Road Cycling · Public discussion

Z's Crash

Started by Jack Hollis · · Last activity · 27 posts · 1,168 views

This thread is locked and is currently read-only.

Thread navigation

Jump through the discussion

Go to the original post, the replies on this page, or the latest preserved contribution.

Thread details

What we know about this thread

Original section
Road Cycling
Published
7 July 2005
Last activity
8 July 2005
Original author
Jack Hollis
Posts
27
Discussion status
Public discussion
Total views
1,168
Views / 30 days
0

The navigation and discussion metadata provide context. Posts remain in their original chronological order.

Showing posts 1–20 of 27
Posts remain in their original chronological order.

Text size
  1. I really enjoyed DZ's explanations of why he crashed, which was that
    he didn't know why he crashed. It didn't look like he sustained a
    head injury, so you can't blame it on retrograde amnesia. My guess is
    that he just to embarrassed to admit that he did something really
    dumb.

    Perhaps Phil (or was it Paul) was right when he said that Z hit his
    elbow with his knee and jerked the handle bars around. If that's what
    happened, I'd probably wouldn't admit it either.

    Either that, or he's covering for someone else.

  2. Jack Hollis said:

    I really enjoyed DZ's explanations of why he crashed, which was that
    he didn't know why he crashed. It didn't look like he sustained a
    head injury, so you can't blame it on retrograde amnesia. My guess is
    that he just to embarrassed to admit that he did something really
    dumb.

    Perhaps Phil (or was it Paul) was right when he said that Z hit his
    elbow with his knee and jerked the handle bars around. If that's what
    happened, I'd probably wouldn't admit it either.

    Either that, or he's covering for someone else.

    Watching the video full screen at slow speed you can see Z's right
    profile and something white/silverish in the pedal area appears to come
    off, at the least looks like he popped out of the pedal. Looks like an
    overlap, a cleat pop, or an elbow bump works too. Expert forensics of
    low res video at 1600px at slow speed.... (worth it for the voiceover
    alone )
    http://v12.velonews.com/tour2005/video/tdf.php?s=4

  3. "Jack Hollis" <[email hidden]> wrote in message
    news:[email hidden]...

    Quoted message said:


    Perhaps Phil (or was it Paul) was right when he said that Z hit his
    elbow with his knee and jerked the handle bars around. If that's what
    happened, I'd probably wouldn't admit it either.

    Looking at the slo-mo (which is very low res.), it looked like he braked too
    hard, and his rear wheel slid out. Those TT wheels are tricky and perhaps
    there
    was a side wind adding to the instability of the bike. The concrete looked
    to be dry
    and not slick, and I don't think the policeman was in the way. It didn't
    look as if
    he was looking over his shoulder before the crash either, but it is really
    difficult to
    tell.

  4. Cranky said:
    Jack Hollis said:

    I really enjoyed DZ's explanations of why he crashed, which was that
    he didn't know why he crashed. It didn't look like he sustained a
    head injury, so you can't blame it on retrograde amnesia. My guess is
    that he just to embarrassed to admit that he did something really
    dumb.

    Perhaps Phil (or was it Paul) was right when he said that Z hit his
    elbow with his knee and jerked the handle bars around. If that's what
    happened, I'd probably wouldn't admit it either.

    Either that, or he's covering for someone else.

    Watching the video full screen at slow speed you can see Z's right
    profile and something white/silverish in the pedal area appears to come
    off, at the least looks like he popped out of the pedal. Looks like an
    overlap, a cleat pop, or an elbow bump works too. Expert forensics of
    low res video at 1600px at slow speed.... (worth it for the voiceover
    alone )
    http://v12.velonews.com/tour2005/video/tdf.php?s=4


    "You are outside of the United States and unfortunately we are unable to
    allow you to view these highlight videos."

  5. On Wed, 6 Jul 2005 18:06:11 -0700, "Gary Funck" <[email hidden]>

    Quoted message said:


    "Jack Hollis" <[email hidden]> wrote in message
    news:[email hidden]...

    Quoted message said:


    Perhaps Phil (or was it Paul) was right when he said that Z hit his
    elbow with his knee and jerked the handle bars around. If that's what
    happened, I'd probably wouldn't admit it either.

    Looking at the slo-mo (which is very low res.), it looked like he braked too
    hard, and his rear wheel slid out. Those TT wheels are tricky and perhaps
    there
    was a side wind adding to the instability of the bike. The concrete looked
    to be dry
    and not slick, and I don't think the policeman was in the way. It didn't
    look as if
    he was looking over his shoulder before the crash either, but it is really
    difficult to
    tell.


    Danish television show it very slow, and it look like he's changing
    gear, and then his foot came down very fast. It could be the chain
    didn't catch the front cogwheel.

    Poul Erik
    Fjern cykel i adresse

    --
    == __o
    Poul Erik Lindaa === _'\ <_ E-mail: [email hidden]
    ==== (¤)/ (¤)
    ------------------------------------------------------------
    http://skivsamling.nu/show.pl?id=26228&orderby=artist+asc&offset=all

  6. "Poul Erik" <[email hidden]> a écrit dans le message de news:
    [email hidden]...
    | On Wed, 6 Jul 2005 18:06:11 -0700, "Gary Funck" <[email hidden]>
    | wrote:
    |
    | >
    | >"Jack Hollis" <[email hidden]> wrote in message
    | >news:[email hidden]...
    | >>
    | >> Perhaps Phil (or was it Paul) was right when he said that Z hit his
    | >> elbow with his knee and jerked the handle bars around. If that's what
    | >> happened, I'd probably wouldn't admit it either.
    | >
    | >Looking at the slo-mo (which is very low res.), it looked like he braked
    too
    | >hard, and his rear wheel slid out. Those TT wheels are tricky and
    perhaps
    | >there
    | >was a side wind adding to the instability of the bike. The concrete
    looked
    | >to be dry
    | >and not slick, and I don't think the policeman was in the way. It didn't
    | >look as if
    | >he was looking over his shoulder before the crash either, but it is
    really
    | >difficult to
    | >tell.
    | >
    | Danish television show it very slow, and it look like he's changing
    | gear, and then his foot came down very fast. It could be the chain
    | didn't catch the front cogwheel.
    |
    | Poul Erik
    | Fjern cykel i adresse
    That is what I saw on the Slow Motion on French Television as well. Bernard
    Thevenet thinks the same thing.

  7. Poul Erik said:
    Quoted message said:


    Danish television show it very slow, and it look like he's changing
    gear, and then his foot came down very fast. It could be the chain
    didn't catch the front cogwheel.

    Dumbass -

    That would still be operator error. Gear changes should be "feathered"
    until the chain is engaged.

  8. Kurgan Gringioni said:


    That would still be operator error. Gear changes should be "feathered"
    until the chain is engaged.

    It's difficult to believe that slipping the chain could cause a pro to
    tumble,
    though I suppose it could've caused the freewheel to seize up if it
    got derailed in the rear wheel. I'd think that most experienced cyclists
    have had a chain break, a rear axle break, and even have the chain skip
    off the freewheel into the spokes without losing control of the bike,
    but then again few have been 60+ kpmh at the time.

  9. On Thu, 7 Jul 2005 00:33:55 -0700, "Gary Funck" <[email hidden]>

    Quoted message said:

    It's difficult to believe that slipping the chain could cause a pro to
    tumble,
    though I suppose it could've caused the freewheel to seize up if it
    got derailed in the rear wheel. I'd think that most experienced cyclists
    have had a chain break, a rear axle break, and even have the chain skip
    off the freewheel into the spokes without losing control of the bike,
    but then again few have been 60+ kpmh at the time.


    And a TT-bike dosn't have a normal handlebar.

    Poul Erik
    Fjern cykel i adresse

    --
    == __o
    Poul Erik Lindaa === _'\ <_ E-mail: [email hidden]
    ==== (¤)/ (¤)
    ------------------------------------------------------------
    http://skivsamling.nu/show.pl?id=26228&orderby=artist+asc&offset=all

  10. "Danish television show it very slow, and it look like he's changing
    gear, and then his foot came down very fast. It could be the chain
    didn't catch the front cogwheel."

    That makes no sense. He was already in the Big Ring.

    His right knee hit his elbow, he was tired, he crashed himself.

    -Ken

  11. Kurgan Gringioni said:


    Poul Erik said:

    Danish television show it very slow, and it look like he's changing
    gear, and then his foot came down very fast. It could be the chain
    didn't catch the front cogwheel.

    Dumbass -

    That would still be operator error. Gear changes should be "feathered"
    until the chain is engaged.

    You can't feather [censored] with ergopower/STI. Which is the whole point of
    them anyways.

    Nice try.

  12. In article <[email hidden]>,
    [email hidden] says...

    Quoted message said:

    Danish television show it very slow, and it look like he's changing
    gear, and then his foot came down very fast. It could be the chain
    didn't catch the front cogwheel.

    Doesn't make sense. In a TTT why would anyone ever be in anything but the big
    chainring?
    ---------------
    Alex

  13. Alex Rodriguez said:

    [email hidden] says...

    Quoted message said:

    It could be the chain didn't catch the front cogwheel.

    Doesn't make sense. In a TTT why would anyone ever be in anything but the big
    chainring?

    Could be he meant smallest cog (the one that's "in front"😉.

    --
    Firefox Browser - Rediscover the web - http://getffox.com/
    Thunderbird E-mail and Newsgroups - http://gettbird.com/

  14. Ewoud Dronkert said:
    Alex Rodriguez said:

    [email hidden] says...

    Quoted message said:

    It could be the chain didn't catch the front cogwheel.

    Doesn't make sense. In a TTT why would anyone ever be in anything but the big
    chainring?

    Could be he meant smallest cog (the one that's "in front"😉.

    How many races have been lost by guys trying to get into the 11? How
    many times has that been used as an excuse?

    They should be outlawed, I tell you.

  15. Alex Rodriguez said:

    In article <[email hidden]>,
    [email hidden] says...

    Quoted message said:
    Quoted message said:

    Danish television show it very slow, and it look like he's changing
    gear, and then his foot came down very fast. It could be the chain
    didn't catch the front cogwheel.

    Quoted message said:

    Doesn't make sense. In a TTT why would anyone ever be in anything but the big
    chainring?

    I saw this movie once, where this guy went 60mph in the small ring.

    Bob Schwartz
    [email hidden]

  16. On Thu, 07 Jul 2005 17:00:12 -0000, Bob Schwartz <[email hidden]>

    Quoted message said:
    Alex Rodriguez said:

    In article <[email hidden]>,
    [email hidden] says...

    Quoted message said:
    Quoted message said:

    Danish television show it very slow, and it look like he's changing
    gear, and then his foot came down very fast. It could be the chain
    didn't catch the front cogwheel.

    Quoted message said:

    Doesn't make sense. In a TTT why would anyone ever be in anything but the big
    chainring?

    I saw this movie once, where this guy went 60mph in the small ring.

    Bob Schwartz
    [email hidden]

    That's what drafting a truck will do for you.

  17. Alex Rodriguez said:

    Doesn't make sense. In a TTT why would anyone ever be in anything but the big
    chainring?

    55*11 for Disco...

  18. k.papai said:

    His right knee hit his elbow, he was tired, he crashed himself.

    This is getting silly now...
    "As I went through the last turn, my front wheel slipped out and I hit
    the handlebars with my knee and went down."
    http://www.cyclingnews.com/road/2005/tour05/?id=results/tour056

    Hitting knee with elbow is the headwind of the Tour.

  19. corey lawson said:


    You can't feather [censored] with ergopower/STI. Which is the whole point of
    them anyways.

    Nice try.

    Dumbass -

    You are a clueless noob.

    You feather the pedaling until the chain is engaged, not the shifting.

    thanks,

    K. Gringioni.

  20. gym.gravity said:


    How many races have been lost by guys trying to get into the 11? How
    many times has that been used as an excuse?

    They should be outlawed, I tell you.

    Dumbass -

    If excuse making were outlawed in bike racing, most bike racers would
    be mutes after races.

    thanks,

    K. Gringioni.

Active in the last 60 minutes

Active in this thread

0 users · 0 guests ·0 bots ·0 total

No signed-in users are active right now.

No known search crawlers active right now.