Haven't had experience with any of the ones from Probikekit but I figure the ones which include bar end plugs, finishing tape and extra tape for brake levers good value. I recently bought Bontrager tape; not great, cheap but does the job. Had to cut it though so I had tape for the brake lever area. Nice bar end plugs though compared to my previous BBB ones.🙂
I understand that cork tapes are less durable and harder to clean. Synthetic can be easily washed with detergents and more resistant to adverse weather.
I have purchased the Cinelli cork tape from PBK, and .. its like any other cork tape. I also tried out the Ambrosio ones but they didnt give as much cushioning as the cork ones.
The elaganza ones look pretty good. Anyone tried those?
Fizik Microtex. Try and get the one with gel under it if you want comfort (comes in a big box with gel+tape) The black tape has a nice suede look. I have the silver (it is the exact shade of the SL01's paint) and it never gets dirts and doesn't wear like cork tape. It is pretty thin though (hence the gel)
I've been using Bike @ ribbon. Only because I got a box of 20 of them cheap. Sold most. Pluses and minuses - comfortable, looks good, inexpensive, stays in place well, but...too short for 44cm + bars(after sections are cut off for under the shifters) even not overlapping much. The main problem is it wears really fast. Two/three thousand kms and I have to replace it(way faster than my tyres).
I think any ol' cork tape will do the trick nicely. Whether it's hard to clean or not, I just love the feel of it. It's not so expensive that if/when you spill and scrape it up, that you can't replace it either.