What is the quality of the late 80's Sturmey Archer hubs. In
particular the alloy shelled ones of in 3 and 5 speed??? Have read a
lot it seems about how their quality was not so good in the newer
models, but when was this? 90's or ???/
Thanks
A community for cyclists, gear, training and racing.
Cycling Equipment · Public discussion
This thread is locked and is currently read-only.
Thread details
The navigation and discussion metadata provide context. Posts remain in their original chronological order.
What is the quality of the late 80's Sturmey Archer hubs. In
particular the alloy shelled ones of in 3 and 5 speed??? Have read a
lot it seems about how their quality was not so good in the newer
models, but when was this? 90's or ???/
Thanks
Quoted message said:What is the quality of the late 80's Sturmey Archer hubs. In
particular the alloy shelled ones of in 3 and 5 speed??? Have read a
lot it seems about how their quality was not so good in the newer
models, but when was this? 90's or ???/
No quality issues I have ever seen with any era of AW, FW[*].
Some late S5 control levers stink. Wait, all S5 control levers stink.
But S5 are OK with two 3 speed triggers. Early 3CB models (TCW series)
have no brake when the cable is kinked and scrambled into the neutral
between 2d & 3d gear. The 'improved' S3C is kinda klutzy compared to the
perfectly fine Shimano SG3-CB gearbox.
Some old grumpy types will wax nostalgic about British lathe-turned
parts versus modern diecast steel bits inside but in practice there's no
wear rate or 'performance' difference.
[*] Jobst notes the inherent oil bleed though Sturmey ball cup threads
and Sturmey's design error which lifts the clutch up from high to
neutral with sustained and constant pedal pressure.
--
Andrew Muzi
www.yellowjersey.org
Open every day since 1 April, 1971
A Muzi said:Quoted message said:What is the quality of the late 80's Sturmey Archer hubs. In
particular the alloy shelled ones of in 3 and 5 speed??? Have read a
lot it seems about how their quality was not so good in the newer
models, but when was this? 90's or ???/No quality issues I have ever seen with any era of AW, FW[*].
Some late S5 control levers stink. Wait, all S5 control levers stink.
But S5 are OK with two 3 speed triggers. Early 3CB models (TCW series)
have no brake when the cable is kinked and scrambled into the neutral
between 2d & 3d gear. The 'improved' S3C is kinda klutzy compared to the
perfectly fine Shimano SG3-CB gearbox.Some old grumpy types will wax nostalgic about British lathe-turned
parts versus modern diecast steel bits inside but in practice there's no
wear rate or 'performance' difference.[*] Jobst notes the inherent oil bleed though Sturmey ball cup threads
and Sturmey's design error which lifts the clutch up from high to
neutral with sustained and constant pedal pressure.
--
Andrew Muziwww.yellowjersey.org
Open every day since 1 April, 1971
The one that I was looking at is an alloy shelled 5 speed. It has the
single lever shifter with 2 cables.
I am assuming that this will be able to be retro fitted with 2- 3
speed triggers. Is this correct for a 2 cable unit ?
Thanks
Robert
Active in the last 60 minutes
0 users · 0 guests ·0 bots ·0 total
No signed-in users are active right now.
No known search crawlers active right now.