General fitness, health and nutrition · Public discussion

weight training

Started by Behmer · · Last activity · 13 posts · 741 views

This thread is locked and is currently read-only.

Thread navigation

Jump through the discussion

Go to the original post, the replies on this page, or the latest preserved contribution.

Thread details

What we know about this thread

Original section
General fitness, health and nutrition
Published
19 October 2005
Last activity
21 October 2005
Original author
Behmer
Posts
13
Discussion status
Public discussion
Total views
741
Views / 30 days
0

The navigation and discussion metadata provide context. Posts remain in their original chronological order.

Showing posts 1–13 of 13
Posts remain in their original chronological order.

Text size
  1. What kind of weight training does professional runners do? I am trying
    ot find a trainign program that makes sense. I have not found much
    results in going low weight high reps. I would like to know what weight
    training triathletes foillow.

  2. Behmer said:

    What kind of weight training does professional runners do? I am trying
    ot find a trainign program that makes sense. I have not found much
    results in going low weight high reps. I would like to know what weight
    training triathletes foillow.

    That's several questions, but I'll take the runners one. Trunk
    exercises are important, as well as upper body, but with reasonably
    light weights. That is what most pro runners do, so why hasn't it
    worked for you? Or what is your goal?

  3. Oh I don't know, you sure sound like a weight lifter to me.

    Ughh.......me go.

  4. On Wed, 19 Oct 2005 21:21:55 -0400, [email hidden] (Miss Anne

    Thrope) said:

    Ughh.......me go.

    ....potty?

  5. Light weights with high reps builds endurance and strength.
    http://www.glennsacks.com/pbs/index.php

    "Behmer" <[email hidden]> wrote in message
    news:[email hidden]...

    Quoted message said:

    What kind of weight training does professional runners do? I am trying
    ot find a trainign program that makes sense. I have not found much
    results in going low weight high reps. I would like to know what weight
    training triathletes foillow.

  6. Behmer said:

    What kind of weight training does professional runners do?

    I suspect that the answer is that "it varies". Quite a lot.

    I've experienced dramatic improvements after doing no weight training. I build
    running specific "strength" by running fast (either on flats or uphill). The
    best thing you can do to your physique as far as running performance is
    concerned, is to be as light as you can get without going hungry all the time.

    Some things I would recommend though:

    (1) prefer compound exercises to isolation. Much more efficient use of time
    because you need fewer exercises per workout. For example, squats, deadlifts,
    bench press, dumbell shoulder press, pullups. Don't waste time with cute stuff
    like wrist curls, dumbell curls, lateral raises, etc.

    (2) IMO upper body work will not help you run faster.

    (3) do something for the midsection -- abs, obliques, lower back.

    Quoted message said:

    I am trying ot find a trainign program that makes sense.

    Good luck (-;

    Quoted message said:

    I have not found much results in going low weight high reps.

    The key is force/power production. Explosive reps. Wouldn't recommend very high
    reps, you don't want to push all the way to (or anywhere near) failure. Better
    to terminate the set when you can no longer lift the weight quickly.

    So I'd actually advocate doing more sets with less reps, e.g. 10 sets of 3 at
    60% max. Lower the weight steadily, explode out of the bottom. To make this
    more time efficient, you can alternate pairs of exercises.

    Quoted message said:

    I would like to know what weight
    training triathletes foillow.

    No idea.

    Cheers,
    --
    Donovan Rebbechi
    http://pegasus.rutgers.edu/~elflord/

  7. Donovan Rebbechi said:
    Behmer said:

    What kind of weight training does professional runners do?

    I suspect that the answer is that "it varies". Quite a lot.

    Yeah, opinion varies all over the spectrum, and I bet DR's right, that
    practices do as well.

    Quoted message said:

    (2) IMO upper body work will not help you run faster.

    And Joe McVeigh, FWIW, has said that it makes a big different for him
    at the marathon distance.

    I don't know who's "right", but

    [a] I suspect the optimal training, including weights, varies nearly as
    much from one person to the next as do theories about the optimal
    training, and

    [b] I'll go with Donovan - for now - on this one if only because it
    conveniently requires less work of me that I'd rather avoid. (My upper
    body could use *something* - traps always tight, right upper arm often
    gets tight running - but suspect things like posture and ergonomics @
    work and carrying a sometimes heavy messenger type bag may be higher
    priorities.)


    Quoted message said:

    (3) do something for the midsection -- abs, obliques, lower back.



    And someone like Yessis will partially agree but add that, if the
    motion is not running-specific, it won't help much. e.g. he's not a
    fan of crunches. (Of course Yessis seems particularly controversial on
    a variety of issues, and I am not advancing him or McVeigh or Rebbechi
    or Pendejo as the one true expert on anything.)


    Quoted message said:
    Quoted message said:

    I have not found much results in going low weight high reps.

    The key is force/power production. Explosive reps.



    Yeah, I've heard this and thought it sounded plausible. Of course "low
    wt, hi reps" is frequently heard; and I also read somewhere a few
    months ago the opinion that "hi wt, low reps" is the way to go for
    runners because it maximizes the strength *for a given muscle mass*,
    i.e. strength w/o bulk. The author had an official sounding phrase for
    this principle and diagrams and IIRC claimed this protocol was
    effective both neurologically (at first) and physiologically (as weeks
    wore on).

    What does seem a safe bet to me, though, is that as DR says, running
    fast - on flats or hills - will improve one's running strength/power
    (and ability to run fast on flats or hills)... and it probably makes
    sense to view that as primary, and any weight work as secondary
    support.


    Quoted message said:
    Quoted message said:

    I would like to know what weight training triathletes foillow.



    It's not so impressive: first they shave all the mass - gram by gram -
    off the weights, then they reduce the routine's time to mere seconds.
    But boy oh boy do they ever dress up for it in some fancy technical
    duds!

  8. Quoth Charlie Pendejo <[email hidden]>:

    Quoted message said:

    Donovan Rebbechi wrote:


    [snip]

    Quoted message said:
    Quoted message said:

    (3) do something for the midsection -- abs, obliques, lower back.

    Quoted message said:

    And someone like Yessis will partially agree but add that, if the
    motion is not running-specific, it won't help much. e.g. he's not a
    fan of crunches.

    It seems to me that this would help with posture and thus running
    form, no?

    Cheers,
    Craig

    --
    Corollary to Clarke's Third Law:
    Any technology distinguishable from magic is insufficiently
    advanced.

  9. Craig Pennington said:

    Quoth Charlie Pendejo <[email hidden]>:

    Quoted message said:

    Donovan Rebbechi wrote:


    [snip]

    Quoted message said:
    Quoted message said:

    (3) do something for the midsection -- abs, obliques, lower back.

    Quoted message said:

    And someone like Yessis will partially agree but add that, if the
    motion is not running-specific, it won't help much. e.g. he's not a
    fan of crunches.

    It seems to me that this would help with posture and thus running
    form, no?

    Seems plausible, but where is the evidence that this work actually improves
    running performance ? And that's exactly where it's at -- there is a lot of
    well-reasoned speculation and theory, but considerably less hard evidence.

    One thing I'd say in favor of core work -- besides taking some time that you
    could be running, it's very unlikely that it will hurt your performance, because
    you will not bulk up from doing it.

    There is *some* evidence that the sort of work Yessis advocates (specific
    explosive training) is effective as part of a peaking program (but maybe one
    could get the same benefits by doing strides or form drills ... )

    One thing that I would point out though is that specificity really counts. When
    you do specific training (that is, running in this case), you get effects that
    not only exceed statistical significance thresholds, the effect size is
    substantial. Specific training produces *huge* improvements. There is no guess
    work or disagreement that running will make you a better runner, whereas cross
    training, in its various forms, generally results in modest to no gains. You
    will not get 20 seconds per mile faster by cross training if you're already
    doing a lot of running.

    In some cases, there may be a reason those benefits aren't available via
    running, so I certainly would not go so far as to imply that it's necessarily
    the case that cross training is a waste of time. My point though is that to get
    better at running, you should just go out and run, and then run some more. If
    you're not doing 100 miles per week (just throwing an arbitrary big number out
    here, but you get the idea, right ?) and speedwork year round, the best thing
    you can do for your performance is to do more running.

    Moreover, if you're a beginner, your focus should really be on getting out there
    and running. If you enjoy doing weights or cross training, that's fine -- go
    ahead and do it. It won't hurt, you will be more rounded which is something that
    most recreational runners appreciate, and you will enjoy huge gains in running
    performance anyway. But to become a faster runner, it's mostly about doing lots
    of running.

    Cheers,
    --
    Donovan Rebbechi
    http://pegasus.rutgers.edu/~elflord/

  10. Craig Pennington said:

    Quoth Charlie Pendejo:

    Quoted message said:

    Yessis [..] he's not a fan of crunches.

    It seems to me that this would help with posture and thus running
    form, no?

    Take it up with Yessis, I'm not his spokesman and have little idea one
    way or the other. :-)

    Just using him as an example of people's strength-training-for-running
    views being all over the map. FWIW, a little search engine whispered
    in my ear that he's now got a website. While this page:

    http://www.dryessis.com/modules.php?name=Content&pa=showpage&pid=2

    mentions that he likes the "reverse trunk twist", the whole page (and
    I'm guessing site) seems to exist mostly just to shill for his book(s).

    Pendejo, the other "CP"

  11. Charlie Pendejo said:
    Craig Pennington said:

    Quoth Charlie Pendejo:

    Quoted message said:

    Yessis [..] he's not a fan of crunches.

    It seems to me that this would help with posture and thus running
    form, no?

    Take it up with Yessis, I'm not his spokesman and have little idea one
    way or the other. :-)

    Neither does he, I suspect.

    BTW, I wouldn't call him an expert. As far as I know, he hasn't produced a
    single peer reviewed publication.

    Out of the people you mentioned, Yessis's opinion would weigh in at a dead last.
    Yes, I'm somewhat interested in what that Charlie guy has to say and not the
    least bit interested in Yessis.

    McVeigh certainly has my ear. Find it hard to believe he does weights though.
    Have you seen him in person ? The guy is built like Alan Culpepper. I suppose
    he's not the type to bulk up.

    The first time I saw him, I showed up to some smalltown NJ race, and looking at
    the previous years times I thought I could go for an outright win. Then
    McVeigh showed up, jogging around in his tracksuit, looking very confident, and
    even though I had no idea who he was or how fast he'd run, my heart plummeted.
    Just to look at him, I was pretty sure he'd go sub 32, the only question was how
    far under.

    In the end, they botched the tag scoring -- they were all downshifted, I suppose
    the "button hitter" missed him crossing because he was just a blur (and not a
    very big blur), so his official time was 36:xx. Not sure whether I should have
    been happy to have an official time within 3 minutes of him, or whether I should
    have been [censored] that my time was 39:xx.

    Cheers,
    --
    Donovan Rebbechi
    http://pegasus.rutgers.edu/~elflord/

  12. Donovan Rebbechi said:

    McVeigh certainly has my ear. Find it hard to believe he does
    weights though. Have you seen him in person ? The guy is built
    like Alan Culpepper.

    I have not seen him, knowingly at least. I am absolutely certain he
    claimed great benefit from upper-body strength training on letsrun but
    now I cannot find it (despite the superior search facility ;-).

    In the process of trying, I did find out about your "MC Esher shortcut"
    in Central Park, which I hope you'll share with me and lance - I could
    really use the help. Otherwise, do you have Rosie Ruiz' number handy?

    Quoted message said:

    The first time I saw him, I showed up to some smalltown NJ race,
    and looking at the previous years times I thought I could go for
    an outright win. Then McVeigh showed up

    Thanks - great story!

  13. Charlie Pendejo said:
    Donovan Rebbechi said:

    McVeigh certainly has my ear. Find it hard to believe he does
    weights though. Have you seen him in person ? The guy is built
    like Alan Culpepper.

    I have not seen him, knowingly at least.

    http://www.mensracing.com/photos/2004/ingnewyorkcitymarathon04/index04.html
    http://brightroom.com/view_user_event.asp?EVENTID=4590&PWD=&BIB=4779

    Cheers,
    --
    Donovan Rebbechi
    http://pegasus.rutgers.edu/~elflord/

Active in the last 60 minutes

Active in this thread

0 users · 0 guests ·0 bots ·0 total

No signed-in users are active right now.

No known search crawlers active right now.