"mayniacDad" <[email hidden]> wrote in message
news:[email hidden]...
Quoted message said:My son spent 5 years in a program where there was not much emphasis on
proper technique. Swimming was more viewed as a fitness program, so the
kids put in a lot of yards but didn't really hone their technique. We
knew the score, but were content to let him stay with the program
because he got a lot of enjoyment out of it. We figured that if he
really wanted to improve his swimming, he would eventually realize that
he was in the wrong place and would be willing to move on in spite
of the friendships he'd formed.
A little over a year ago he turned 11 and plateaued big time. Although
there are a lot of reasons for this, it was pretty clear that lots of
yards and sloppy technique were only going to take him so far. We
moved to another program where there is more emphasis put on technique.
After a year, he's still struggling. There has been progress but it
has been really sporadic. When he does what the coaches tell him he
swims well, but far too often he just lapses back into his old form.
Now there is a new coach with yet another club in town who is pushing
yet another idea. In my son's current club the coaches recognize the
problems and tell him what to do to correct them, but they generally do
this in the context of swimming the complete stroke. Along comes the
new coach, with his method of doing drills that break the strokes down,
sometimes to the point that I can't even pick out what stroke is being
emphasized.
So here's the question. Do we stick with the current club, or should
we hop to the new club because the drilling method really is more
effective?
First off, your answer is really in your post:
"When he does what the coaches tell him he
swims well"
Admittedly, the coaching staff he is currently under has been able to
improve his technique to the extent that he is swimming well - when he cares
to follow instructions. Sooooo, do you really want to switch again?
I don't know a single professional coach out there who would advocate 'club
hopping'. It's usually associated with high-talent athletes, usually age
groupers, and is quite infuriating, and often doesn't produce the results
you're looking for.
As for the 'new' coach with his 'new' method of doing things - has this
produced any meaningful widespread improvement? If he takes a group of BB-A
swimmers and turns them into AAA and quad A athletes in 6 months, (aside
from me wanting to know how he's doing it), you *may* have a viable reason
to switch clubs, if your son's plateau continues.
However i would probably suggest that your son's plateau has little to do
with coaching, either past or present, and at his age may have everything to
do with growth. How much has he grown physically since his last great surge
of time improvements? If your current club is servicing his technique and
you see sustained improvement in that area, i wouldn't suggest its worth the
bother of switching teams.
He is a very young swimmer. You may feel like he's been in the sport for
years and is an old hand, but he isn't. Age Group swimming is dominated by
the big kids, who don't always stay big. If you are happy with your current
program's attention to technique, education and training (i.e. its balanced
well, unlike your prior club), then i would suggest you stay put, let him
develop a relationship with his current coach and team and be patient.
Steve