General fitness, health and nutrition · Public discussion

Ribeye steaks

Started by Renee · · Last activity · 105 posts · 4,146 views

This thread is locked and is currently read-only.

Thread navigation

Jump through the discussion

Go to the original post, the replies on this page, or the latest preserved contribution.

Thread details

What we know about this thread

Original section
General fitness, health and nutrition
Published
6 August 2005
Last activity
11 August 2005
Original author
Renee
Posts
105
Discussion status
Public discussion
Total views
4,146
Views / 30 days
0

The navigation and discussion metadata provide context. Posts remain in their original chronological order.

Showing posts 1–20 of 105
Posts remain in their original chronological order.

Text size
  1. Picked up some great looking Choice ribeyes yesterday at Winn Dixie for
    $4.99 / lb. In spite of the fact that I hate shopping at any Winn Dixie, I
    don't go there regularly, and their stores are depressing and ugly, their
    meat is always very good.

    Ribeyes are supposed to be one of the most flavorful cuts of meats. These
    are really thick so each one can easily feed two people.

    Can anyone tell me more about this cut of meat? If this were a Prime cut
    instead of Choice and cut off the bone, would it be a Filet of Prime Rib?

    TIA

    Renee

  2. Renee said:

    Picked up some great looking Choice ribeyes yesterday at Winn Dixie for
    $4.99 / lb. In spite of the fact that I hate shopping at any Winn Dixie, I
    don't go there regularly, and their stores are depressing and ugly, their
    meat is always very good.

    Ribeyes are supposed to be one of the most flavorful cuts of meats.

    Ribeye IS the *least* flavorful cut of beef... it's for those who
    really don't like the taste of beef... ribeye is the tofu/American
    cheese of beef. Why do you think rib portions are so popular, same
    reason chicken breasts are, same reason for the popularity of American
    cheese. From an anatomical aspect there really is no logical reason
    for rib to cost more than chuck, it's just that the demand for
    flavorless beef is so high.

    Sheldon

  3. Sheldon said:


    Renee said:

    Picked up some great looking Choice ribeyes yesterday at Winn Dixie for
    $4.99 / lb. In spite of the fact that I hate shopping at any Winn Dixie, I
    don't go there regularly, and their stores are depressing and ugly, their
    meat is always very good.

    Ribeyes are supposed to be one of the most flavorful cuts of meats.

    Ribeye IS the *least* flavorful cut of beef... it's for those who
    really don't like the taste of beef... ribeye is the tofu/American
    cheese of beef. Why do you think rib portions are so popular, same
    reason chicken breasts are, same reason for the popularity of American
    cheese. From an anatomical aspect there really is no logical reason
    for rib to cost more than chuck, it's just that the demand for
    flavorless beef is so high.

    Sheldon

    Once more you expose yourself as full of [censored]. Back into the
    killfile.

    Boron

  4. Renee said:

    Picked up some great looking Choice ribeyes yesterday at Winn Dixie for

    Quoted message said:

    Ribeyes are supposed to be one of the most flavorful cuts of meats. These
    are really thick so each one can easily feed two people.

    Quoted message said:

    Can anyone tell me more about this cut of meat? If this were a Prime cut
    instead of Choice and cut off the bone, would it be a Filet of Prime Rib?

    Huh? Ribeyes are by definition cut off the bone. In my
    opinion rib steaks with the bone have more flavor, but ribeyes
    are still good. So what is it you have ribeyes or rib steaks?

    Let's not get into the prime-rib-is-a-cut vs prime-rib-is-a-grade
    debate again. A ribeye is a ribeye regardless of grade, and
    that means off the bone.

    Bill Ranck
    Blacksburg, Va.

  5. Sheldon said:
    Renee said:

    Picked up some great looking Choice ribeyes yesterday at Winn Dixie for
    $4.99 / lb. In spite of the fact that I hate shopping at any Winn Dixie, I
    don't go there regularly, and their stores are depressing and ugly, their
    meat is always very good.

    Ribeyes are supposed to be one of the most flavorful cuts of meats.

    Ribeye IS the *least* flavorful cut of beef... it's for those who
    really don't like the taste of beef... ribeye is the tofu/American
    cheese of beef.

    [censored]. Rib eye steaks are quite tasty.

  6. Quoted message said:


    Huh? Ribeyes are by definition cut off the bone.

    So is every other cut of beef cut off the bone, bonehead.

    Sheldon

  7. Sheldon said:
    Renee said:

    Picked up some great looking Choice ribeyes yesterday at Winn Dixie for
    $4.99 / lb. In spite of the fact that I hate shopping at any Winn Dixie, I
    don't go there regularly, and their stores are depressing and ugly, their
    meat is always very good.

    Ribeyes are supposed to be one of the most flavorful cuts of meats.

    Ribeye IS the *least* flavorful cut of beef... it's for those who
    really don't like the taste of beef... ribeye is the tofu/American
    cheese of beef. Why do you think rib portions are so popular, same
    reason chicken breasts are, same reason for the popularity of American
    cheese. From an anatomical aspect there really is no logical reason
    for rib to cost more than chuck, it's just that the demand for
    flavorless beef is so high.

    Sheldon


    You bored again Sheldon? 😉 Okay. I'll agree with you, just to give you
    something to read 🙂
    Cheers
    Cathy - (chuckle)

  8. Sheldon said:
    Quoted message said:


    Huh? Ribeyes are by definition cut off the bone.

    Quoted message said:

    So is every other cut of beef cut off the bone, bonehead.

    So, you've never seen a rib steak with the bone? Or a T-bone?
    You do lead a sheltered life.

    Bill Ranck
    Blacksburg, Va.

  9. cathyxyz said:
    Quoted message said:
    Quoted message said:


    You bored again Sheldon? 😉 Okay. I'll agree with you.

    See how easy it is to expose the taste-in-assers.

    Sheldon

  10. Renee said:

    Picked up some great looking Choice ribeyes yesterday at Winn Dixie for
    $4.99 / lb. <snip>

    I really envy you for the great price. Where I live choice ribeye
    steaks sell for $16.99/lb. A once-in-a-while sale price is usually
    $11.99/lb.

    Quoted message said:

    Ribeyes are supposed to be one of the most flavorful cuts of meats.

    Many people, myself included, think they are the most flavorful.

    Quoted message said:


    Can anyone tell me more about this cut of meat? If this were a Prime cut
    instead of Choice and cut off the bone, would it be a Filet of Prime Rib?

    The ribeye is taken, as the name indicates, from the rib and is the
    central muscle in the rib. If you look at a rib roast, that meat at
    the "heart" of the roast is the "ribeye".

    Two comments about the word "prime":

    1. "Prime" is a USDA classification, or grade, for meat (in this case,
    beef) which is well-marbeled and meets some other criteria. It is the
    highest classification, just above the "choice" classification, and its
    price will be considerably higher than that for choice.

    2. A "prime rib roast" is a term used to describe what is also called
    a standing rib roast. In this usage the term does *not* refer to the
    USDA grade of the beef(in fact, adding to the confusion, a "prime rib
    roast" may have a USDA grade of "choice"😉.

    If you bought a prime (USDA grade) ribeye without the rib bone the
    steak could be called a ribeye or possibly a Delmonico, altho that name
    isn't used much anymore. The names given to retail pieces of beef refer
    to the part of the animal the cut came from, not the USDA grade. For
    example, a ribeye steak could be choice, or select, or ungraded (there
    is another grade but that grade isn't seen in retail markets).

    The term "filet" refers to a cut from the tenderloin, which is not part
    of the rib structure. The tenderloin, like that other cuts of beef,
    will be graded also but the grade is separate from the name of the cut.

    Now that I've shed such light on the subject........

    Mac

  11. <[email hidden]> wrote in message
    news:[email hidden]...

    Quoted message said:


    Renee said:

    Picked up some great looking Choice ribeyes yesterday at Winn Dixie for
    $4.99 / lb. <snip>

    I really envy you for the great price. Where I live choice ribeye
    steaks sell for $16.99/lb. A once-in-a-while sale price is usually
    $11.99/lb.

    Quoted message said:

    Ribeyes are supposed to be one of the most flavorful cuts of meats.

    Many people, myself included, think they are the most flavorful.

    Quoted message said:


    Can anyone tell me more about this cut of meat? If this were a Prime cut
    instead of Choice and cut off the bone, would it be a Filet of Prime Rib?

    The ribeye is taken, as the name indicates, from the rib and is the
    central muscle in the rib. If you look at a rib roast, that meat at
    the "heart" of the roast is the "ribeye".

    Two comments about the word "prime":

    1. "Prime" is a USDA classification, or grade, for meat (in this case,
    beef) which is well-marbeled and meets some other criteria. It is the
    highest classification, just above the "choice" classification, and its
    price will be considerably higher than that for choice.

    2. A "prime rib roast" is a term used to describe what is also called
    a standing rib roast. In this usage the term does *not* refer to the
    USDA grade of the beef(in fact, adding to the confusion, a "prime rib
    roast" may have a USDA grade of "choice"😉.

    If you bought a prime (USDA grade) ribeye without the rib bone the
    steak could be called a ribeye or possibly a Delmonico, altho that name
    isn't used much anymore. The names given to retail pieces of beef refer
    to the part of the animal the cut came from, not the USDA grade. For
    example, a ribeye steak could be choice, or select, or ungraded (there
    is another grade but that grade isn't seen in retail markets).

    The term "filet" refers to a cut from the tenderloin, which is not part
    of the rib structure. The tenderloin, like that other cuts of beef,
    will be graded also but the grade is separate from the name of the cut.

    Now that I've shed such light on the subject........

    Mac

    The regular price for Choice at this market is $8.99 / lb. Your prices at
    $16.99 are really high. Even lobster is a lot less than that around here.

    Thanks for taking the time with your explanation. All that prime, and rib,
    and standing stuff has always confused me. Never tried cooking one before,
    but prime rib roast is on my list of things to serve to company some day.

  12. Goomba38 said:
    Sheldon said:

    Ribeye IS the *least* flavorful cut of beef... it's for those who
    really don't like the taste of beef... ribeye is the tofu/American
    cheese of beef. Why do you think rib portions are so popular, same
    reason chicken breasts are, same reason for the popularity of American
    cheese. From an anatomical aspect there really is no logical reason
    for rib to cost more than chuck, it's just that the demand for
    flavorless beef is so high.

    Sheldon


    I like Ribeyes, Shel. I know you don't but I've had VERY tasty ones. I
    think they've got a bit of fat in 'em so they're very tasty. They run
    about $6.99/pound here.

    Never said I don't like them, just not my favorite, they have tender
    texture but ribeyes haven't much flavor... yeah, if you doll them up
    with lotsa garlic, pepper, and salt, and serve with creamy horseradish
    sauce, steak sauce, or salty au jus then they have flavor, but none of
    their own.

    Quoted message said:

    Another steak I don't do enough of is flank. I
    love a good marinated grilled flank steak.

    Flank steak is a whole nother matter, not much on tenderness but
    extremely flavorful all on its own, in fact you can smother them in
    onions roasted peppers, and spicey hot salsa and still their rich
    beefyness shines through.

    Sheldon

  13. dwacon

    . said:

    I would marinade it overnight in a nice dark Ale... and then blacken it
    Cajun style with lots of spices.

    Yup, gots to treat em like tofu and chicken breasts... marinate well
    and a good hot stir fry with lotsa spice.

    Sheldon

  14. Renee said:

    Thanks for taking the time with your explanation. All that prime, and rib,
    and standing stuff has always confused me. Never tried cooking one before,
    but prime rib roast is on my list of things to serve to company some day.

    A standing rib (or 'prime rib'--I don't use that term simply because
    it's almost impossible to buy prime at retail) roast is a Very Good
    Thing indeed. Spendy, but oh, so yummy.

    --
    -denny-

    "I don't like it when a whole state starts
    acting like a marital aid."
    "John R. Campbell" in a Usenet post.

  15. In article <[email hidden]>, Andy <Q>

    Quoted message said:

    Stan Horwitz <[email hidden]> wrote in
    news:[email hidden]:

    Quoted message said:

    In article <[email hidden]>, Andy <Q>

    Quoted message said:

    "Renee" <[email hidden]> wrote in news:981Je.37240$iG6.27701
    @tornado.tampabay.rr.com:

    > Ribeyes are supposed to be one of the most flavorful cuts of meats.

    Renee,

    I've never seen a rib eye steak on a menu. Porterhouse, t-bone, strip
    or filet mignon. I guess it's got more fat than the others.

    When the price is right, I buy bone-in rib eye to grind into
    hamburger. It makes the best burgers. Saute some onion in the grease,
    toss some cheese on, and damn if it's not a cheesesteak on a bun.

    Maybe its a regional thing, but ribeye steak is found on the menu of
    most steak houses in the Philadelphia, New Jersey area where I live
    and elsewhere in the United States. In fact, I am going out to dinner
    with some friends tonight to a local steak house and I am sure the
    menu there will include a ribeye. In fact, Ruth Chris Steak House has
    a ribeye on their menu. See
    http://www.ruthschris.com/menu/entrees.html for yourself.

    Stan,

    Ruth's Chris and Morton's are first-rate steak houses. But on the
    average, to make a profit, most restaurants offer the more requested
    cuts. Imho.

    How about Outback Steakhouse? No one could claim the Outback Steakhouse
    chain is first rate. The food at the Outback Steakhouse is not bad, but
    its not on the level of the food at Ruth's Chris.

    Some friends and I went for an early dinner today at the Outback
    Steakhouse on Route 38 in Mount Laurel, NJ. This was at 2:00pm and the
    steakhouse we really wanted to eat at was not yet opened, so the Outback
    Steakhouse was our second choice. The first steak listed on the menu was
    a ribeye. That steak was also one of the cheapest steaks there. I was
    being treated for dinner, so in order to avoid being greedy, I ordered a
    ribeye. It tasted okay, but it was a bit too dry and too fatty. I made
    the mistake of ordering it medium well. I should have known better and
    ordered it medium, which is what the waitress suggested.

  16. In article <[email hidden]>, Andy <Q>

    Quoted message said:

    Stan Horwitz <[email hidden]> wrote in
    news:[email hidden]:

    Quoted message said:

    In article <[email hidden]>, Andy <Q>

    Quoted message said:

    "Renee" <[email hidden]> wrote in news:981Je.37240$iG6.27701
    @tornado.tampabay.rr.com:

    > Ribeyes are supposed to be one of the most flavorful cuts of meats.

    Renee,

    I've never seen a rib eye steak on a menu. Porterhouse, t-bone, strip
    or filet mignon. I guess it's got more fat than the others.

    When the price is right, I buy bone-in rib eye to grind into
    hamburger. It makes the best burgers. Saute some onion in the grease,
    toss some cheese on, and damn if it's not a cheesesteak on a bun.

    Maybe its a regional thing, but ribeye steak is found on the menu of
    most steak houses in the Philadelphia, New Jersey area where I live
    and elsewhere in the United States. In fact, I am going out to dinner
    with some friends tonight to a local steak house and I am sure the
    menu there will include a ribeye. In fact, Ruth Chris Steak House has
    a ribeye on their menu. See
    http://www.ruthschris.com/menu/entrees.html for yourself.

    Stan,

    Ruth's Chris and Morton's are first-rate steak houses. But on the
    average, to make a profit, most restaurants offer the more requested
    cuts. Imho.

    How about Outback Steakhouse? No one could claim the Outback Steakhouse
    chain is first rate. The food at the Outback Steakhouse is not bad, but
    its not on the level of the food at Ruth's Chris.

    Some friends and I went for an early dinner today at the Outback
    Steakhouse on Route 38 in Mount Laurel, NJ. This was at 2:00pm and the
    steakhouse we really wanted to eat at was not yet opened, so the Outback
    Steakhouse was our second choice. The first steak listed on the menu was
    a ribeye. That steak was also one of the cheapest steaks there. I was
    being treated for dinner, so in order to avoid being greedy, I ordered a
    ribeye. It tasted okay, but it was a bit too dry and too fatty. I made
    the mistake of ordering it medium well. I should have known better and
    ordered it medium, which is what the waitress suggested.

  17. Stan Horwitz <[email hidden]> wrote in news:stan-3CB179.20353606082005
    @news.giganews.com:

    Quoted message said:

    Some friends and I went for an early dinner today at the Outback
    Steakhouse

    Enuf said.

    Back in 2000, at the US Boomerang Nationals in Virginia Beach, our
    sponsors were Outback and Fosters.

    We were forced to eat Outback steaks and chicken during a recess, and
    drink Fosters beer.

    The temperature on the field was 114 degrees at midday and the Outback
    [censored] was full of salt and spicy-hot which was kinda/sorta awful at the
    time.

    Fosters Beer = [censored] Water brewed in Canada. No fault of Canada, mind ya!

    Andy
    Professional Boomerang Thrower, retired.

  18. Denny Wheeler said:

    Is this Sheldon guy as big a jerk as he seems in this thread?
    (or is this one of his good days?)

    Not really any more of a jerk than those that ask those type questions
    in a public forum.
    Goomba

  19. Denny Wheeler said:

    Is this Sheldon guy as big a jerk as he seems in this thread?
    (or is this one of his good days?)

    Not really any more of a jerk than those that ask those type questions
    in a public forum.
    Goomba

  20. Same here in Tennessee--just about every steakhouse has a ribeye on the
    menu.

Active in the last 60 minutes

Active in this thread

0 users · 0 guests ·0 bots ·0 total

No signed-in users are active right now.

No known search crawlers active right now.