General fitness, health and nutrition · Public discussion

Is butter really bad for you?

Started by mikedob · · Last activity · 40 posts · 935 views

This thread is locked and is currently read-only.

Thread navigation

Jump through the discussion

Go to the original post, the replies on this page, or the latest preserved contribution.

Thread details

What we know about this thread

Original section
General fitness, health and nutrition
Published
27 April 2006
Last activity
12 May 2006
Original author
mikedob
Posts
40
Discussion status
Public discussion
Total views
935
Views / 30 days
0

The navigation and discussion metadata provide context. Posts remain in their original chronological order.

Showing posts 1–20 of 40
Posts remain in their original chronological order.

Text size
  1. I go to a doctor who says butter is not really bad for you-- maybe he
    means in comparison
    to the usual margarine sold in stores---also that eggs are not bad for
    you --comment ??

  2. mikedob said:

    I go to a doctor who says butter is not really bad for you-- maybe he
    means in comparison
    to the usual margarine sold in stores---also that eggs are not bad for
    you --comment ??

    Real fresh butter from a healthy well fed cow is extremely healthy for
    you. Same with eggs.

    Much more healthy than the highly refined, cooked, and filtered
    vegetable oils and the highly processed margarines.

    TC

  3. Marlon Brando in /Last Tango in Paris/ managed to put a stick of butter
    to good use. But, margarine would have done just as well. 🙁

  4. "mikedob" <[email hidden]> wrote in message
    news:[email hidden]...

    Quoted message said:

    I go to a doctor who says butter is not really bad for you-- maybe he
    means in comparison
    to the usual margarine sold in stores---also that eggs are not bad for
    you --comment ??

    Are atheroschlerotic plaques really bad for you?

    You decide, it's your carotid artery.

    George

  5. See my posts to the thread entitled, "Is Coconut Oil Healthful?"

    It is true that eggs are high in cholesterol, so you need to boil them,
    which keeps the cholesterol from being oxidized. Only oxidized
    cholesterol can do you harm. It appears that the people who don't
    understand this are deficient in basic knowledge of biochemistry,
    because the evidence is there, and has been available to them for
    several years now.

  6. George Cherry wrote:
    : "mikedob" <[email hidden]> wrote in message
    : news:[email hidden]...

    :: I go to a doctor who says butter is not really bad for you-- maybe he
    :: means in comparison
    :: to the usual margarine sold in stores---also that eggs are not bad
    :: for you --comment ??
    :
    : Are atheroschlerotic plaques really bad for you?
    :
    : You decide, it's your carotid artery.

    I agree with George. Choose a good quality (soft) margarine that does not
    contain hydrogenated fats and no transfats (read the lable). You can consume
    1-4 eggs a week but preferably no more.

    --
    Juhana

  7. "Juhana Harju" <[email hidden]> wrote in message
    news:[email hidden]...

    Quoted message said:

    George Cherry wrote:
    : "mikedob" <[email hidden]> wrote in message
    : news:[email hidden]...

    :: I go to a doctor who says butter is not really bad for you-- maybe he
    :: means in comparison
    :: to the usual margarine sold in stores---also that eggs are not bad
    :: for you --comment ??
    :
    : Are atheroschlerotic plaques really bad for you?
    :
    : You decide, it's your carotid artery.

    I agree with George. Choose a good quality (soft) margarine that does not
    contain hydrogenated fats and no transfats (read the lable). You can
    consume
    1-4 eggs a week but preferably no more.

    Egg whites are great low-calorie sources of protein.
    My wife bakes pumpkin custard with egg whites. We
    give the yolks to our dogs who love them. We also
    hard boil eggs. When I eat one, I eat the white part
    and give the yolk to Greta (poodle) or Emmy (mixed-
    breed). This makes me happy and them happy. I
    eat about six egg whites a day.

    George

  8. "George Cherry" <[email hidden]> wrote in message news:[email hidden]...

    Quoted message said:


    "Juhana Harju" <[email hidden]> wrote in message
    news:[email hidden]...

    Quoted message said:

    George Cherry wrote:
    : "mikedob" <[email hidden]> wrote in message
    : news:[email hidden]...

    :: I go to a doctor who says butter is not really bad for you-- maybe he
    :: means in comparison
    :: to the usual margarine sold in stores---also that eggs are not bad
    :: for you --comment ??
    :
    : Are atheroschlerotic plaques really bad for you?
    :
    : You decide, it's your carotid artery.

    I agree with George. Choose a good quality (soft) margarine that does not
    contain hydrogenated fats and no transfats (read the lable). You can
    consume
    1-4 eggs a week but preferably no more.

    Egg whites are great low-calorie sources of protein.
    My wife bakes pumpkin custard with egg whites. We
    give the yolks to our dogs who love them. We also
    hard boil eggs. When I eat one, I eat the white part
    and give the yolk to Greta (poodle) or Emmy (mixed-
    breed). This makes me happy and them happy. I
    eat about six egg whites a day.

    How are your dogs?

    N.

  9. Butter : sturated fat

    Margarine : trans fat

    BOTH can raise total cholesterol and LDL cholesterol.

    Just try minimizing both intakes.

    Cheers,
    nina
    http://www.lipblogs.com/asweetnectarwomb/

  10. mikedob said:

    I go to a doctor who says butter is not really bad for you-- maybe he
    means in comparison
    to the usual margarine sold in stores---also that eggs are not bad for
    you --comment ??

    Butter is around 50% saturated fat so it isn't healthy although there
    are other fats that have a higher percent of saturated fats. I use some
    butter for flavor and for corn on the cob, but the two of us together
    use less than a pound a year. I don't use margarine. I do use vegetable
    oils in small amounts and find spray on canola oil a nice convenience.
    I do use sesame butter and other nut butters as a replacement for
    shortening.

    Eggs are a good source of nutrients with the whites containing no fat.
    The yolks have fat of which 40% is saturated. The yolks contain many
    vitiamins, so it is a good idea to eat a few (3-4) a week. So just
    throw away half of the yolks to keep your saturated fat and cholesterol
    down.

    Egg have a protein efficacy of 93.7%, making them one of the best
    sources of protein.

    Be sure to cook your eggs until they aren't runny to kill any
    pathogenic bacteria.

    --
    Ron

  11. "Neryl Chyphes" <[email hidden]> wrote in message
    news:[email hidden]...

    Quoted message said:


    "George Cherry" <[email hidden]> wrote in
    message news:[email hidden]...

    Quoted message said:


    "Juhana Harju" <[email hidden]> wrote in message
    news:[email hidden]...

    Quoted message said:

    George Cherry wrote:
    : "mikedob" <[email hidden]> wrote in message
    : news:[email hidden]...

    :: I go to a doctor who says butter is not really bad for you-- maybe he
    :: means in comparison
    :: to the usual margarine sold in stores---also that eggs are not bad
    :: for you --comment ??
    :
    : Are atheroschlerotic plaques really bad for you?
    :
    : You decide, it's your carotid artery.

    I agree with George. Choose a good quality (soft) margarine that does
    not
    contain hydrogenated fats and no transfats (read the lable). You can
    consume
    1-4 eggs a week but preferably no more.

    Egg whites are great low-calorie sources of protein.
    My wife bakes pumpkin custard with egg whites. We
    give the yolks to our dogs who love them. We also
    hard boil eggs. When I eat one, I eat the white part
    and give the yolk to Greta (poodle) or Emmy (mixed-
    breed). This makes me happy and them happy. I
    eat about six egg whites a day.

    How are your dogs?

    Flourishing. We take into account the egg yolks
    they eat in the rest of their diet. Over-all, they don't
    get as much sat fat as most canines. They are also
    on mild calorie restriction diets.

  12. <[email hidden]> wrote in message
    news:[email hidden]...

    Quoted message said:

    Butter : sturated fat

    Margarine : trans fat

    BOTH can raise total cholesterol and LDL cholesterol.

    Just try minimizing both intakes.

    There are some margarine-like soft spreads that
    don't have trans fats. Personally, I don't eat them,
    but that's because I get my essential fatty acids
    from other sources.

    George

  13. [email hidden] wrote:
    : Butter : sturated fat
    : Margarine : trans fat

    Good quality margarine does not contain transfat.

    --
    Juhana

  14. "Ron Peterson" <[email hidden]> wrote in message
    news:[email hidden]...

    Quoted message said:


    mikedob said:

    I go to a doctor who says butter is not really bad for you-- maybe he
    means in comparison
    to the usual margarine sold in stores---also that eggs are not bad for
    you --comment ??

    Butter is around 50% saturated fat so it isn't healthy although there
    are other fats that have a higher percent of saturated fats. I use some
    butter for flavor and for corn on the cob, but the two of us together
    use less than a pound a year. I don't use margarine. I do use vegetable
    oils in small amounts and find spray on canola oil a nice convenience.
    I do use sesame butter and other nut butters as a replacement for
    shortening.

    Good choices. I find sesame butter particularly
    delicious. My wife also adds it to hummus.
    Sesame butter: yummmm!

    Quoted message said:

    Eggs are a good source of nutrients with the whites containing no fat.
    The yolks have fat of which 40% is saturated. The yolks contain many
    vitiamins, so it is a good idea to eat a few (3-4) a week. So just
    throw away half of the yolks to keep your saturated fat and cholesterol
    down.

    Or give it do your dogs with their lean meat!

    George

    Quoted message said:

    Egg have a protein efficacy of 93.7%, making them one of the best
    sources of protein.

    Be sure to cook your eggs until they aren't runny to kill any
    pathogenic bacteria.

  15. George Cherry wrote:
    : "Ron Peterson" <[email hidden]> wrote in message
    : news:[email hidden]...

    :: I do
    :: use vegetable oils in small amounts and find spray on canola oil a
    :: nice convenience. I do use sesame butter and other nut butters as a
    :: replacement for shortening.
    :
    : Good choices. I find sesame butter particularly
    : delicious. My wife also adds it to hummus.
    : Sesame butter: yummmm!

    In addition to tahini (sesame butter) I also use sliced avokado on bread.
    That makes a very delicious sandwich if you season it with some herb or
    garlic and top it with some other sliced vegetables like sweet pepper or
    tomato.

    --
    Juhana

  16. Ron Peterson said:

    Eggs are a good source of nutrients with the whites containing no fat.
    The yolks have fat of which 40% is saturated. The yolks contain many
    vitiamins, so it is a good idea to eat a few (3-4) a week. So just
    throw away half of the yolks to keep your saturated fat and cholesterol
    down.

    There are some egg producers that add omega-3 fatty acids to the
    poultry feed resulting in eggs with high omega-3 content.

    --
    Ron

  17. Quoted message said:

    <[email hidden]> wrote in message

    Quoted message said:

    Butter : saturated fat

    Margarine : trans fat

    BOTH can raise total cholesterol and LDL cholesterol. Once you get beyond the paranoia of these Kooks, trans fat lowers HDL.

    Personally, I have not eaten either butter or margarine in decades.
    Nor, do I particularly miss them.

    The whole notion of rubbing a slab of fat over a slice of bread or on a
    baked potato is rather a bizarre custom to begin with.

    I rather like red or 'new potatoes.' And, they are quite tasty all by
    themselves when properly cooked.

    Who says so? I do. 🙂

  18. Neryl Chyphes said:


    How are your dogs?

    Probably better off healthwise than George. ;o)

    RBR

  19. ur absolutely right...
    now trans fat is on the food label...

    just check b4 u buy...

    ;D

    cheers,
    nina
    http://www.asweetnectarwomb.lipblogs.com

  20. YES!

    Who says so? I do. 🙂

Active in the last 60 minutes

Active in this thread

0 users · 0 guests ·0 bots ·0 total

No signed-in users are active right now.

No known search crawlers active right now.