General fitness, health and nutrition · Public discussion

Three bean salad

Started by Nancy Young · · Last activity · 27 posts · 255 views

This thread is locked and is currently read-only.

Thread navigation

Jump through the discussion

Go to the original post, the replies on this page, or the latest preserved contribution.

Thread details

What we know about this thread

Original section
General fitness, health and nutrition
Published
2 July 2007
Last activity
3 July 2007
Original author
Nancy Young
Posts
27
Discussion status
Public discussion
Total views
255
Views / 30 days
0

The navigation and discussion metadata provide context. Posts remain in their original chronological order.

Showing posts 1–20 of 27
Posts remain in their original chronological order.

Text size
  1. I know. Three bean salad is old news to everyone. I have never
    made it because it doesn't particularly appeal to me. But, we went
    to my brother's place yesterday and his wife made some and it was
    very good. It wasn't actually 3 bean ... more like 5 bean.

    How she described the recipe, it looked a lot like this one, except
    she didn't mention sugar. It sure didn't need it, and she cooks pretty
    healthfully so I doubt it was in there. Just curious if this is a typical
    recipe and what's up with the sugar:

    http://www.elise.com/recipes/archives/001911three_bean_salad.php

    3-bean salad is one of those quintessential American summer picnic foods.
    It's usually

    made with canned green beans instead of the cannellini white beans I'm using
    here. But

    I really don't care for canned green beans, so cannellini it is. Also of
    note is that

    three bean salad traditionally has a dressing comprised of vinegar, oil and
    sugar.

    The sugar is important. I tried making this salad without out sugar and it
    just didn't work.

    1 15-oz can cannellini beans, rinsed and drained
    1 15-oz can kidney beans, rinsed and drained
    1 15-oz can garbanzo beans, rinsed and drained
    2 celery stalks, chopped fine
    1/2 red onion, chopped fine
    1 cup fresh, finely chopped flat-leaf parsley
    1 Tbsp fresh finely chopped rosemary

    1/3 cup apple cider vinegar
    1/3 cup granulated sugar
    1/4 cup olive oil
    1 1/2 teaspoons salt
    1/4 teaspoon black pepper

    1 In a large bowl, mix the beans, celery, onion, parsley and rosemary.

    2 In a separate small bowl, whisk together the vinegar, sugar, olive oil,
    salt, and pepper. Add the dressing to the beans. Toss to coat.

    3 Chill beans in the refrigerator for several hours, to allow the beans to
    soak up the flavor of the dressing.

    Serves 4 to 8.

  2. Nancy Young said:

    I know. Three bean salad is old news to everyone. I have never
    made it because it doesn't particularly appeal to me. But, we went
    to my brother's place yesterday and his wife made some and it was
    very good. It wasn't actually 3 bean ... more like 5 bean.

    How she described the recipe, it looked a lot like this one, except
    she didn't mention sugar. It sure didn't need it, and she cooks pretty
    healthfully so I doubt it was in there. Just curious if this is a typical
    recipe and what's up with the sugar:

    http://www.elise.com/recipes/archives/001911three_bean_salad.php

    3-bean salad is one of those quintessential American summer picnic foods.
    It's usually

    made with canned green beans instead of the cannellini white beans I'm using
    here. But

    I really don't care for canned green beans, so cannellini it is. Also of
    note is that

    three bean salad traditionally has a dressing comprised of vinegar, oil and
    sugar.

    The sugar is important. I tried making this salad without out sugar and it
    just didn't work.

    1 15-oz can cannellini beans, rinsed and drained
    1 15-oz can kidney beans, rinsed and drained
    1 15-oz can garbanzo beans, rinsed and drained
    2 celery stalks, chopped fine
    1/2 red onion, chopped fine
    1 cup fresh, finely chopped flat-leaf parsley
    1 Tbsp fresh finely chopped rosemary

    1/3 cup apple cider vinegar
    1/3 cup granulated sugar
    1/4 cup olive oil
    1 1/2 teaspoons salt
    1/4 teaspoon black pepper

    1 In a large bowl, mix the beans, celery, onion, parsley and rosemary.

    2 In a separate small bowl, whisk together the vinegar, sugar, olive oil,
    salt, and pepper. Add the dressing to the beans. Toss to coat.

    3 Chill beans in the refrigerator for several hours, to allow the beans to
    soak up the flavor of the dressing.

    Serves 4 to 8.


    My version would be leaving out the celery (sounds like something to try
    though) using more onion (maybe a mix of red and Vidalia), no added salt
    (canned beans have plenty) and just a half teaspoon of sugar and a
    squeeze of citrus. The beans can vary with little change in result so
    other bean combinations will work.

  3. "George" <[email hidden]> wrote

    Quoted message said:

    Nancy Young wrote:

    Quoted message said:
    Quoted message said:

    How she described the recipe, it looked a lot like this one, except
    she didn't mention sugar. It sure didn't need it, and she cooks pretty
    healthfully so I doubt it was in there. Just curious if this is a
    typical
    recipe and what's up with the sugar:

    http://www.elise.com/recipes/archives/001911three_bean_salad.php

    Quoted message said:

    My version would be leaving out the celery (sounds like something to try
    though)

    She did have celery in there. It was minced pretty fine if I'm not
    mistaken.

    Quoted message said:

    using more onion (maybe a mix of red and Vidalia), no added salt (canned
    beans have plenty)

    Good, I'll add that last if it's even needed.

    Quoted message said:

    and just a half teaspoon of sugar and a squeeze of citrus.

    Great idea. Thanks for all the ideas.

    nancy

  4. "Nancy Young" <[email hidden]> wrote in
    news:[email hidden]:

    Quoted message said:

    I know. Three bean salad is old news to everyone. I have never
    made it because it doesn't particularly appeal to me. But, we went
    to my brother's place yesterday and his wife made some and it was
    very good. It wasn't actually 3 bean ... more like 5 bean.

    How she described the recipe, it looked a lot like this one, except
    she didn't mention sugar. It sure didn't need it, and she cooks
    pretty healthfully so I doubt it was in there. Just curious if this
    is a typical recipe and what's up with the sugar:

    http://www.elise.com/recipes/archives/001911three_bean_salad.php

    3-bean salad is one of those quintessential American summer picnic
    foods. It's usually

    made with canned green beans instead of the cannellini white beans I'm
    using here. But

    I really don't care for canned green beans, so cannellini it is. Also
    of note is that

    three bean salad traditionally has a dressing comprised of vinegar,
    oil and sugar.

    The sugar is important. I tried making this salad without out sugar
    and it just didn't work.

    1 15-oz can cannellini beans, rinsed and drained
    1 15-oz can kidney beans, rinsed and drained
    1 15-oz can garbanzo beans, rinsed and drained
    2 celery stalks, chopped fine
    1/2 red onion, chopped fine
    1 cup fresh, finely chopped flat-leaf parsley
    1 Tbsp fresh finely chopped rosemary

    1/3 cup apple cider vinegar
    1/3 cup granulated sugar
    1/4 cup olive oil
    1 1/2 teaspoons salt
    1/4 teaspoon black pepper

    1 In a large bowl, mix the beans, celery, onion, parsley and rosemary.

    2 In a separate small bowl, whisk together the vinegar, sugar, olive
    oil, salt, and pepper. Add the dressing to the beans. Toss to coat.

    3 Chill beans in the refrigerator for several hours, to allow the
    beans to soak up the flavor of the dressing.

    Serves 4 to 8.

    Since the dressing on this is very similar to a cole slaw dressing. If
    you want to redice/remove sugar get ideas from other cole slaw style
    dressings.

    --

    The house of the burning beet-Alan

    It'll be a sunny day in August, when the Moon will shine that night-
    Elbonian Folklore

  5. "Nancy Young" <[email hidden]> wrote in
    news:[email hidden]:

    Quoted message said:


    "George" <[email hidden]> wrote

    Quoted message said:

    Nancy Young wrote:

    Quoted message said:
    Quoted message said:

    How she described the recipe, it looked a lot like this one, except
    she didn't mention sugar. It sure didn't need it, and she cooks
    pretty healthfully so I doubt it was in there. Just curious if this
    is a typical
    recipe and what's up with the sugar:

    http://www.elise.com/recipes/archives/001911three_bean_salad.php

    Quoted message said:

    My version would be leaving out the celery (sounds like something to
    try though)

    She did have celery in there. It was minced pretty fine if I'm not
    mistaken.

    Quoted message said:

    using more onion (maybe a mix of red and Vidalia), no added salt
    (canned beans have plenty)

    Good, I'll add that last if it's even needed.

    Quoted message said:

    and just a half teaspoon of sugar and a squeeze of citrus.

    Great idea. Thanks for all the ideas.

    nancy

    maybe some canned sweet corn would work.

    --

    The house of the burning beet-Alan

    It'll be a sunny day in August, when the Moon will shine that night-
    Elbonian Folklore

  6. "hahabogus" <[email hidden]> wrote

    Quoted message said:

    "Nancy Young" <[email hidden]> wrote

    Quoted message said:
    Quoted message said:

    How she described the recipe, it looked a lot like this one, except
    she didn't mention sugar. It sure didn't need it, and she cooks
    pretty healthfully so I doubt it was in there. Just curious if this
    is a typical recipe and what's up with the sugar:

    http://www.elise.com/recipes/archives/001911three_bean_salad.php

    Quoted message said:

    Since the dressing on this is very similar to a cole slaw dressing. If
    you want to redice/remove sugar get ideas from other cole slaw style
    dressings.

    Thanks, I didn't think of cole slaw dressing. I'll be making this salad
    in the next couple of days.

    nancy

  7. what other beans did your SIL use?
    "Nancy Young" <[email hidden]> wrote in message
    news:[email hidden]...

    Quoted message said:

    I know. Three bean salad is old news to everyone. I have never
    made it because it doesn't particularly appeal to me. But, we went
    to my brother's place yesterday and his wife made some and it was
    very good. It wasn't actually 3 bean ... more like 5 bean.

    How she described the recipe, it looked a lot like this one, except
    she didn't mention sugar. It sure didn't need it, and she cooks pretty
    healthfully so I doubt it was in there. Just curious if this is a typical
    recipe and what's up with the sugar:

    http://www.elise.com/recipes/archives/001911three_bean_salad.php

    3-bean salad is one of those quintessential American summer picnic foods.
    It's usually

    made with canned green beans instead of the cannellini white beans I'm
    using here. But

    I really don't care for canned green beans, so cannellini it is. Also of
    note is that

    three bean salad traditionally has a dressing comprised of vinegar, oil
    and sugar.

    The sugar is important. I tried making this salad without out sugar and it
    just didn't work.

    1 15-oz can cannellini beans, rinsed and drained
    1 15-oz can kidney beans, rinsed and drained
    1 15-oz can garbanzo beans, rinsed and drained
    2 celery stalks, chopped fine
    1/2 red onion, chopped fine
    1 cup fresh, finely chopped flat-leaf parsley
    1 Tbsp fresh finely chopped rosemary

    1/3 cup apple cider vinegar
    1/3 cup granulated sugar
    1/4 cup olive oil
    1 1/2 teaspoons salt
    1/4 teaspoon black pepper

    1 In a large bowl, mix the beans, celery, onion, parsley and rosemary.

    2 In a separate small bowl, whisk together the vinegar, sugar, olive oil,
    salt, and pepper. Add the dressing to the beans. Toss to coat.

    3 Chill beans in the refrigerator for several hours, to allow the beans to
    soak up the flavor of the dressing.

    Serves 4 to 8.

  8. "readandpostrosie" <[email hidden]> wrote

    Quoted message said:

    what other beans did your SIL use?

    Heh, now I have to think. Cannellini, red kidney, black, green beans.

    That might have been it. She didn't add chick peas because one of
    my brothers is very allergic to them. I'd probably add them, myself,
    because I love them.

    nancy

  9. Nancy Young said:


    Quoted message said:

    using more onion (maybe a mix of red and Vidalia), no added salt (canned
    beans have plenty)

    Good, I'll add that last if it's even needed.

    Quoted message said:

    and just a half teaspoon of sugar and a squeeze of citrus.

    Great idea. Thanks for all the ideas.

    nancy


    The citrus adds a lot and a finely minced clove of fresh garlic is also
    a good addition. Making it the day before also helps the flavors mix.

    I don't understand sugar being an issue because I use very little (for
    no other reason than I don't like sweetened salads and want to taste the
    main ingredients) and typically a few people will ask how to make the
    salad because it tastes do good.

  10. "George" <[email hidden]> wrote

    Quoted message said:

    I don't understand sugar being an issue because I use very little (for no
    other reason than I don't like sweetened salads and want to taste the main
    ingredients) and typically a few people will ask how to make the salad
    because it tastes do good.

    I'm with you there, I can't think why I'd like the salad better if
    it was sweet.

    nancy

  11. Nancy Young said:

    Heh, now I have to think. Cannellini, red kidney, black, green beans.

    That might have been it. She didn't add chick peas because one of
    my brothers is very allergic to them. I'd probably add them, myself,
    because I love them.

    Thanks for posting this new bean salad idea. I love three bean salad
    and would never think to use black beans or cannellinis... now I will.

    Karen

  12. "Karen" <[email hidden]> wrote

    Quoted message said:
    Nancy Young said:

    Heh, now I have to think. Cannellini, red kidney, black, green beans.

    That might have been it. She didn't add chick peas because one of
    my brothers is very allergic to them. I'd probably add them, myself,
    because I love them.

    Thanks for posting this new bean salad idea. I love three bean salad
    and would never think to use black beans or cannellinis... now I will.

    Oh, you're very welcome. It was an attractive salad.

    nancy

  13. Nancy Young said:

    I know. Three bean salad is old news to everyone. I have never
    made it because it doesn't particularly appeal to me. But, we went
    to my brother's place yesterday and his wife made some and it was
    very good. It wasn't actually 3 bean ... more like 5 bean.

    How she described the recipe, it looked a lot like this one, except
    she didn't mention sugar. It sure didn't need it, and she cooks pretty
    healthfully so I doubt it was in there. Just curious if this is a typical
    recipe and what's up with the sugar:

    http://www.elise.com/recipes/archives/001911three_bean_salad.php

    3-bean salad is one of those quintessential American summer picnic foods.
    It's usually

    made with canned green beans instead of the cannellini white beans I'm using
    here. But

    I really don't care for canned green beans, so cannellini it is. Also of
    note is that

    three bean salad traditionally has a dressing comprised of vinegar, oil and
    sugar.

    The sugar is important. I tried making this salad without out sugar and it
    just didn't work.

    1 15-oz can cannellini beans, rinsed and drained
    1 15-oz can kidney beans, rinsed and drained
    1 15-oz can garbanzo beans, rinsed and drained
    2 celery stalks, chopped fine
    1/2 red onion, chopped fine
    1 cup fresh, finely chopped flat-leaf parsley
    1 Tbsp fresh finely chopped rosemary

    1/3 cup apple cider vinegar
    1/3 cup granulated sugar
    1/4 cup olive oil
    1 1/2 teaspoons salt
    1/4 teaspoon black pepper

    1 In a large bowl, mix the beans, celery, onion, parsley and rosemary.

    2 In a separate small bowl, whisk together the vinegar, sugar, olive oil,
    salt, and pepper. Add the dressing to the beans. Toss to coat.

    3 Chill beans in the refrigerator for several hours, to allow the beans to
    soak up the flavor of the dressing.

    Serves 4 to 8.

    That dressing does seem excessively sweet, and sour... in fact it's
    pretty disgusting.. A bean salad can have any kind of salad
    dressing... I typically make up a vinaigrette and add fresh lemon
    juice. If you don't like canned green beans (they are kind of mushy)
    use frozen green beans, frozen niblets are nice too, so are frozen
    baby limas. I like to use the *dark* red kidney beans... use as many
    types of canned beans as you desire, I use whatever I have on hand,
    might be 5-6 kind. I add onion and celery too, but not so much as
    that recipe. I also like to add diced cukes and sliced okra when I
    have them, and minced curly leaf parsley. There are really no rules,
    so long as the predominent ingredient is beans. You can also blend
    the bean salad with pasta. Add some bacon too. There is no end to
    possibilities...

    Sheldon

  14. hahabogus said:

    "Nancy Young" <[email hidden]> wrote in
    news:[email hidden]:

    Quoted message said:


    1/3 cup apple cider vinegar
    1/3 cup granulated sugar
    1/4 cup olive oil
    1 1/2 teaspoons salt
    1/4 teaspoon black pepper

    Since the dressing on this is very similar to a cole slaw dressing. If
    you want to redice/remove sugar get ideas from other cole slaw style
    dressings.

    oil in slaw recipes makes me nervous. i guess it's there in
    mayonnaise, but still. seems like a lot of sugar, too.

    your pal,
    blake

  15. blake murphy <[email hidden]> wrote in
    news:[email hidden]:

    Quoted message said:

    oil in slaw recipes makes me nervous. i guess it's there in
    mayonnaise, but still. seems like a lot of sugar, too.

    Isn't there oil in most salad dressings?

    --

    The house of the burning beet-Alan

    It'll be a sunny day in August, when the Moon will shine that night-
    Elbonian Folklore

  16. Nancy Young said:

    I know. Three bean salad is old news to everyone. I have never
    made it because it doesn't particularly appeal to me.

    It is NASTY, NASTY, NASTY.

    --Bryan

  17. BOBOBOnoBO® said:
    Nancy Young said:

    I know. Three bean salad is old news to everyone. I have never
    made it because it doesn't particularly appeal to me.

    It is NASTY, NASTY, NASTY.

    --Bryan

    Quoted message said:



    It's one of those dishes that can be taken or left. Not a favorite,
    it's just 'ok.'

  18. On Mon, 2 Jul 2007 09:44:57 -0400, "Nancy Young" <[email hidden]>

    Quoted message said:

    I know. Three bean salad is old news to everyone. I have never
    made it because it doesn't particularly appeal to me. But, we went
    to my brother's place yesterday and his wife made some and it was
    very good. It wasn't actually 3 bean ... more like 5 bean.

    I always make 5 bean salad... the other two beans are green and yellow
    (wax) beans. I love that salad. I use commercial Italian dressing
    (Good Seasons), but rosemary sounds like an interesting variation.
    Not sure if I'd like it (probably would with lamb or chicken), but
    it's worth a try sometime.

    thanks for the recipe
    🙂

    --
    See return address to reply by email

  19. "Sheldon" <[email hidden]> wrote

    Quoted message said:
    Nancy Young said:

    I know. Three bean salad is old news to everyone. I have never
    made it because it doesn't particularly appeal to me. But, we went
    to my brother's place yesterday and his wife made some and it was
    very good. It wasn't actually 3 bean ... more like 5 bean.

    Quoted message said:

    juice. If you don't like canned green beans (they are kind of mushy)
    use frozen green beans,

    I have fresh green beans, I was thinking of cooking some of them
    up. However, I also think I have some frozen, and it would be a good
    way to use them up.

    Quoted message said:

    frozen niblets are nice too, so are frozen
    baby limas.

    We were talking about limas yesterday, I don't know why people
    don't like them. Alan mentioned corn, too, that would work.

    Quoted message said:

    I like to use the *dark* red kidney beans... use as many
    types of canned beans as you desire, I use whatever I have on hand,
    might be 5-6 kind.

    I happen to have red (not the dark), garbanzo and black.
    I also have black eyed peas, but I don't know if they would
    be suitable. It just amused me to find that I actually have
    beans on hand at all, except the chick peas.

    Quoted message said:

    I add onion and celery too, but not so much as
    that recipe. I also like to add diced cukes and sliced okra when I
    have them, and minced curly leaf parsley. There are really no rules,
    so long as the predominent ingredient is beans. You can also blend
    the bean salad with pasta. Add some bacon too. There is no end to
    possibilities...

    I'll make this once and see how it goes. Seems to me a good thing
    to have in the refrigerator to pick at. There's nothing in there now,
    along those lines.

    nancy

  20. "itsjoannotjoann" <[email hidden]> wrote

    Quoted message said:

    It's one of those dishes that can be taken or left. Not a favorite,
    it's just 'ok.'

    I have similar feelings when I see tri color rotelli pasta
    salad. Put that next to the three bean salad and it's like there's
    no food there. Heh.

    nancy

Active in the last 60 minutes

Active in this thread

0 users · 0 guests ·0 bots ·0 total

No signed-in users are active right now.

No known search crawlers active right now.