Uncomfortable saddle?

Hi~ I had saddle problems for awhile and what I did was go to the LBS and they had me sit on this kinda gel thing to determine a measurement for my "Sits Bone", I bought the saddle that they reccomended and the severe sore ass problem almost completely went away.
Good Luck!

Seeking help from your LBS is good advice. Not just for width of the seat, but adjustment as well.

Have you tried lowering the nose of the seat just a bit? For some reason, most new riders have the nose too high, even though that puts your weight on areas not meant to support it. You don't want to have it so steep you are sliding off the seat, or holding yourself back with rigid arms.

And don't judge a seat by its padding: some of the very thin seats have a good deal of flex, making them far more comfortable than than cushy looking seats.

the seat that came with my specialized Allez triple isnt too bad, once i adjusted it. I have the top of the seat parallel to the ground when the wheels are both on level ground. AND, I wear cycling shorts...they help out more than i ever thought possible 🙂 I was looking into a new seat untill i bought the shorts, i ride 16 miles and my rear is feeling just fine. also, make sure you sitting on your SIT bones, not just sitting, it makes a huge difference as well.

I always find bigger saddles with more padding to be less comfortable, and Im not small to say the least. remember you want a narrow saddle otherwise youll experience more inner thigh chaffing ...

Too much padding is bad - it squishes you in places you shouldn't be squished, if you know what I mean.

I went through four saddles before I found the one I liked - Fizik Aliante. It has almost no padding on it. But I can ride it for hours without discomfort.

Saddle discomfort is usually an adjustment issue, takes some time, everyone is different. Agreed, the less padding the better. You don't want to be sitting on a big ole pillow. Gimme a flat razor blade saddle anyday, good for 7, 8 hours.

It's vital to adjust your bike to fit your body from the start if you want to keep appropriate alignment and avoid physical difficulties. This will also help you stay comfortable during your bike ride. Setting your bike seat to the same height as your hip bones is a good idea.

It sounds like you're dealing with some discomfort on your rides, and I can definitely empathize with that. Saddle choice is a very personal thing, and what works for one person might not work for another. Have you considered trying a saddle with a cut-out or a pressure relief channel? It might help alleviate some of the pressure you're feeling in the middle of the saddle.

In general, it's important to make sure your saddle height and position are adjusted correctly. If your saddle is too high or too low, it can cause discomfort and even lead to injuries over time. It might be worth visiting a local bike shop to get a professional bike fit, which can help ensure that your bike is set up correctly for your body.

As for your current saddle, it's possible that the padding is just not sufficient for your needs. However, it's also possible that the saddle is simply not the right shape for your body. Everyone's sit bones are different, and some saddles are better suited to certain shapes and sizes than others.

Overall, my advice would be to keep experimenting with different saddles until you find one that works for you. Don't be afraid to try different shapes, sizes, and amounts of padding. And if you're still having trouble, consider getting a professional bike fit. It might be the best investment you ever make in your cycling journey!