    Also, check your cranks BB bearings ... slip the chain OFF, and see if the crank spins smoothly without binding (of course, this will be more meaningful IF you know how freely/smoothly the crank spun a year ago).

    Check your OTHER bearings (e.g., pulley bearings) ... I've seen pulleys which were gunked with ProLink/etc. THAT, alone, won't cause the problem, but it may be symptomatic of poor maintenance which subsequently needs to be attended to.

  6. alfeng said:

    To actually answer your query:

    • Swap your rear wheel for another one, first -- use a traditional, 32-spoke wheel as a benchmark -- and, see if that makes any difference.

    Is your rear wheel TRUE?

    • Check things like your brake pads possibly rubbing against the rim IF you run them close to the brake surface ... especially, if you STAND on the pedals when you want the bike to "jump" ...

    Also, check your cranks BB bearings ... slip the chain OFF, and see if the crank spins smoothly without binding (of course, this will be more meaningful IF you know how freely/smoothly the crank spun a year ago).

    Check your OTHER bearings (e.g., pulley bearings) ... I've seen pulleys which were gunked with ProLink/etc. THAT, alone, won't cause the problem, but it may be symptomatic of poor maintenance which subsequently needs to be attended to.


    I agree and would add that some rear wheels "drift" from being centered as the left side spokes bed in further (often further than drive side spokes). So besides checking for true, check for centering and proper spoke tension.

  7. spinner32 said:

    Ok, so last summer I bought a 2007 Specialized Tarmac Pro. Here are the specs:.......

    it's slightly possible that your spokes have lost some tension, but if this was so, you'd probably see the wheels out of true. Also, Damon Rinard found in his delfection test that loose spokes make hardly any difference to lateral rigidity, unless the spokes are almost totally slack:
    http://www.sheldonbrown.com/rinard/wheel/index.htm

  8. spinner32 said:

    Ok, so last summer........

    My two-bit theory is that you've become complacent with the initally noticeable (well, preceived, at least) benefits of your new bike, so it no longer blows your socks off.

    When I first got my alu Soloist, it felt like an absolute rocket, but now, about a year later, it's bit ho-hum, and actually feels slow on some days.

  9. Thanks for the replies. I have read plenty about the frame stiffness vs. efficiency controversy, and understand that it doesn't truly reduce your power on the bike. The difference is simply in how it feels now, and in comparison with other bikes recently (many of which I compared against when buying it initially), it just doesn't have any "go."
    I'm going to give the wheel swap a try, as I always keep my wheels pretty true (they weren't off when I checked them yesterday). Training/weight is the same. Hopefully it's just my mind playing tricks on me - I wouldn't give the bike up in a million years for its handling characteristics or fit. Thanks again for the input.

Active in the last 60 minutes

Active in this thread

0 users · 0 guests ·0 bots ·0 total

No signed-in users are active right now.

No known search crawlers active right now.