General fitness, health and nutrition · Public discussion

Muscle heads

Started by Per Elmsäter · · Last activity · 16 posts · 776 views

This thread is locked and is currently read-only.

Thread navigation

Jump through the discussion

Go to the original post, the replies on this page, or the latest preserved contribution.

Thread details

What we know about this thread

Original section
General fitness, health and nutrition
Published
19 October 2005
Last activity
21 October 2005
Original author
Per Elmsäter
Posts
16
Discussion status
Public discussion
Total views
776
Views / 30 days
0

The navigation and discussion metadata provide context. Posts remain in their original chronological order.

Showing posts 1–16 of 16
Posts remain in their original chronological order.

Text size
  1. Some muscles have several heads. For instance the quads have four heads as
    the name implies.
    1.. Rectus Femoris
    2.. Vastus Lateralis (Externus)
    3.. Vastus Intermedius
    4.. Vastus Medialis (Internus)
    Do all exercises that work the quads work all the heads equally or is it
    possible to work one head more than another. If the latter is true, does
    anybody do this and why? I know you cannot work only part of a muscle since
    a muscle fiber runs from one end to the other. So how does this apply to the
    different heads?

    --
    Perre
    I gave up on SPAM and redirected it to hotmail instead.

  2. In article <[email hidden]>,

    Per Elmsäter said:

    Some muscles have several heads. For instance the quads have four heads as
    the name implies.
    1.. Rectus Femoris
    2.. Vastus Lateralis (Externus)
    3.. Vastus Intermedius
    4.. Vastus Medialis (Internus)
    Do all exercises that work the quads work all the heads equally or is it
    possible to work one head more than another. If the latter is true, does
    anybody do this and why? I know you cannot work only part of a muscle since
    a muscle fiber runs from one end to the other. So how does this apply to the
    different heads?

    Actually there are 5 'heads' to the quads as rectus femoris has a two
    heads - one has origin on the iliac spine and the reflected head
    originates on the acetabulum.

    All the muscles of the quads are primarily knee extensors and insert at
    the patella. It is possible to stress specific muscles in the quads
    preferentially during during knee extension movement, but really
    questionable to what matter of degree. Even though you could put an EMG
    on the muscle and possibly stress the vastus lateralis slightly more (in
    theory), in reality you'd have to ask - what difference does it make? Is
    the small degree of preferential recruitment really important especially
    as you may have to sacrifice total motor units being recuited in all
    four muscles?

    Unless you have a pathology and have lost recruitment I'd question why
    it was necessary. Possibly a very advanced bodybuilder would need this
    in order to get a certain shape, but for the average weight trainer I'm
    not sure why you would worry about it.

    --
    Keith

  3. Per Elmsäter said:

    Some muscles have several heads. For instance the quads have four heads as
    the name implies.
    1.. Rectus Femoris
    2.. Vastus Lateralis (Externus)
    3.. Vastus Intermedius
    4.. Vastus Medialis (Internus)
    Do all exercises that work the quads work all the heads equally or is it
    possible to work one head more than another. If the latter is true, does
    anybody do this and why? I know you cannot work only part of a muscle since
    a muscle fiber runs from one end to the other. So how does this apply to the
    different heads?

    Well, rectus femoris is a (really weak) hip flexor, so you could do that (hip
    flexion) to work it in isolation.

  4. Hobbes said:

    Unless you have a pathology and have lost recruitment I'd question why
    it was necessary. Possibly a very advanced bodybuilder would need this
    in order to get a certain shape, but for the average weight trainer
    I'm not sure why you would worry about it.

    I think I'm more curious than anything else. However on the practical side I
    was probably wondering how the different exercises that work the quads would
    affect them. Like why do a bunch of different exercises if only one or two
    are sufficient? Let's say that you'd go a long way just doing DL and squat.
    Why then bother with all the other leg exercises that work the same muscles.

    --
    Perre
    I gave up on SPAM and redirected it to hotmail instead.

  5. "Per Elmsäter" <[email hidden]> wrote in message
    news:[email hidden]...

    Quoted message said:
    Hobbes said:

    Unless you have a pathology and have lost recruitment I'd question why
    it was necessary. Possibly a very advanced bodybuilder would need this
    in order to get a certain shape, but for the average weight trainer
    I'm not sure why you would worry about it.

    I think I'm more curious than anything else. However on the practical side
    I
    was probably wondering how the different exercises that work the quads
    would
    affect them. Like why do a bunch of different exercises if only one or two
    are sufficient? Let's say that you'd go a long way just doing DL and
    squat.
    Why then bother with all the other leg exercises that work the same
    muscles.

    --
    Perre
    I gave up on SPAM and redirected it to hotmail instead.

    Marketing. Hip aductor machines are so much more sexy for the women folk
    than humping a bunch of iron onto your traps and squatting to get the same
    effect. And you don't have to vomit on your spandex bodysuit and leg
    warmers.

    'least wise TBR tol' me so. And he is a god. Lower case, definitely.

    Quoted message said:


  6. In article <[email hidden]>,

    Lascivious Mink said:
    Per Elmsäter said:

    Some muscles have several heads. For instance the quads have four heads as
    the name implies.
    1.. Rectus Femoris
    2.. Vastus Lateralis (Externus)
    3.. Vastus Intermedius
    4.. Vastus Medialis (Internus)
    Do all exercises that work the quads work all the heads equally or is it
    possible to work one head more than another. If the latter is true, does
    anybody do this and why? I know you cannot work only part of a muscle since
    a muscle fiber runs from one end to the other. So how does this apply to the
    different heads?

    Well, rectus femoris is a (really weak) hip flexor, so you could do that (hip
    flexion) to work it in isolation.

    Good point.

    --
    Keith

  7. In article <[email hidden]>,

    Per Elmsäter said:
    Hobbes said:

    Unless you have a pathology and have lost recruitment I'd question why
    it was necessary. Possibly a very advanced bodybuilder would need this
    in order to get a certain shape, but for the average weight trainer
    I'm not sure why you would worry about it.

    I think I'm more curious than anything else. However on the practical side I
    was probably wondering how the different exercises that work the quads would
    affect them. Like why do a bunch of different exercises if only one or two
    are sufficient? Let's say that you'd go a long way just doing DL and squat.
    Why then bother with all the other leg exercises that work the same muscles.

    I don't. I squat and deadlift.

    However, in all fairness some people prefer variety of exercise
    selection. You need variety, although it can be achieved with two
    exercises by varying intensities, volume, etc. But some people just
    prefer to try new things and that is okay too.

    --
    Keith

  8. Hobbes said:

    In article <[email hidden]>,

    Per Elmsäter said:
    Hobbes said:

    Unless you have a pathology and have lost recruitment I'd question why
    it was necessary. Possibly a very advanced bodybuilder would need this
    in order to get a certain shape, but for the average weight trainer
    I'm not sure why you would worry about it.

    I think I'm more curious than anything else. However on the practical side I
    was probably wondering how the different exercises that work the quads would
    affect them. Like why do a bunch of different exercises if only one or two
    are sufficient? Let's say that you'd go a long way just doing DL and squat.
    Why then bother with all the other leg exercises that work the same muscles.

    I don't. I squat and deadlift.

    However, in all fairness some people prefer variety of exercise
    selection. You need variety, although it can be achieved with two
    exercises by varying intensities, volume, etc. But some people just
    prefer to try new things and that is okay too.

    I seem to get enough variety with one exercise. ;-) Volume goes up and down,
    weight goes up, effort varies....

    Perhaps I'm just easily amused. ;-)

  9. Hobbes said:

    In article <[email hidden]>,

    Per Elmsäter said:
    Hobbes said:

    Unless you have a pathology and have lost recruitment I'd question
    why it was necessary. Possibly a very advanced bodybuilder would
    need this in order to get a certain shape, but for the average
    weight trainer I'm not sure why you would worry about it.

    I think I'm more curious than anything else. However on the
    practical side I was probably wondering how the different exercises
    that work the quads would affect them. Like why do a bunch of
    different exercises if only one or two are sufficient? Let's say
    that you'd go a long way just doing DL and squat. Why then bother
    with all the other leg exercises that work the same muscles.

    I don't. I squat and deadlift.

    C'mon. You can't spend an hour in the gym several days a week just doing the
    three big ones. As I'm sure you also bench a pound or two 😉

    Or. Do you just vary your squats by doing all sorts of box squats, bottoms
    up, front squats etc? Still it'd be hard to do so much compound exercises 😉

    --
    Perre
    I gave up on SPAM and redirected it to hotmail instead.

  10. Lascivious Mink said:
    Per Elmsäter said:

    Some muscles have several heads. For instance the quads have four
    heads as the name implies.
    1.. Rectus Femoris
    2.. Vastus Lateralis (Externus)
    3.. Vastus Intermedius
    4.. Vastus Medialis (Internus)
    Do all exercises that work the quads work all the heads equally or
    is it possible to work one head more than another. If the latter is
    true, does anybody do this and why? I know you cannot work only part
    of a muscle since a muscle fiber runs from one end to the other. So
    how does this apply to the different heads?

    Well, rectus femoris is a (really weak) hip flexor, so you could do
    that (hip flexion) to work it in isolation.

    Fine. That pretty much answers my question. Not that it'll do me any good,
    but as I said. I'm mainly curious.
    How about the heads on the biceps and triceps?

    --
    Perre
    I gave up on SPAM and redirected it to hotmail instead.

  11. In article <[email hidden]>,

    Per Elmsäter said:
    Hobbes said:

    In article <[email hidden]>,

    Per Elmsäter said:

    Hobbes wrote:
    > Unless you have a pathology and have lost recruitment I'd question
    > why it was necessary. Possibly a very advanced bodybuilder would
    > need this in order to get a certain shape, but for the average
    > weight trainer I'm not sure why you would worry about it.

    I think I'm more curious than anything else. However on the
    practical side I was probably wondering how the different exercises
    that work the quads would affect them. Like why do a bunch of
    different exercises if only one or two are sufficient? Let's say
    that you'd go a long way just doing DL and squat. Why then bother
    with all the other leg exercises that work the same muscles.

    I don't. I squat and deadlift.

    C'mon. You can't spend an hour in the gym several days a week just doing the
    three big ones. As I'm sure you also bench a pound or two 😉

    Or. Do you just vary your squats by doing all sorts of box squats, bottoms
    up, front squats etc? Still it'd be hard to do so much compound exercises 😉

    Actually I front squat, [censored], OH squat, clean and jerk and once every
    couple of weeks deadlifts. I also do high repetition bodyweight
    exercises. I will start doing deadlifts more often and switch to the
    so-called "Romanian" deadlift.

    I also run sometimes and stretch. Martial arts. Sports. Etc.

    --
    Keith

  12. Hobbes said:

    In article <[email hidden]>,

    Per Elmsäter said:
    Hobbes said:

    In article <[email hidden]>,
    "Per Elmsäter" <[email hidden]> wrote:

    > Hobbes wrote:
    >> Unless you have a pathology and have lost recruitment I'd question
    >> why it was necessary. Possibly a very advanced bodybuilder would
    >> need this in order to get a certain shape, but for the average
    >> weight trainer I'm not sure why you would worry about it.
    >
    > I think I'm more curious than anything else. However on the
    > practical side I was probably wondering how the different exercises
    > that work the quads would affect them. Like why do a bunch of
    > different exercises if only one or two are sufficient? Let's say
    > that you'd go a long way just doing DL and squat. Why then bother
    > with all the other leg exercises that work the same muscles.

    I don't. I squat and deadlift.

    C'mon. You can't spend an hour in the gym several days a week just
    doing the three big ones. As I'm sure you also bench a pound or two
    😉

    Or. Do you just vary your squats by doing all sorts of box squats,
    bottoms up, front squats etc? Still it'd be hard to do so much
    compound exercises 😉

    Actually I front squat, [censored], OH squat, clean and jerk and once
    every couple of weeks deadlifts. I also do high repetition bodyweight
    exercises. I will start doing deadlifts more often and switch to the
    so-called "Romanian" deadlift.

    I also run sometimes and stretch. Martial arts. Sports. Etc.

    OK I get the picture. I suppose all I see in my gym is either bodybuilders
    or fitness freaks. The fitness freaks love the machines and the cardio park
    whilst the BB people just cannot wait to lay their hands on the 60 kg
    dumbbells, for all sorts of different exercises. 😉

    --
    Perre
    I gave up on SPAM and redirected it to hotmail instead.

  13. Per Elmsäter said:
    Hobbes said:

    In article <[email hidden]>,

    Per Elmsäter said:

    Hobbes wrote:

    >Unless you have a pathology and have lost recruitment I'd question
    >why it was necessary. Possibly a very advanced bodybuilder would
    >need this in order to get a certain shape, but for the average
    >weight trainer I'm not sure why you would worry about it.

    I think I'm more curious than anything else. However on the
    practical side I was probably wondering how the different exercises
    that work the quads would affect them. Like why do a bunch of
    different exercises if only one or two are sufficient? Let's say
    that you'd go a long way just doing DL and squat. Why then bother
    with all the other leg exercises that work the same muscles.

    I don't. I squat and deadlift.

    C'mon. You can't spend an hour in the gym several days a week just doing the
    three big ones. As I'm sure you also bench a pound or two 😉

    Why would you want to spend an hour in the gym? Some of my best workouts lasted
    fifteen minutes. Here's one: after setting two squat PRs in succession, somehow
    I just didn't feel like doing anything else.

  14. Per Elmsäter said:
    Lascivious Mink said:
    Per Elmsäter said:

    Some muscles have several heads. For instance the quads have four
    heads as the name implies.
    1.. Rectus Femoris
    2.. Vastus Lateralis (Externus)
    3.. Vastus Intermedius
    4.. Vastus Medialis (Internus)
    Do all exercises that work the quads work all the heads equally or
    is it possible to work one head more than another. If the latter is
    true, does anybody do this and why? I know you cannot work only part
    of a muscle since a muscle fiber runs from one end to the other. So
    how does this apply to the different heads?

    Well, rectus femoris is a (really weak) hip flexor, so you could do
    that (hip flexion) to work it in isolation.

    Fine. That pretty much answers my question. Not that it'll do me any good,
    but as I said. I'm mainly curious.
    How about the heads on the biceps and triceps?

    Biceps brachii is an elbow flexor and a forearm supinator, so you *might* work
    it a little harder with supinating dumbbell curls than you could with a barbell
    curl.

    All three heads of the triceps are elbow extensors, but only the long head is a
    shoulder extensor and adductor, so you could probably work it in isolation.

    All this cribbed off www.exrx.net/Lists/Directory.html

  15. Lascivious Mink said:
    Per Elmsäter said:
    Hobbes said:

    In article <[email hidden]>,
    "Per Elmsäter" <[email hidden]> wrote:

    > Hobbes wrote:
    >
    >> Unless you have a pathology and have lost recruitment I'd question
    >> why it was necessary. Possibly a very advanced bodybuilder would
    >> need this in order to get a certain shape, but for the average
    >> weight trainer I'm not sure why you would worry about it.
    >
    > I think I'm more curious than anything else. However on the
    > practical side I was probably wondering how the different exercises
    > that work the quads would affect them. Like why do a bunch of
    > different exercises if only one or two are sufficient? Let's say
    > that you'd go a long way just doing DL and squat. Why then bother
    > with all the other leg exercises that work the same muscles.

    I don't. I squat and deadlift.

    C'mon. You can't spend an hour in the gym several days a week just
    doing the three big ones. As I'm sure you also bench a pound or two
    😉

    Why would you want to spend an hour in the gym? Some of my best
    workouts lasted fifteen minutes. Here's one: after setting two squat
    PRs in succession, somehow I just didn't feel like doing anything
    else.

    Well those are the days you spend in the juice bar afterwards telling
    everybody about them 😉
    However I'm sure you spent many hours in the gym building strength for those
    PR's!

    --
    Perre
    I gave up on SPAM and redirected it to hotmail instead.

  16. Lascivious Mink said:
    Per Elmsäter said:
    Lascivious Mink said:

    Per Elmsäter wrote:

    > Some muscles have several heads. For instance the quads have four
    > heads as the name implies.
    > 1.. Rectus Femoris
    > 2.. Vastus Lateralis (Externus)
    > 3.. Vastus Intermedius
    > 4.. Vastus Medialis (Internus)
    > Do all exercises that work the quads work all the heads equally or
    > is it possible to work one head more than another. If the latter is
    > true, does anybody do this and why? I know you cannot work only
    > part of a muscle since a muscle fiber runs from one end to the
    > other. So how does this apply to the different heads?
    >

    Well, rectus femoris is a (really weak) hip flexor, so you could do
    that (hip flexion) to work it in isolation.

    Fine. That pretty much answers my question. Not that it'll do me any
    good, but as I said. I'm mainly curious.
    How about the heads on the biceps and triceps?

    Biceps brachii is an elbow flexor and a forearm supinator, so you
    *might* work it a little harder with supinating dumbbell curls than
    you could with a barbell curl.

    All three heads of the triceps are elbow extensors, but only the long
    head is a shoulder extensor and adductor, so you could probably work
    it in isolation.

    All this cribbed off www.exrx.net/Lists/Directory.html

    Thanks a lot Mink!

    --
    Perre
    I gave up on SPAM and redirected it to hotmail instead.

Active in the last 60 minutes

Active in this thread

0 users · 0 guests ·0 bots ·0 total

No signed-in users are active right now.

No known search crawlers active right now.