"Ranieri" <nah> wrote in message
news:[email hidden]...
Quoted message said:
"Steve Freides" <[email hidden]> wrote in message
Quoted message said:We'll let the people reading decide. Yes. No. I'm frankly surprised
you're citing the Arnold Press as somehow being dangerous. Care to
point us to someone's opinion other than yours that it's a bad
exercise?
Steve, I recall getting into it with you a while back about shoulders,
I think you were recommending subluxing the shoulder on bar hangs.
No, Jim, this is absolutely not true. A subluxation is defined as as
"temporary, partial dislocation of the shoulder joint" and it's not
something I ever do or ever advocate anyone doing. I keep my shoulders
tight - firmly together, never relaxed on bar hangs and the bottom
position of pullups. There is a big difference between full extension,
known as a dead hang, and relaxtion and (shudder) subluxation. I think
response of "damfino" on this thread addresses the issue correctly -
form is everything and then some. I mean, hell, saying Arnold presses
are dangerous is like saying deadlifting is dangerous. Sure,
deadlifting is a fine way to ruin your back *if* you do it with poor
technique. In the Party, we believe that proper form and heavy weight
go hand in hand, and that if you lift properly you will, if anything, be
better with a heavy (80-85%) weight than with a light one because a
heavy weight enforces good form.
Quoted message said:At any rate, I think you have been blessed with shoulder joints that
can withstand a lot of use and abuse.
I don't think this is true, either. When I'm doing DL cycles, I DL 3-4
times per week and often finish a cycle with lots of 90%+ lifts - lots
of folks will tell you that's bad for you, too.
Quoted message said:That's great, but it's not necessarily the norm in the general
population. Overhead pressing movements can be problematic for an
awful lot of people, not to mention throwing in a rotational
component.
Only when not done properly. I do mine 6 days a week on average, 80-85%
weight most of the time, for a few short, heavy sets, typically 3-5 sets
of 2-4 reps, and I follow all the good training guidelines - I mix up
the kinds of presses I do, I go for full range of motion, I vary the
weights periodically, I cycle them up and down, and I get to reap the
results - healthy, strong shoulders.
The only piece I might agree on when it comes to "not necessarily the
norm" is that I'm lighter than most people, and that does make for less
of a load on my shoulders for things like bar hangs, but it's why I also
do most of my chinup work with at least 30 lbs. of added weight.
-S-
http://www.kbnj.com
Quoted message said:Quoted message said: