General fitness, health and nutrition · Public discussion

cooking wine?

Started by Bernard Arnest · · Last activity · 39 posts · 1,241 views

This thread is locked and is currently read-only.

Thread navigation

Jump through the discussion

Go to the original post, the replies on this page, or the latest preserved contribution.

Thread details

What we know about this thread

Original section
General fitness, health and nutrition
Published
18 September 2005
Last activity
29 September 2005
Original author
Bernard Arnest
Posts
39
Discussion status
Public discussion
Total views
1,241
Views / 30 days
0

The navigation and discussion metadata provide context. Posts remain in their original chronological order.

Showing posts 1–20 of 39
Posts remain in their original chronological order.

Text size
  1. Hi,
    In recipes that call for white wine, is cooking wine from the grocery
    store fine, or does it offer poor flavor, too much salt, or conflict
    with the rest of the seasoning vs. standard wine? I ask because this
    is my first year in college, and I'm 18, thus cooking wine is really
    the only wine, but I want to know how it might affect a recipe and how
    I might compensate.

    If non-cooking-wine is the way to go (at least when home, and my dad
    can buy it), do you have any best-value recommendations? Since it's
    cooked and not drunk, is the dirt cheapest the way to go...?

    thanks!
    -Bernard Arnest

  2. Bernard Arnest said:

    Hi,
    In recipes that call for white wine, is cooking wine from the grocery
    store fine, or does it offer poor flavor, too much salt, or conflict
    with the rest of the seasoning vs. standard wine? I ask because this
    is my first year in college, and I'm 18, thus cooking wine is really
    the only wine, but I want to know how it might affect a recipe and how
    I might compensate.

    If non-cooking-wine is the way to go (at least when home, and my dad
    can buy it), do you have any best-value recommendations? Since it's
    cooked and not drunk, is the dirt cheapest the way to go...?


    Dry vermouth works pretty well in most recipes that call for white
    wine. Keeps forever, neutral taste. Dry sherry works for some things,
    depending on whether the flavor meshes with the recipe. But not
    "cooking sherry," which as you note, contains salt and tastes terrible.
    -aem

  3. I agree strongly with the above poster! Amen!
    Julia Child, on the TV show, The French Chef, used vermouth
    always for "white wine". I use Ponti dry vermouth at Trade Joes'
    for about three $/bottle, and I like it better than most other white wines
    for cooking.
    Kent

    "Bernard Arnest" <[email hidden]> wrote in message
    news:[email hidden]...

    Quoted message said:

    Hi,
    In recipes that call for white wine, is cooking wine from the grocery
    store fine, or does it offer poor flavor, too much salt, or conflict
    with the rest of the seasoning vs. standard wine? I ask because this
    is my first year in college, and I'm 18, thus cooking wine is really
    the only wine, but I want to know how it might affect a recipe and how
    I might compensate.

    If non-cooking-wine is the way to go (at least when home, and my dad
    can buy it), do you have any best-value recommendations? Since it's
    cooked and not drunk, is the dirt cheapest the way to go...?

    thanks!
    -Bernard Arnest

  4. Bernard Arnest said:

    Hi,
    In recipes that call for white wine, is cooking wine from the
    grocery
    store fine, or does it offer poor flavor, too much salt, or conflict
    with the rest of the seasoning vs. standard wine? I ask because this
    is my first year in college, and I'm 18, thus cooking wine is really
    the only wine, but I want to know how it might affect a recipe and how

    I might compensate.

    If non-cooking-wine is the way to go (at least when home, and my dad

    can buy it), do you have any best-value recommendations? Since it's
    cooked and not drunk, is the dirt cheapest the way to go...?

    thanks!
    -Bernard Arnest

    Avoid anything labelled 'cooking wine' try a Gallo Chenin blanc if
    acquiring the wine is not a problem for you.
    ---
    JL

  5. cooking with wine 101: As the wine's flavor will concentrate with
    cooking, don't use anything that tastes like [censored].
    Unless you're into concentrated [censored].

  6. Hi Bernard,
    In your situation I wouldn't waste my money on white wine for cooking. Get
    yourself a big bottle of dry vermouth. Its cheap, you only need half the
    amount, it works well in cooking and you won't be tempted to drink it "-)
    Otherwise try madeira, or even dry sherry. Experiment till you find the
    taste you like. This will vary depending on the recipe. You can use a cheap
    port too in recipes that can use some sweetness.
    Good Luck!!
    Richard.

    "Bernard Arnest" <[email hidden]> wrote in message
    news:[email hidden]...

    Quoted message said:

    Hi,
    In recipes that call for white wine, is cooking wine from the grocery
    store fine, or does it offer poor flavor, too much salt, or conflict
    with the rest of the seasoning vs. standard wine? I ask because this
    is my first year in college, and I'm 18, thus cooking wine is really
    the only wine, but I want to know how it might affect a recipe and how
    I might compensate.

    If non-cooking-wine is the way to go (at least when home, and my dad
    can buy it), do you have any best-value recommendations? Since it's
    cooked and not drunk, is the dirt cheapest the way to go...?

    thanks!
    -Bernard Arnest

  7. Never cook with a wine you wouldn't drink.. That's my contribution.

    Horse

    "Richard Green" <[email hidden]> wrote in message
    news:[email hidden]...

    Quoted message said:

    Hi Bernard,
    In your situation I wouldn't waste my money on white wine for cooking. Get
    yourself a big bottle of dry vermouth. Its cheap, you only need half the
    amount, it works well in cooking and you won't be tempted to drink it "-)
    Otherwise try madeira, or even dry sherry. Experiment till you find the
    taste you like. This will vary depending on the recipe. You can use a


    cheap

    Quoted message said:

    port too in recipes that can use some sweetness.
    Good Luck!!
    Richard.

    "Bernard Arnest" <[email hidden]> wrote in message
    news:[email hidden]...

    Quoted message said:

    Hi,
    In recipes that call for white wine, is cooking wine from the grocery
    store fine, or does it offer poor flavor, too much salt, or conflict
    with the rest of the seasoning vs. standard wine? I ask because this
    is my first year in college, and I'm 18, thus cooking wine is really
    the only wine, but I want to know how it might affect a recipe and how
    I might compensate.

    If non-cooking-wine is the way to go (at least when home, and my dad
    can buy it), do you have any best-value recommendations? Since it's
    cooked and not drunk, is the dirt cheapest the way to go...?

    thanks!
    -Bernard Arnest

  8. Never cook with a wine you wouldn't drink.. That's my contribution.

    Horse

    "Richard Green" <[email hidden]> wrote in message
    news:[email hidden]...

    Quoted message said:

    Hi Bernard,
    In your situation I wouldn't waste my money on white wine for cooking. Get
    yourself a big bottle of dry vermouth. Its cheap, you only need half the
    amount, it works well in cooking and you won't be tempted to drink it "-)
    Otherwise try madeira, or even dry sherry. Experiment till you find the
    taste you like. This will vary depending on the recipe. You can use a


    cheap

    Quoted message said:

    port too in recipes that can use some sweetness.
    Good Luck!!
    Richard.

    "Bernard Arnest" <[email hidden]> wrote in message
    news:[email hidden]...

    Quoted message said:

    Hi,
    In recipes that call for white wine, is cooking wine from the grocery
    store fine, or does it offer poor flavor, too much salt, or conflict
    with the rest of the seasoning vs. standard wine? I ask because this
    is my first year in college, and I'm 18, thus cooking wine is really
    the only wine, but I want to know how it might affect a recipe and how
    I might compensate.

    If non-cooking-wine is the way to go (at least when home, and my dad
    can buy it), do you have any best-value recommendations? Since it's
    cooked and not drunk, is the dirt cheapest the way to go...?

    thanks!
    -Bernard Arnest

  9. In article <[email hidden]>,

    Bernard Arnest said:

    Hi,
    In recipes that call for white wine, is cooking wine from the grocery
    store fine, or does it offer poor flavor, too much salt, or conflict
    with the rest of the seasoning vs. standard wine? I ask because this
    is my first year in college, and I'm 18, thus cooking wine is really
    the only wine, but I want to know how it might affect a recipe and how
    I might compensate.

    If non-cooking-wine is the way to go (at least when home, and my dad
    can buy it), do you have any best-value recommendations? Since it's
    cooked and not drunk, is the dirt cheapest the way to go...?

    Whatever you like that's in your budget is fine. Cooking wine from
    grocery stores tends to be a bad choice because its mostly salt and low
    quality wine. You might enjoy those recipes that call for wine more if
    you go to a wine store and buy an inexpensive bottle of wine. A rule of
    thumb is that if you don't enjoy drinking a wine, don't cook with it.

  10. <snipped a bit>

    Quoted message said:
    Quoted message said:

    In recipes that call for white wine, is cooking wine from the grocery
    store fine, or does it offer poor flavor, too much salt, or conflict
    with the rest of the seasoning vs. standard wine? >


    Whatever you like that's in your budget is fine. Cooking wine from
    grocery stores tends to be a bad choice because its mostly salt and low
    quality wine.

    Ok, I have to ask...I've never heard of "cooking wine" as such, and am
    wondering what the heck is salt doing in wine? I Googled a bit, but didn't
    find much about why. Cooking wine to me (and I would say with some
    confidence, most other Aussies) is "normal" wine that you cook with.

    Granted, maybe I'm just showing some ignorance about stuff from O/S, but I
    live in a great wine-growing state (Sth Australia) with many wonderful
    wineries 1 hour North of me (Barossa Valley, Clare Valley), and several
    others 1 hour South of me (McLaren Vale, Clarendon, the Southern Vales), and
    maybe even better wine country another couple of hours away (Coonawarra,
    etc), but I've never heard of salt in wine.

    I've always followed my parents' advice (mum a great Italian home cook, and
    dad a chef) that if I couldn't drink the stuff, I shouldn't cook with it,
    but it was always normal bottled or even cask wine.

    Thanks in advance
    Maria
    a somewhat confused, occasional wine drinker :-)

  11. MG wrote:

    <snip>

    Quoted message said:

    Ok, I have to ask...I've never heard of "cooking wine" as such, and am
    wondering what the heck is salt doing in wine? I Googled a bit, but didn't
    find much about why. Cooking wine to me (and I would say with some
    confidence, most other Aussies) is "normal" wine that you cook with.

    <snip>

    The story I always used to hear was that cooking wine was salted
    to discourage the servants from taking a nip.

  12. "MG" <[email hidden]> wrote in message
    news:[email hidden]...

    Quoted message said:

    <snipped a bit>

    Quoted message said:
    Quoted message said:

    In recipes that call for white wine, is cooking wine from the
    grocery
    store fine, or does it offer poor flavor, too much salt, or conflict
    with the rest of the seasoning vs. standard wine? >


    Whatever you like that's in your budget is fine. Cooking wine from
    grocery stores tends to be a bad choice because its mostly salt and
    low
    quality wine.

    Ok, I have to ask...I've never heard of "cooking wine" as such, and am
    wondering what the heck is salt doing in wine? I Googled a bit, but
    didn't find much about why. Cooking wine to me (and I would say with
    some confidence, most other Aussies) is "normal" wine that you cook
    with.

    Granted, maybe I'm just showing some ignorance about stuff from O/S,
    but I live in a great wine-growing state (Sth Australia) with many
    wonderful wineries 1 hour North of me (Barossa Valley, Clare Valley),
    and several others 1 hour South of me (McLaren Vale, Clarendon, the
    Southern Vales), and maybe even better wine country another couple of
    hours away (Coonawarra, etc), but I've never heard of salt in wine.

    I've always followed my parents' advice (mum a great Italian home
    cook, and dad a chef) that if I couldn't drink the stuff, I shouldn't
    cook with it, but it was always normal bottled or even cask wine.

    Thanks in advance
    Maria
    a somewhat confused, occasional wine drinker :-)

    I believe the development of cooking wine has something to do with laws
    regarding wine sales. In many US states, it was (and often still is)
    illegal to sell "normal" wines in places other than liquor stores.
    Cooking wines were okay to sell in grocery stores.

    -T

  13. "Bernard Arnest" <[email hidden]> wrote in message
    news:[email hidden]...

    Quoted message said:

    Hi,
    In recipes that call for white wine, is cooking wine from the grocery
    store fine, or does it offer poor flavor, too much salt, or conflict
    with the rest of the seasoning vs. standard wine? I ask because this
    is my first year in college, and I'm 18, thus cooking wine is really
    the only wine, but I want to know how it might affect a recipe and how
    I might compensate.

    If non-cooking-wine is the way to go (at least when home, and my dad
    can buy it), do you have any best-value recommendations? Since it's
    cooked and not drunk, is the dirt cheapest the way to go...?

    thanks!
    -Bernard Arnest

    Keep in mind that wine freezes pretty well. If you are only using a
    small amount, pour the rest in ice cube trays, and then move it to
    plastic bags after it freezes.

    -T

  14. Richard Green said:

    Hi Bernard,
    In your situation I wouldn't waste my money on white wine for cooking. Get
    yourself a big bottle of dry vermouth. Its cheap, you only need half the
    amount, it works well in cooking and you won't be tempted to drink it "-)

    5 parts gin, 1 part dry vermouth, ice, shake (not stir), strain into
    glass, add green olive. Why wouldn't you be tempted to drink that?
    -aem

  15. Yes.........now you're talking. "Cooking martinis" - forget the bloody
    cooking "wine".
    "aem" <[email hidden]> wrote in message
    news:[email hidden]...

    Quoted message said:


    Richard Green said:

    Hi Bernard,
    In your situation I wouldn't waste my money on white wine for cooking.
    Get
    yourself a big bottle of dry vermouth. Its cheap, you only need half the
    amount, it works well in cooking and you won't be tempted to drink it "-)

    5 parts gin, 1 part dry vermouth, ice, shake (not stir), strain into
    glass, add green olive. Why wouldn't you be tempted to drink that?
    -aem

  16. "skoonj" <[email hidden]> wrote in message
    news:[email hidden]...

    Quoted message said:


    "MG" <[email hidden]> wrote in message
    news:[email hidden]...

    Quoted message said:

    <snipped a bit>

    Quoted message said:

    > In recipes that call for white wine, is cooking wine from the grocery
    > store fine, or does it offer poor flavor, too much salt, or conflict
    > with the rest of the seasoning vs. standard wine? >
    Whatever you like that's in your budget is fine. Cooking wine from
    grocery stores tends to be a bad choice because its mostly salt and low
    quality wine.

    Ok, I have to ask...I've never heard of "cooking wine" as such, and am
    wondering what the heck is salt doing in wine? I Googled a bit, but
    didn't find much about why. Cooking wine to me (and I would say with
    some confidence, most other Aussies) is "normal" wine that you cook with.

    Granted, maybe I'm just showing some ignorance about stuff from O/S, but
    I live in a great wine-growing state (Sth Australia) with many wonderful
    wineries 1 hour North of me (Barossa Valley, Clare Valley), and several
    others 1 hour South of me (McLaren Vale, Clarendon, the Southern Vales),
    and maybe even better wine country another couple of hours away
    (Coonawarra, etc), but I've never heard of salt in wine.

    I've always followed my parents' advice (mum a great Italian home cook,
    and dad a chef) that if I couldn't drink the stuff, I shouldn't cook with
    it, but it was always normal bottled or even cask wine.

    Thanks in advance
    Maria
    a somewhat confused, occasional wine drinker :-)

    I believe the development of cooking wine has something to do with laws
    regarding wine sales. In many US states, it was (and often still is)
    illegal to sell "normal" wines in places other than liquor stores. Cooking
    wines were okay to sell in grocery stores.

    -T

    OK, that must be why we don't have that here...it's also illegal here to
    sell alcoholic drinks in grocery stores, but manufacturers haven't gone the
    path of adding salt to them so they can do so (maybe there's a law against
    selling salted wines here? who knows?! lol)

    there are a couple of grocery stores/supermarkets which often have their own
    liquor store nearby or in the same shopping mall, so I guess it's just as
    convenient for the consumer to go there for their alcohol rather than expect
    it to be at the supermarket

  17. In article <[email hidden]>,

    Bernard Arnest said:

    Hi,
    In recipes that call for white wine, is cooking wine from the grocery
    store fine, or does it offer poor flavor, too much salt, or conflict
    with the rest of the seasoning vs. standard wine? I ask because this
    is my first year in college, and I'm 18, thus cooking wine is really
    the only wine, but I want to know how it might affect a recipe and how
    I might compensate.

    Quoted message said:

    thanks!
    -Bernard Arnest

    Don't cook with any wine you wouldn't drink from a glass.
    I usually have dry sherry and dry vermouth in the fridge for cooking
    purposes. Have never used a recipe that specified a particular kind of
    wine, I guess. Neither is very expensive.
    --
    -Barb, <http://www.jamlady.eboard.com> Sam I Am! updated 9-12-05

  18. In article <[email hidden]>,

    Bernard Arnest said:

    In recipes that call for white wine, is cooking wine from the grocery
    store fine, or does it offer poor flavor, too much salt, or conflict
    with the rest of the seasoning vs. standard wine?

    Salt? Ugh. I would never cook with a wine I wouldn't drink from a
    glass. Chefs I have asked have told me also, the quality of the
    food depends in good part on the quality of the ingredients. Use
    poor ingredients, get a poor result.

    Quoted message said:

    If non-cooking-wine is the way to go (at least when home, and my dad
    can buy it), do you have any best-value recommendations? Since it's
    cooked and not drunk, is the dirt cheapest the way to go...?

    If there's a Trader Joe's in your area, pick up a few bottles of
    "Two Buck Chuck" ...er, Charles Shaw wine. It's $3/bottle, and
    quite drinkable all by itself. It's cheap enough that you can use
    it for cooking, and tasty enough that you can drink it while you
    eat.

    -A
    [posted and emailed]

  19. In article <[email hidden]>,

    Bernard Arnest said:

    In recipes that call for white wine, is cooking wine from the grocery
    store fine, or does it offer poor flavor, too much salt, or conflict
    with the rest of the seasoning vs. standard wine?

    Salt? Ugh. I would never cook with a wine I wouldn't drink from a
    glass. Chefs I have asked have told me also, the quality of the
    food depends in good part on the quality of the ingredients. Use
    poor ingredients, get a poor result.

    Quoted message said:

    If non-cooking-wine is the way to go (at least when home, and my dad
    can buy it), do you have any best-value recommendations? Since it's
    cooked and not drunk, is the dirt cheapest the way to go...?

    If there's a Trader Joe's in your area, pick up a few bottles of
    "Two Buck Chuck" ...er, Charles Shaw wine. It's $3/bottle, and
    quite drinkable all by itself. It's cheap enough that you can use
    it for cooking, and tasty enough that you can drink it while you
    eat.

    -A
    [posted and emailed]

  20. In article <[email hidden]>, [email hidden] (axlq)

    Quoted message said:

    If there's a Trader Joe's in your area, pick up a few bottles of
    "Two Buck Chuck" ...er, Charles Shaw wine. It's $3/bottle, and
    quite drinkable all by itself. It's cheap enough that you can use
    it for cooking, and tasty enough that you can drink it while you
    eat.

    I second the recommendation, but the reason that it's called "two buck
    Chuck" is because it costs US$1.99, not $3.

Active in the last 60 minutes

Active in this thread

0 users · 0 guests ·0 bots ·0 total

No signed-in users are active right now.

No known search crawlers active right now.