General fitness, health and nutrition · Public discussion

German Red Chicken

Started by D.Currie · · Last activity · 114 posts · 2,681 views

This thread is locked and is currently read-only.

Thread navigation

Jump through the discussion

Go to the original post, the replies on this page, or the latest preserved contribution.

Thread details

What we know about this thread

Original section
General fitness, health and nutrition
Published
9 August 2005
Last activity
18 August 2005
Original author
D.Currie
Posts
114
Discussion status
Public discussion
Total views
2,681
Views / 30 days
0

The navigation and discussion metadata provide context. Posts remain in their original chronological order.

Showing posts 1–20 of 114
Posts remain in their original chronological order.

Text size
  1. This is probably a hopeless quest, but...

    When I was a kid, my mother worked a German restaurant, and the owner/cook
    made chicken that we always called "Red Chicken." There was probably a name
    for it on the menu, but I was a kid, so...it might have just been roast
    chicken, for all I know.

    Anyway, the place burned down, the owner moved away, and my mother was never
    able to beg, borrow or steal the secret recipe while she worked there. I
    think she even offered to buy it, but in any case, he wouldn't tell.

    The chicken was baked or roasted -- it definitely wasn't fried. It had some
    sort of coating on it. Not a breading like you'd find on fried chicken, but
    it wasn't just skin and spices, either. Maybe some kind of thin batter. I
    don't recall it being crispy or crunchy, either.

    The color was a deep mahogany reddish-brown when it was served. I have no
    idea what color it was before cooking, but it had to be some version of red.

    It wasn't overly spicy, but it had good flavor. Thinking back, I can't
    recall any one predominant flavor.

    The owner/cook was from Germany, so I'm hoping that maybe this was some sort
    of ethnic/regional dish that someone has heard of, rather than something the
    cook came up with on his own.

    Any ideas? I googled first, and I found lots of hits for curried red chicken
    and adding "German" to it didn't help, because then I got red potato salads.

    Donna

  2. "D.Currie" <[email hidden]> wrote in message
    news:[email hidden]...

    Quoted message said:

    This is probably a hopeless quest, but...

    When I was a kid, my mother worked a German restaurant, and the owner/cook
    made chicken that we always called "Red Chicken." There was probably a


    name

    Quoted message said:

    for it on the menu, but I was a kid, so...it might have just been roast
    chicken, for all I know.

    Anyway, the place burned down, the owner moved away, and my mother was


    never

    Quoted message said:

    able to beg, borrow or steal the secret recipe while she worked there. I
    think she even offered to buy it, but in any case, he wouldn't tell.

    I never understand it when people won't share their recipes. GREAT RECIPES
    ARE SUPPOSED TO BE SHARED!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

    argh.

  3. "rmg" <[email hidden]> wrote in message
    news:[email hidden]...

    Quoted message said:


    "D.Currie" <[email hidden]> wrote in message
    news:[email hidden]...

    Quoted message said:

    This is probably a hopeless quest, but...

    When I was a kid, my mother worked a German restaurant, and the
    owner/cook
    made chicken that we always called "Red Chicken." There was probably a


    name

    Quoted message said:

    for it on the menu, but I was a kid, so...it might have just been roast
    chicken, for all I know.

    Anyway, the place burned down, the owner moved away, and my mother was


    never

    Quoted message said:

    able to beg, borrow or steal the secret recipe while she worked there. I
    think she even offered to buy it, but in any case, he wouldn't tell.

    I never understand it when people won't share their recipes. GREAT RECIPES
    ARE SUPPOSED TO BE SHARED!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

    argh.

    The thing is, I can understand him not wanting to give it up while he had
    the restaurant, but after the place went up in flames and he decided not to
    reopen, I can't see how it would have hurt.

  4. You have to ask yourself this....what would Sandra Lee do in a situation
    like this?

    I bet she would fry it.

    <html><body bgcolor="black"

    text="white"></html>

  5. I am so hoping there's a great background story to this Red Chicken
    recipe, maybe involving how the dish was first prepared at a restaurant
    known as a popular meeting spot for Bolsheviks, and when the Nazi party
    took power in Germany they made it a crime to serve chicken in this
    fashion...

    Hey, if there isn't such a story, there should be.
    --
    Michael

  6. I am so hoping there's a great background story to this Red Chicken
    recipe, maybe involving how the dish was first prepared at a restaurant
    known as a popular meeting spot for Bolsheviks, and when the Nazi party
    took power in Germany they made it a crime to serve chicken in this
    fashion...

    Hey, if there isn't such a story, there should be.
    --
    Michael

  7. rmg said:

    "D.Currie" <[email hidden]> wrote in message
    news:[email hidden]...

    Quoted message said:

    This is probably a hopeless quest, but...

    When I was a kid, my mother worked a German restaurant, and the owner/cook
    made chicken that we always called "Red Chicken." There was probably a


    name

    Quoted message said:

    for it on the menu, but I was a kid, so...it might have just been roast
    chicken, for all I know.

    Anyway, the place burned down, the owner moved away, and my mother was


    never

    Quoted message said:

    able to beg, borrow or steal the secret recipe while she worked there. I
    think she even offered to buy it, but in any case, he wouldn't tell.

    I never understand it when people won't share their recipes. GREAT RECIPES
    ARE SUPPOSED TO BE SHARED!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

    argh.

    I have some recipes that I won't share, at least not now. We have
    frequent potluck luncheons at work, and I have developed several
    'signature' dishes that I like to bring -- a few desserts, a few
    entrees, and a special salad dressing. Additionally, I do small
    catering jobs during the summer and holidays to make ends meet. The
    *vast* majority of what I cook I'll happily share, in fact, I've
    organized staff cookbook projects since we have *so* many excellent
    cooks in our building. But those dishes that are the, "oh, Alex is
    bringing her _____? Yay!" dishes? Nope, those are mine. None of them
    are overly difficult to make, but they're signature dishes. I have
    them written down, and if I die suddenly, they'll go to a friend of
    mine as part of my personal cookbook, but until then, I'd rather not
    have everyone and their brother-in-law making them. Most of the casual
    cooks I know have at least one, if not several, of these recipes that
    they don't share, and it's never once bothered me when I've asked for a
    recipe and they've said, "sorry, not that one."

    Alexis.

    (I had a friend, Amy, who was a wonderful seamstress, and over the
    years she developed several patterns for gift items, including one
    perfect baby blanket/towel/hoodie combination set. They were
    beautiful, and, I'm told, ideal for one-handed wet-baby drying and
    swaddling. For years these were known around town, and her pregnant
    friends looked forward to having one of the few around. Then Amy
    shared the pattern with someone from work who "wanted one for [her]
    sister down in the states" and Amy didn't have time to make one then.
    Two months later, Amy was at the Saturday Market (a big outdoor vendor
    market that takes place here every weekend during the summer) and there
    in a stall was this other woman, surrounded by a big selection of Amy's
    blanket sets. The woman had taken her pattern, duplicated it on her
    own, and was selling the blankets *and* a copy of the pattern. No, it
    wasn't the end of the world, but Amy was understandably upset by it.)

  8. rmg said:

    "D.Currie" <[email hidden]> wrote in message
    news:[email hidden]...

    Quoted message said:

    This is probably a hopeless quest, but...

    When I was a kid, my mother worked a German restaurant, and the owner/cook
    made chicken that we always called "Red Chicken." There was probably a


    name

    Quoted message said:

    for it on the menu, but I was a kid, so...it might have just been roast
    chicken, for all I know.

    Anyway, the place burned down, the owner moved away, and my mother was


    never

    Quoted message said:

    able to beg, borrow or steal the secret recipe while she worked there. I
    think she even offered to buy it, but in any case, he wouldn't tell.

    I never understand it when people won't share their recipes. GREAT RECIPES
    ARE SUPPOSED TO BE SHARED!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

    argh.

    I have some recipes that I won't share, at least not now. We have
    frequent potluck luncheons at work, and I have developed several
    'signature' dishes that I like to bring -- a few desserts, a few
    entrees, and a special salad dressing. Additionally, I do small
    catering jobs during the summer and holidays to make ends meet. The
    *vast* majority of what I cook I'll happily share, in fact, I've
    organized staff cookbook projects since we have *so* many excellent
    cooks in our building. But those dishes that are the, "oh, Alex is
    bringing her _____? Yay!" dishes? Nope, those are mine. None of them
    are overly difficult to make, but they're signature dishes. I have
    them written down, and if I die suddenly, they'll go to a friend of
    mine as part of my personal cookbook, but until then, I'd rather not
    have everyone and their brother-in-law making them. Most of the casual
    cooks I know have at least one, if not several, of these recipes that
    they don't share, and it's never once bothered me when I've asked for a
    recipe and they've said, "sorry, not that one."

    Alexis.

    (I had a friend, Amy, who was a wonderful seamstress, and over the
    years she developed several patterns for gift items, including one
    perfect baby blanket/towel/hoodie combination set. They were
    beautiful, and, I'm told, ideal for one-handed wet-baby drying and
    swaddling. For years these were known around town, and her pregnant
    friends looked forward to having one of the few around. Then Amy
    shared the pattern with someone from work who "wanted one for [her]
    sister down in the states" and Amy didn't have time to make one then.
    Two months later, Amy was at the Saturday Market (a big outdoor vendor
    market that takes place here every weekend during the summer) and there
    in a stall was this other woman, surrounded by a big selection of Amy's
    blanket sets. The woman had taken her pattern, duplicated it on her
    own, and was selling the blankets *and* a copy of the pattern. No, it
    wasn't the end of the world, but Amy was understandably upset by it.)

  9. [email hidden] (D.Currie)WROTE:
    This is probably a hopeless quest, but...
    When I was a kid, my mother worked a German restaurant, and the
    owner/cook made chicken that we always called "Red Chicken." There was
    probably a name for it on the menu, but I was a kid, so...it might have
    just been roast chicken, for all I know.
    Anyway, the place burned down, the owner moved away, and my mother was
    never able to beg, borrow or steal the secret recipe while she worked
    there. I think she even offered to buy it, but in any case, he wouldn't
    tell.
    The chicken was baked or roasted -- it definitely wasn't fried. It had
    some sort of coating on it. Not a breading like you'd find on fried
    chicken, but it wasn't just skin and spices, either. Maybe some kind of
    thin batter. I don't recall it being crispy or crunchy, either.
    The color was a deep mahogany reddish-brown when it was served. I have
    no idea what color it was before cooking, but it had to be some version
    of red.
    It wasn't overly spicy, but it had good flavor. Thinking back, I can't
    recall any one predominant flavor.
    The owner/cook was from Germany, so I'm hoping that maybe this was some
    sort of ethnic/regional dish that someone has heard of, rather than
    something the cook came up with on his own.
    Any ideas? I googled first, and I found lots of hits for curried red
    chicken and adding "German" to it didn't help, because then I got red
    potato salads.
    Donna ------------------------------------------------------
    RESPONSE: Try calling german community centers etc. in your area and see
    if they can help. I know in the past they helped me locate hard to find
    holiday foods & recipes I wanted to serve @ Christmas Eve dinner in
    honor of my b/f's grandfather who hailed from germany.
    Gut feeling though this recipe your searching for is not german but
    something this owner made up himself.

  10. On Mon 08 Aug 2005 08:57:00p, Alexis wrote in rec.food.cooking:

    Quoted message said:

    I have some recipes that I won't share, at least not now. We have
    frequent potluck luncheons at work, and I have developed several
    'signature' dishes that I like to bring -- a few desserts, a few
    entrees, and a special salad dressing. Additionally, I do small
    catering jobs during the summer and holidays to make ends meet. The
    *vast* majority of what I cook I'll happily share, in fact, I've
    organized staff cookbook projects since we have *so* many excellent
    cooks in our building. But those dishes that are the, "oh, Alex is
    bringing her _____? Yay!" dishes? Nope, those are mine. None of them
    are overly difficult to make, but they're signature dishes. I have
    them written down, and if I die suddenly, they'll go to a friend of
    mine as part of my personal cookbook, but until then, I'd rather not
    have everyone and their brother-in-law making them. Most of the casual
    cooks I know have at least one, if not several, of these recipes that
    they don't share, and it's never once bothered me when I've asked for a
    recipe and they've said, "sorry, not that one."

    Alexis.

    You have your reasons, of course, but I don't have any such reasons. I
    will gladly share any recipe I have. Truth be told, most people who would
    try to duplicate my recipes will not have identical results, due mainly to
    cooking technique or the inability to "taste and adjust". I have even been
    accused of not giving someone the correct recipe a couple times, but that
    wasn't the case.

    --
    Wayne Boatwright *¿*
    ____________________________________________

    Give me a smart idiot over a stupid genius any day.
    Sam Goldwyn, 1882-1974

    ---
    avast! Antivirus: Outbound message clean.
    Virus Database (VPS): 0532-0, 08/08/2005
    Tested on: 8/8/2005 9:43:57 PM
    avast! - copyright (c) 1988-2005 ALWIL Software.
    http://www.avast.com

  11. On Mon 08 Aug 2005 08:57:00p, Alexis wrote in rec.food.cooking:

    Quoted message said:

    I have some recipes that I won't share, at least not now. We have
    frequent potluck luncheons at work, and I have developed several
    'signature' dishes that I like to bring -- a few desserts, a few
    entrees, and a special salad dressing. Additionally, I do small
    catering jobs during the summer and holidays to make ends meet. The
    *vast* majority of what I cook I'll happily share, in fact, I've
    organized staff cookbook projects since we have *so* many excellent
    cooks in our building. But those dishes that are the, "oh, Alex is
    bringing her _____? Yay!" dishes? Nope, those are mine. None of them
    are overly difficult to make, but they're signature dishes. I have
    them written down, and if I die suddenly, they'll go to a friend of
    mine as part of my personal cookbook, but until then, I'd rather not
    have everyone and their brother-in-law making them. Most of the casual
    cooks I know have at least one, if not several, of these recipes that
    they don't share, and it's never once bothered me when I've asked for a
    recipe and they've said, "sorry, not that one."

    Alexis.

    You have your reasons, of course, but I don't have any such reasons. I
    will gladly share any recipe I have. Truth be told, most people who would
    try to duplicate my recipes will not have identical results, due mainly to
    cooking technique or the inability to "taste and adjust". I have even been
    accused of not giving someone the correct recipe a couple times, but that
    wasn't the case.

    --
    Wayne Boatwright *¿*
    ____________________________________________

    Give me a smart idiot over a stupid genius any day.
    Sam Goldwyn, 1882-1974

    ---
    avast! Antivirus: Outbound message clean.
    Virus Database (VPS): 0532-0, 08/08/2005
    Tested on: 8/8/2005 9:43:57 PM
    avast! - copyright (c) 1988-2005 ALWIL Software.
    http://www.avast.com

  12. "Wayne Boatwright" <[email hidden]> wrote in message
    news:[email hidden]...

    Quoted message said:

    On Mon 08 Aug 2005 08:57:00p, Alexis wrote in rec.food.cooking:

    Quoted message said:

    I have some recipes that I won't share, at least not now. We have
    frequent potluck luncheons at work, and I have developed several
    'signature' dishes that I like to bring -- a few desserts, a few
    entrees, and a special salad dressing. Additionally, I do small
    catering jobs during the summer and holidays to make ends meet. The
    *vast* majority of what I cook I'll happily share, in fact, I've
    organized staff cookbook projects since we have *so* many excellent
    cooks in our building. But those dishes that are the, "oh, Alex is
    bringing her _____? Yay!" dishes? Nope, those are mine. None of them
    are overly difficult to make, but they're signature dishes. I have
    them written down, and if I die suddenly, they'll go to a friend of
    mine as part of my personal cookbook, but until then, I'd rather not
    have everyone and their brother-in-law making them. Most of the casual
    cooks I know have at least one, if not several, of these recipes that
    they don't share, and it's never once bothered me when I've asked for a
    recipe and they've said, "sorry, not that one."

    Alexis.

    You have your reasons, of course, but I don't have any such reasons. I
    will gladly share any recipe I have. Truth be told, most people who would
    try to duplicate my recipes will not have identical results, due mainly to
    cooking technique or the inability to "taste and adjust". I have even
    been
    accused of not giving someone the correct recipe a couple times, but that
    wasn't the case.

    --
    Wayne Boatwright *¿*

    The things I cook most often, I don't even have recipes for, I just cook
    'em. And some things, like soup, I just wing it with whatever I've got on
    hand. But if somebody really wanted one of my recipes, I could at least give
    out ingredients and a general idea of how it's done.

    I can see why the restaurant owner didn't want to give out his recipe while
    he had the restaurant, but after he went out of business, and he had no kids
    to pass the recipe down to, it probably just vanished.

  13. "Michael in Maryland" <[email hidden]> wrote in message
    news:[email hidden]...

    Quoted message said:

    I am so hoping there's a great background story to this Red Chicken
    recipe, maybe involving how the dish was first prepared at a restaurant
    known as a popular meeting spot for Bolsheviks, and when the Nazi party
    took power in Germany they made it a crime to serve chicken in this
    fashion...

    Hey, if there isn't such a story, there should be.
    --
    Michael

    Somebody finds me a recipe, I'll write an appropriate story.

  14. D.Currie said:

    This is probably a hopeless quest, but...

    When I was a kid, my mother worked a German restaurant, and the owner/cook
    made chicken that we always called "Red Chicken." There was probably a name
    for it on the menu, but I was a kid, so...it might have just been roast
    chicken, for all I know.

    Anyway, the place burned down, the owner moved away, and my mother was never
    able to beg, borrow or steal the secret recipe while she worked there. I
    think she even offered to buy it, but in any case, he wouldn't tell.

    The chicken was baked or roasted -- it definitely wasn't fried. It had some
    sort of coating on it. Not a breading like you'd find on fried chicken, but
    it wasn't just skin and spices, either. Maybe some kind of thin batter. I
    don't recall it being crispy or crunchy, either.

    The color was a deep mahogany reddish-brown when it was served. I have no
    idea what color it was before cooking, but it had to be some version of red.

    It wasn't overly spicy, but it had good flavor. Thinking back, I can't
    recall any one predominant flavor.

    The owner/cook was from Germany, so I'm hoping that maybe this was some sort
    of ethnic/regional dish that someone has heard of, rather than something the
    cook came up with on his own.

    Any ideas? I googled first, and I found lots of hits for curried red chicken
    and adding "German" to it didn't help, because then I got red potato salads.

    Donna

    You got me curious so I did a search too (Google: "recipe" "red
    chicken" "german"😉 and came up with this recipe which I've cut and
    pasted below. There were 2 "5 star" reviews on the site for the recipe
    and I think I'll try it - something new to do with chicken breasts. If
    it's the same type of recipe the cook refused to share, I can
    understand why he might have been so tightlipped - it could have been
    his recipe was so simple he was embarrassed to share the "big secret."
    Nancy

    Balsamic/Paprika Marinated Chicken #61779
    Red chicken! nice, smoky taste. TOO EASY

    1 lb boneless skinless chicken breasts
    1/8 cup balsamic vinegar
    1/4 cup canola oil
    1/2 tablespoon olive oil
    1/2-7/8 tablespoon paprika
    1/4 tablespoon garlic powder
    1/4-1/2 teaspoon salt
    fresh ground black pepper
    Mix everything but the chicken in a quart mason jar, shake to combine.
    Pour over trimmed chicken breasts and marinate, refrigerated, for 4-48
    hours.
    Broil about 2" from the element or grill in batches with 1" space
    around the breasts, 7 minutes per side (give or take). (serves 4)
    http://www.recipezaar.com/recipe/getrecipe.zsp?scaleto=4&id=61779

  15. D.Currie said:

    This is probably a hopeless quest, but...

    When I was a kid, my mother worked a German restaurant, and the owner/cook
    made chicken that we always called "Red Chicken." There was probably a name
    for it on the menu, but I was a kid, so...it might have just been roast
    chicken, for all I know.

    Anyway, the place burned down, the owner moved away, and my mother was never
    able to beg, borrow or steal the secret recipe while she worked there. I
    think she even offered to buy it, but in any case, he wouldn't tell.

    The chicken was baked or roasted -- it definitely wasn't fried. It had some
    sort of coating on it. Not a breading like you'd find on fried chicken, but
    it wasn't just skin and spices, either. Maybe some kind of thin batter. I
    don't recall it being crispy or crunchy, either.

    The color was a deep mahogany reddish-brown when it was served. I have no
    idea what color it was before cooking, but it had to be some version of red.

    It wasn't overly spicy, but it had good flavor. Thinking back, I can't
    recall any one predominant flavor.

    The owner/cook was from Germany, so I'm hoping that maybe this was some sort
    of ethnic/regional dish that someone has heard of, rather than something the
    cook came up with on his own.

    Any ideas? I googled first, and I found lots of hits for curried red chicken
    and adding "German" to it didn't help, because then I got red potato salads.

    Donna

    You got me curious so I did a search too (Google: "recipe" "red
    chicken" "german"😉 and came up with this recipe which I've cut and
    pasted below. There were 2 "5 star" reviews on the site for the recipe
    and I think I'll try it - something new to do with chicken breasts. If
    it's the same type of recipe the cook refused to share, I can
    understand why he might have been so tightlipped - it could have been
    his recipe was so simple he was embarrassed to share the "big secret."
    Nancy

    Balsamic/Paprika Marinated Chicken #61779
    Red chicken! nice, smoky taste. TOO EASY

    1 lb boneless skinless chicken breasts
    1/8 cup balsamic vinegar
    1/4 cup canola oil
    1/2 tablespoon olive oil
    1/2-7/8 tablespoon paprika
    1/4 tablespoon garlic powder
    1/4-1/2 teaspoon salt
    fresh ground black pepper
    Mix everything but the chicken in a quart mason jar, shake to combine.
    Pour over trimmed chicken breasts and marinate, refrigerated, for 4-48
    hours.
    Broil about 2" from the element or grill in batches with 1" space
    around the breasts, 7 minutes per side (give or take). (serves 4)
    http://www.recipezaar.com/recipe/getrecipe.zsp?scaleto=4&id=61779

  16. Alexis said:

    Then Amy
    shared the pattern with someone from work who "wanted one for [her]
    sister down in the states" and Amy didn't have time to make one then.
    Two months later, Amy was at the Saturday Market (a big outdoor vendor
    market that takes place here every weekend during the summer) and there
    in a stall was this other woman, surrounded by a big selection of Amy's
    blanket sets. The woman had taken her pattern, duplicated it on her
    own, and was selling the blankets *and* a copy of the pattern. No, it
    wasn't the end of the world, but Amy was understandably upset by it.)

    Amy owned the pattern. She also owned the copyright. I'd have gone
    after the woman in a very serious manner.

    --
    -denny-

    "I don't like it when a whole state starts
    acting like a marital aid."
    "John R. Campbell" in a Usenet post.

  17. Alexis said:

    Then Amy
    shared the pattern with someone from work who "wanted one for [her]
    sister down in the states" and Amy didn't have time to make one then.
    Two months later, Amy was at the Saturday Market (a big outdoor vendor
    market that takes place here every weekend during the summer) and there
    in a stall was this other woman, surrounded by a big selection of Amy's
    blanket sets. The woman had taken her pattern, duplicated it on her
    own, and was selling the blankets *and* a copy of the pattern. No, it
    wasn't the end of the world, but Amy was understandably upset by it.)

    Amy owned the pattern. She also owned the copyright. I'd have gone
    after the woman in a very serious manner.

    --
    -denny-

    "I don't like it when a whole state starts
    acting like a marital aid."
    "John R. Campbell" in a Usenet post.

  18. Alexis said:

    I have some recipes that I won't share, at least not now. We have
    frequent potluck luncheons at work, and I have developed several
    'signature' dishes that I like to bring -- a few desserts, a few
    entrees, and a special salad dressing. Additionally, I do small
    catering jobs during the summer and holidays to make ends meet. The
    *vast* majority of what I cook I'll happily share, in fact, I've
    organized staff cookbook projects since we have *so* many excellent
    cooks in our building. But those dishes that are the, "oh, Alex is
    bringing her _____? Yay!" dishes? Nope, those are mine.

    That's just stupid and arrogant.

    Quoted message said:

    None of them
    are overly difficult to make, but they're signature dishes. I have
    them written down, and if I die suddenly, they'll go to a friend of
    mine as part of my personal cookbook, but until then, I'd rather not
    have everyone and their brother-in-law making them.

    Why not? Are you afraid someone migh improve on them? That's just
    silly and selfish.

    Quoted message said:

    Most of the casual
    cooks I know have at least one, if not several, of these recipes that
    they don't share, and it's never once bothered me when I've asked for a
    recipe and they've said, "sorry, not that one."

    Alexis.

    I totally don't understand this mentality. AT ALL. Big deal - you
    make a couple good dishes. It's ridiculous to think they are so
    important that you can't share them with others.

    -L.
    <rolling eyeballs>

  19. Alexis said:

    I have some recipes that I won't share, at least not now. We have
    frequent potluck luncheons at work, and I have developed several
    'signature' dishes that I like to bring -- a few desserts, a few
    entrees, and a special salad dressing. Additionally, I do small
    catering jobs during the summer and holidays to make ends meet. The
    *vast* majority of what I cook I'll happily share, in fact, I've
    organized staff cookbook projects since we have *so* many excellent
    cooks in our building. But those dishes that are the, "oh, Alex is
    bringing her _____? Yay!" dishes? Nope, those are mine.

    That's just stupid and arrogant.

    Quoted message said:

    None of them
    are overly difficult to make, but they're signature dishes. I have
    them written down, and if I die suddenly, they'll go to a friend of
    mine as part of my personal cookbook, but until then, I'd rather not
    have everyone and their brother-in-law making them.

    Why not? Are you afraid someone migh improve on them? That's just
    silly and selfish.

    Quoted message said:

    Most of the casual
    cooks I know have at least one, if not several, of these recipes that
    they don't share, and it's never once bothered me when I've asked for a
    recipe and they've said, "sorry, not that one."

    Alexis.

    I totally don't understand this mentality. AT ALL. Big deal - you
    make a couple good dishes. It's ridiculous to think they are so
    important that you can't share them with others.

    -L.
    <rolling eyeballs>

  20. D.Currie said:

    The things I cook most often, I don't even have recipes for, I just cook
    'em. And some things, like soup, I just wing it with whatever I've got on
    hand. But if somebody really wanted one of my recipes, I could at least give
    out ingredients and a general idea of how it's done.

    That's pretty much how I cook as well. I try to write down my
    "recipes" as often as I can now because when my Mom died many of her
    recipes died with her, because she cooked the same way, and not much
    was written down. It was such a shame. She was probably one of the
    best cooks I have ever encountered.

    Quoted message said:


    I can see why the restaurant owner didn't want to give out his recipe while
    he had the restaurant, but after he went out of business, and he had no kids
    to pass the recipe down to, it probably just vanished.

    IMO, a good restauranteur will share recipes. It's not like I am going
    to dine there any less often because I have a recipe or two, if he is
    the master chef I think he is. I dine out when *I* don't want to cook,
    afterall.

    -L.

Active in the last 60 minutes

Active in this thread

0 users · 0 guests ·0 bots ·0 total

No signed-in users are active right now.

No known search crawlers active right now.