Australia and New Zealand · Public discussion

Better Road Signs or NO Road Signs

Started by rooman · · Last activity · 41 posts · 2,273 views

This thread is locked and is currently read-only.

Thread navigation

Jump through the discussion

Go to the original post, the replies on this page, or the latest preserved contribution.

Thread details

What we know about this thread

Original section
Australia and New Zealand
Published
23 April 2007
Last activity
25 April 2007
Original author
rooman
Posts
41
Discussion status
Public discussion
Total views
2,273
Views / 30 days
0

The navigation and discussion metadata provide context. Posts remain in their original chronological order.

Showing posts 1–20 of 41
Posts remain in their original chronological order.

Text size
  1. I've long believed road users would be better drivers/riders/pedestrians if they had to watch out for road conditions and didnt get "comfort" or "courage"from road signs (which encouraged many to drive on or above the limit).

    I feel bike riders fair best on the road and not on marked paths and bike lanes and road signs lull many into a false sense of security.

    So its interesting to hear the news from Holland.
    (courtesy RACV- RoyalAuto April07)

    A town which removed ALL its road signs is claiming a 10% drop in traffic casualties and a reduction in average speeds. The council in Makkinga removed all road markings and signs three years ago and a neighbouring town followed suit, but using different coloured road surfaces to guide traffic.

    European road saftey experts say the success of the move can be put down to "unsafe safety": because the absence of signs means drivers are unsure where to drive, they become more cautious.

  2. rooman said:


    A town which removed ALL its road signs is claiming a 10% drop in traffic casualties and a reduction in average speeds. The council in Makkinga removed all road markings and signs three years ago and a neighbouring town followed suit, but using different coloured road surfaces to guide traffic.

    European road saftey experts say the success of the move can be put down to "unsafe safety": because the absence of signs means drivers are unsure where to drive, they become more cautious.

    The human mind in all its glory..... I guess the only concern I would have with regards to Cyclists is Europeans treat cyclists differently than in Australia, in Europe they are not considered Moving Targets.

    Makes sense, but would it work over here and where would you trial it ? Seems like common sense and the sort of thing that works, which means there is no chance of it being used in Australia.

  3. On Apr 23, 11:13 am, MikeyOz <MikeyOz.2pg...@no-

    mx.forums.cyclingforums.com said:
    rooman said:

    -A town which removed ALL its road signs is claiming a 10% drop in
    traffic casualties and a reduction in average speeds. The council in
    Makkinga removed all road markings and signs three years ago and a
    neighbouring town followed suit, but using different coloured road
    surfaces to guide traffic.-

    Quoted message said:

    -European road saftey experts say the success of the move can be put
    down to "unsafe safety": because the absence of signs means drivers
    are unsure where to drive, they become more cautious-.

    The human mind in all its glory..... I guess the only concern I would
    have with regards to Cyclists is Europeans treat cyclists differently
    than in Australia, in Europe they are not considered Moving Targets.

    Makes sense, but would it work over here and where would you trial it ?
    Seems like common sense and the sort of thing that works, which means
    there is no chance of it being used in Australia.

    Apart from Mikey's cynicism (I don't feel like a moving target when I
    ride), I wonder how well that sort of thing scales. It's fine to have
    anarchy in small scale applications - like communism, it works in
    small communities, but may not scale all that well. Once a place gets
    big enough that not everyone knows everyone, these sorts of things can
    often fall to bits. So how well does it scale outside of small
    towns? And was the test site a small or a large town?

  4. On 2007-04-23, Bleve (aka Bruce)
    was almost, but not quite, entirely unlike tea:

    Quoted message said:

    It's fine to have anarchy in small scale applications - like
    communism, it works in small communities, but may not scale all that
    well. Once a place gets big enough that not everyone knows
    everyone, these sorts of things can often fall to bits.

    Incidentally, I never know whether to abuse someone in this town for
    nearly running me over. What if they recognise me? What if I abuse
    someone I end up working with? Will it be awkward? Argh, hard
    decisions!

    --
    TimC
    NOP NOP NOP NOP <bang> NOP NOP <bang> <ouch>
    -- TimC spinning in the corner.

  5. rooman said:

    I've long believed road users would be better drivers/riders/pedestrians if they had to watch out for road conditions and didnt get "comfort" or "courage"from road signs (which encouraged many to drive on or above the limit).

    I feel bike riders fair best on the road and not on marked paths and bike lanes and road signs lull many into a false sense of security.

    So its interesting to hear the news from Holland.
    (courtesy RACV- RoyalAuto April07)

    A town which removed ALL its road signs is claiming a 10% drop in traffic casualties and a reduction in average speeds. The council in Makkinga removed all road markings and signs three years ago and a neighbouring town followed suit, but using different coloured road surfaces to guide traffic.

    European road saftey experts say the success of the move can be put down to "unsafe safety": because the absence of signs means drivers are unsure where to drive, they become more cautious.

    I'm a supporter for no road signs.

    Over the years as people get used to having signs around (and then ignoring them) we have had to do more and more to get their attention. Brighter colours, bigger signs, more frequent signs, flashing lights on signs and the biggest joke of them all signs to tell us there is a sign coming up.

    Let people assess the conditions and drive/ride accordingly. Don't blame road conditions for crashes. If the road is poor, drive more slowly.

  6. In aus.bicycle on Mon, 23 Apr 2007 12:10:53 +1000

    mitosis said:


    Over the years as people get used to having signs around (and then
    ignoring them) we have had to do more and more to get their attention.
    Brighter colours, bigger signs, more frequent signs, flashing lights on
    signs and the biggest joke of them all signs to tell us there is a sign
    coming up.

    Umm.. so what's the difference between signs being ignored and no
    signs?

    Everyone who is ignoring a sign is using their own judgement....

    Zebee

  7. On Apr 23, 12:10 pm, mitosis <mitosis.2ph...@no-

    mx.forums.cyclingforums.com said:
    rooman said:

    I've long believed road users would be better drivers/riders/pedestrians
    if they had to watch out for road conditions and didnt get "comfort" or
    "courage"from road signs (which encouraged many to drive on or above
    the limit).

    Quoted message said:

    I feel bike riders fair best on the road and not on marked paths and
    bike lanes and road signs lull many into a false sense of security.

    Quoted message said:

    So its interesting to hear the news from Holland.
    (-courtesy- RACV- *RoyalAuto* April07)

    Quoted message said:

    -A town which removed ALL its road signs is claiming a 10% drop in
    traffic casualties and a reduction in average speeds. The council in
    Makkinga removed all road markings and signs three years ago and a
    neighbouring town followed suit, but using different coloured road
    surfaces to guide traffic.-

    Quoted message said:

    -European road saftey experts say the success of the move can be put
    down to "unsafe safety": because the absence of signs means drivers
    are unsure where to drive, they become more cautious-.

    I'm a supporter for no road signs.

    Over the years as people get used to having signs around (and then
    ignoring them) we have had to do more and more to get their attention.
    Brighter colours, bigger signs, more frequent signs, flashing lights on
    signs and the biggest joke of them all signs to tell us there is a sign
    coming up.

    Let people assess the conditions and drive/ride accordingly. Don't
    blame road conditions for crashes. If the road is poor, drive more
    slowly.

    And world peace!

  8. Zebee Johnstone said:

    In aus.bicycle on Mon, 23 Apr 2007 12:10:53 +1000

    mitosis said:


    Over the years as people get used to having signs around (and then
    ignoring them) we have had to do more and more to get their attention.
    Brighter colours, bigger signs, more frequent signs, flashing lights on
    signs and the biggest joke of them all signs to tell us there is a sign
    coming up.

    Umm.. so what's the difference between signs being ignored and no
    signs?

    Everyone who is ignoring a sign is using their own judgement....

    Zebee


    Maybe, or zombie drivers are so reassured by the presence of signs, as they are by the technology that they are assured will prevent them crashing or getting injured, that they feel infallible and therefore don't assess the conditions. Everyone who crashes wants to blame someone else.

    World peace is another thread.

  9. Bleve said:

    Apart from Mikey's cynicism (I don't feel like a moving target when I
    ride)

    You should speed up a bit then. Do you know anyone who could give you some
    training tips?

    --
    Dave Hughes | [email hidden]
    "When you need a helpline for breakfast cereals, it's time to start
    thinking about tearing down civilisation and giving the ants a go"
    - Chris King

  10. Dave said:
    Bleve said:

    Apart from Mikey's cynicism (I don't feel like a moving target when I
    ride)

    You should speed up a bit then. Do you know anyone who could give you some
    training tips?

    I've started taking Oxy Shots and I am buying a Cervello Soloist, and
    two disk wheels and some aerobars, will that help?

  11. quote='Bleve'On Apr 23 said:
    Bleve said:

    Apart from Mikey's cynicism (I don't feel like a moving target when I
    ride)

    You should speed up a bit then. Do you know anyone who could give you some
    training tips?

    I've started taking Oxy Shots and I am buying a Cervello Soloist, and
    two disk wheels and some aerobars, will that help?[/QUOTE]

    you can borrow my aero helmet if you like, Bleve. I have a book somewhere on training too - you can borrow it if you like :p

  12. quote='Dave'On Sun said:

    Apart from Mikey's cynicism (I don't feel like a moving target when I
    ride)

    You should speed up a bit then. Do you know anyone who could give you some
    training tips?
    [/QUOTE]

    I am not being cynical, I am expressing what it feels like when I ride, just because you don't does not mean other people don't.

    I am definately a supporter for no signs but then what happens is something will happen, and the person will claim, well there was no sign, so I did not know I was doing anything wrong. Common sense has no place in todays society, lawyers have made sure of that, thats not cynical, that is what I mean't by it won't happen in Australia.

    I am going to be of the mentality these days that I am a moving target, hopefully will aid in survival on the roads.

    This mornings stroll was pretty good though, even had a driver wait for me when he could have gone, a thank you wave greeted him.

  13. Bleve said:


    I've started taking Oxy Shots and I am buying a Cervello Soloist, and
    two disk wheels and some aerobars, will that help?

    Nope, you still need brains, so just forget it :p

  14. On Apr 23, 2:47 pm, MikeyOz <MikeyOz.2ph...@no-

    mx.forums.cyclingforums.com said:
    Dave said:

    On Sun, 22 Apr 2007 18:44:22 -0700, Bleve wrote:

    Quoted message said:
    Quoted message said:

    Apart from Mikey's cynicism (I don't feel like a moving target when


    I

    Quoted message said:

    ride)

    Quoted message said:

    You should speed up a bit then. Do you know anyone who could give you
    some
    training tips?

    I am not being cynical, I am expressing what it feels like when I ride,
    just because you don't does not mean other people don't.

    And then, you write a very cynical appraisal of "the system"
    immediately afterwards!

    Quoted message said:

    I am definately a supporter for no signs but then what happens is
    something will happen, and the person will claim, well there was no
    sign, so I did not know I was doing anything wrong. Common sense has
    no place in todays society, lawyers have made sure of that, thats not
    cynical, that is what I mean't by it won't happen in Australia.

    Err, yes it is, Mikey. That's a textbook example. There's probably
    some good reasons for why it hasn't been tried (although I imagine in
    the dim dark days before the Internet there were plenty of places
    around Australia that had sparse road signs, so perhaps it has been
    done before?), or maybe there isn't good reasons, but "it's all the
    fault of the lawyers"?

    Quoted message said:

    I am going to be of the mentality these days that I am a moving target,
    hopefully will aid in survival on the roads.

    That's one (unfortunate, but understandable) strategy. What works for
    me is

    "I'm a vehicle, with as much right to use the road as anyone else, I'm
    also less visible and have to ride defensively and predictably and be
    where other road users are looking for me, attempting to predict and
    anticipate the actions of drivers and other riders, they're not out to
    get me, but they're not generally looking out for me, as just like me,
    they are looking out for themselves first".

    If "they're all out to kill me" works for you, then that's good, but
    it does seem pretty sad, and must be very stressful. That would ruin
    my pleasure in riding, if I felt like that all the time.

  15. rooman said:

    I've long believed road users would be better drivers/riders/pedestrians if they had to watch out for road conditions and didnt get "comfort" or "courage"from road signs (which encouraged many to drive on or above the limit).

    I feel bike riders fair best on the road and not on marked paths and bike lanes and road signs lull many into a false sense of security.

    So its interesting to hear the news from Holland.
    (courtesy RACV- RoyalAuto April07)

    A town which removed ALL its road signs is claiming a 10% drop in traffic casualties and a reduction in average speeds. The council in Makkinga removed all road markings and signs three years ago and a neighbouring town followed suit, but using different coloured road surfaces to guide traffic.

    European road saftey experts say the success of the move can be put down to "unsafe safety": because the absence of signs means drivers are unsure where to drive, they become more cautious.

    I remember seeing a tv programme about (presumably) this place. It seemed to work like a charm. Even their busiest intersections were dramatically calmed. Accident rates plummented to near zero and av speeds went down too.

    The comment posted here that Aust has too many signs that seem to get bigger and flashier is so true. Still, people ignore them. The standard excuse for disobeying school zone 40 km/h is either a) "me didn't know me was in da school zone." (despite huge signs) or b) "me didn't knows it was school time" (because they are just so random).

    Now, many schools have HUGE signs that flash red and orange at the applicable times and still nearly everyone speeds along.

    There are far too many signs that detract from an expectation of common sense and personal responsibility.

    Scotty

  16. scotty72 said:

    I remember seeing a tv programme about (presumably) this place. It seemed to work like a charm. Even their busiest intersections were dramatically calmed. Accident rates plummented to near zero and av speeds went down too.

    The comment posted here that Aust has too many signs that seem to get bigger and flashier is so true. Still, people ignore them. The standard excuse for disobeying school zone 40 km/h is either a) "me didn't know me was in da school zone." (despite huge signs) or b) "me didn't knows it was school time" (because they are just so random).

    Now, many schools have HUGE signs that flash red and orange at the applicable times and still nearly everyone speeds along.

    There are far too many signs that detract from an expectation of common sense and personal responsibility.

    Scotty

    the best (in terms of fellow driver courtesy & politeness, and safety) drive home in peak hour traffic, was recently (Feb???) when large sections of Melbourne blacked out and traffic lights were out all over the place. I was dreading the drive home, but instead, traffic was calm and sensible.

  17. In aus.bicycle on 22 Apr 2007 22:21:15 -0700

    Bleve said:

    "I'm a vehicle, with as much right to use the road as anyone else, I'm
    also less visible and have to ride defensively and predictably and be
    where other road users are looking for me, attempting to predict and
    anticipate the actions of drivers and other riders, they're not out to
    get me, but they're not generally looking out for me, as just like me,
    they are looking out for themselves first".

    Powered or unpowered, 2 wheels or 4, works for me.

    Quoted message said:


    If "they're all out to kill me" works for you, then that's good, but
    it does seem pretty sad, and must be very stressful. That would ruin
    my pleasure in riding, if I felt like that all the time.

    I've never really understood how to put that idea into action.

    After all, if they were trying to kill me the'd have me, no question.
    I'd have to have large solid objects between every car and me all the
    time. I'd never lanesplit, and never travel beside or in any way in
    front of a car. I'd have to always give way to any vehicle so that
    they'd have to turn really sharply to get me.

    I just can't see how it's possible to do any riding if you are
    assuming they are actively trying to kill you because the
    opportunities for them doing so are legion.

    So how do people who say this is how they ride cope? How do they
    manage to always be in such a position that no car anywhere has any
    chance at all of ever hitting them (we'll presume no snipers) and
    still actually get where they are going?

    Zebee

  18. Zebee Johnstone said:

    In aus.bicycle on 22 Apr 2007 22:21:15 -0700

    Bleve said:

    "I'm a vehicle, with as much right to use the road as anyone else, I'm
    also less visible and have to ride defensively and predictably and be
    where other road users are looking for me, attempting to predict and
    anticipate the actions of drivers and other riders, they're not out to
    get me, but they're not generally looking out for me, as just like me,
    they are looking out for themselves first".

    Powered or unpowered, 2 wheels or 4, works for me.

    Quoted message said:

    If "they're all out to kill me" works for you, then that's good, but
    it does seem pretty sad, and must be very stressful. That would ruin
    my pleasure in riding, if I felt like that all the time.

    I've never really understood how to put that idea into action.

    After all, if they were trying to kill me the'd have me, no question.
    I'd have to have large solid objects between every car and me all the
    time. I'd never lanesplit, and never travel beside or in any way in
    front of a car. I'd have to always give way to any vehicle so that
    they'd have to turn really sharply to get me.

    I just can't see how it's possible to do any riding if you are
    assuming they are actively trying to kill you because the
    opportunities for them doing so are legion.

    So how do people who say this is how they ride cope? How do they
    manage to always be in such a position that no car anywhere has any
    chance at all of ever hitting them (we'll presume no snipers) and
    still actually get where they are going?

    For a short amount of time when I was learning to ride motorbikes, I
    used to feel like that (moving target etc) but I found that I was
    incredibly stressed doing so and didn't enjoy riding. Especially
    though high traffic merging areas (like the bridge across the Swan R
    in Perth that goes to Vic Park, I can't remember its name?). I'd get
    to places in a sweat with a huge sense of relief.

    After a bit of good instruction from a very experienced and clueful
    rider I did a lot of riding with, that changed into the attitude I've
    held since (as described above). Much less stressful, much more
    enjoyable. I've been in two collisions (bikes, motor and push) in my
    whole time on the road, both of which I place a significant chunk of
    responsibility for at my feet (I was tired, wasn't thinking
    properly). If I didn't enjoy riding (motor or push) I'd not do it.
    I'd walk or catch trains.

    Mikey had, if I recall correctly, a nasty prang a while back where
    some drongo turned right into him, it's quite a common collision I
    believe, and while he was unlucky to have experienced it, it's not
    that uncommon a class of accident. From a defensive riding position,
    it's interesting to ask what he (and the rest of us) can learn from
    his collision. I know I'm very wary of coming up to intersections
    with oncoming traffic where there's a chance that a driver or rider
    can turn if they haven't seen me or have misjudged my speed (or, the
    odd psycopath who just pushes because they own the road, but they're,
    IME, *very* rare). I tend, at that point, to watch oncoming traffic
    very closely, especially at night - I do my best to make some sort of
    eye contact with the driver if possible (not always possible, of
    course ... esp on country roads, like where Mikey's collision
    occurred). and if they show signs of slowing to turn I generally also
    slow down and watch them closely. If they do turn, if you're watching
    for it, you have a better chance of taking successful evasive action.
    It's only (IME) stressful when there's more than one car to keep track
    of.

    Those of you familiar with Canterbury Rd heading towards the city in
    Melbourne, coming down the hill near Mailing Rd will know the type of
    intersection where this sort of collision is quite likely to occur.
    There's *2* right turn opportunities one right behind the other, so
    one is blinded by the second if there's any traffic, and there always
    is. Despite it being a 45km/h section of road if rolling, I always
    slow down to about 30 and watch *very* closely through that
    intersection, and in 3 years of riding it most days a week, never had
    an incident of note accordingly.

    A key question to ask is "Why didn't they see me?" and "How can I
    reduce the chances of not being seen?".
    I don't think the answer is paranoia.

  19. Bleve said:


    If "they're all out to kill me" works for you, then that's good, but
    it does seem pretty sad, and must be very stressful. That would ruin
    my pleasure in riding, if I felt like that all the time.

    Just out of curiosity have you ever been cleaned up by a car while on a pushie on the road ? I am not saying because I have, I know everything, just curious if it has happened to you ? Because ever since that happened to me I have never been the same since, did I expect to be, NO, I can't help it when ever I see a car attempting to do the same thing that happend to me previously I get nervous and jittery, but its getting better.

    As for my cynical point of view, I probably am a bit cynical but living in the society we live in and having seen the things I have seen in life and also the things I have seen in my professional life, I am really not surprised.

    I did not say the Lawyers were responsible for everything, but they are definately a major part of why common sense no longer exists today, because a Lawyer somewhere is ready at the mention of money to defend someone who has clearly shown a complete lack of common sense and will usually defend the person sucessfully.

  20. "scotty72" <[email hidden]> wrote in message
    news:[email hidden]...

    Quoted message said:


    rooman said:

    I've long believed road users would be better drivers/riders/pedestrians
    if they had to watch out for road conditions and didnt get "comfort" or
    "courage"from road signs (which encouraged many to drive on or above
    the limit).

    I feel bike riders fair best on the road and not on marked paths and
    bike lanes and road signs lull many into a false sense of security.

    So its interesting to hear the news from Holland.
    (-courtesy- RACV- *RoyalAuto* April07)

    -A town which removed ALL its road signs is claiming a 10% drop in
    traffic casualties and a reduction in average speeds. The council in
    Makkinga removed all road markings and signs three years ago and a
    neighbouring town followed suit, but using different coloured road
    surfaces to guide traffic.-

    -European road saftey experts say the success of the move can be put
    down to "unsafe safety": because the absence of signs means drivers
    are unsure where to drive, they become more cautious-.I remember seeing a
    tv programme about (presumably) this place.

    Do a Google on Hans Mondeman to see stuff on the traffic engineer who is
    doing this in Holland. Or Hamilton-Baillie in UK. Eco-plan also has links to
    Mondeman, even a video of him in Groningen at http://tinyurl.com/39kzwq .

    I think it is mainly being trialled in towns or local suburban centres etc,
    not major cities, although Groningen is pop. 180,000. The Dutch have been
    doing "Woonerfen" for years, where they design or encourage local
    residential streets to be seen as backyards with gardens and chairs acting
    as traffic calming devices and no kerbs, and car drivers are expected to
    behave as visitors, who have no special right of way, as I understand it. A
    bit alien to most Aussie cities.

    Following animation shows the general idea I hope.

    http://www.hamilton-baillie.co.uk/gifs/gallery/cartoon_anim1.gif

Active in the last 60 minutes

Active in this thread

0 users · 0 guests ·0 bots ·0 total

No signed-in users are active right now.

No known search crawlers active right now.