Mountain Bikes · Public discussion

Roof Rack Reccommendations

Started by tcmedara · · Last activity · 27 posts · 1,446 views

This thread is locked and is currently read-only.

Thread navigation

Jump through the discussion

Go to the original post, the replies on this page, or the latest preserved contribution.

Thread details

What we know about this thread

Original section
Mountain Bikes
Published
2 June 2005
Last activity
5 June 2005
Original author
tcmedara
Posts
27
Discussion status
Public discussion
Total views
1,446
Views / 30 days
0
Topics

The navigation and discussion metadata provide context. Posts remain in their original chronological order.

Showing posts 1–20 of 27
Posts remain in their original chronological order.

Text size
  1. I've been using a trunk rack for years and have never had any issues
    carrying the bike(s). I'm moving this summer and want to bring the bikes
    with me to do some riding in various locales across along the way. I want a
    way to carry the bikes, but still have access to my trunk. I looked into
    the price of roof racks and was floored. For what I was looking at (Yakima)
    I was up around $500. (Cue Spanky here) Yikes. I saw the Performance
    catalog had a rack system for about half that, but it seems even the gear
    lovers at MTBR didn't think much of this equipment.

    I looked on ebay and saw what looked like some good deals, but I have no
    idea how to tell what I need for my car. Any roof rack experts out there
    that can point me on the path of righteousness?

    Tom

  2. tcmedara said:

    I've been using a trunk rack for years and have never had any issues
    carrying the bike(s). I'm moving this summer and want to bring the bikes
    with me to do some riding in various locales across along the way. I want a
    way to carry the bikes, but still have access to my trunk. I looked into
    the price of roof racks and was floored. For what I was looking at (Yakima)
    I was up around $500. (Cue Spanky here) Yikes. I saw the Performance
    catalog had a rack system for about half that, but it seems even the gear
    lovers at MTBR didn't think much of this equipment.

    I looked on ebay and saw what looked like some good deals, but I have no
    idea how to tell what I need for my car. Any roof rack experts out there
    that can point me on the path of righteousness?

    Actually, Spanky might have a point on this one. I wouldn't trust my
    bikes to a bargain-basement set of racks. I have Thule, and have never
    regretted spending the extra coin on quality.

    Buy the "fit kit" retail, and get the bike stuff and load bars via
    eBay, or some online discounter.

    E.P.

  3. tcmedara said:

    I've been using a trunk rack for years and have never had any issues
    carrying the bike(s). I'm moving this summer and want to bring the
    bikes with me to do some riding in various locales across along the
    way. I want a way to carry the bikes, but still have access to my
    trunk. I looked into the price of roof racks and was floored. For
    what I was looking at (Yakima) I was up around $500. (Cue Spanky
    here) Yikes. I saw the Performance catalog had a rack system for
    about half that, but it seems even the gear lovers at MTBR didn't
    think much of this equipment.
    I looked on ebay and saw what looked like some good deals, but I have
    no idea how to tell what I need for my car. Any roof rack experts
    out there that can point me on the path of righteousness?

    Tom

    Yakima is good stuff but you will get nickel and dimed to death getting the
    right little parts for your particular car. I"m using a rack we bought 15
    years ago and it's still in great shape.

    Penny

  4. Quoted message said:


    tcmedara said:

    I've been using a trunk rack for years and have never had any issues
    carrying the bike(s). I'm moving this summer and want to bring the bikes
    with me to do some riding in various locales across along the way. I want a
    way to carry the bikes, but still have access to my trunk. I looked into
    the price of roof racks and was floored. For what I was looking at (Yakima)
    I was up around $500. (Cue Spanky here) Yikes. I saw the Performance
    catalog had a rack system for about half that, but it seems even the gear
    lovers at MTBR didn't think much of this equipment.

    I looked on ebay and saw what looked like some good deals, but I have no
    idea how to tell what I need for my car. Any roof rack experts out there
    that can point me on the path of righteousness?

    Actually, Spanky might have a point on this one. I wouldn't trust my
    bikes to a bargain-basement set of racks. I have Thule, and have never
    regretted spending the extra coin on quality.

    Buy the "fit kit" retail, and get the bike stuff and load bars via
    eBay, or some online discounter.

    E.P.

    Good advice. The fit kit is the only part that would be hard to get
    right. I also have Thule and am happy. Haven't lost a bike, ski or kayak
    yet!

    $500 does seem steep. I think I paid a couple hundred but it's been a
    while.

    Matt

  5. tcmedara said:

    I've been using a trunk rack for years and have never had any issues
    carrying the bike(s). I'm moving this summer and want to bring the bikes
    with me to do some riding in various locales across along the way. I want a
    way to carry the bikes, but still have access to my trunk. I looked into
    the price of roof racks and was floored. For what I was looking at (Yakima)
    I was up around $500. (Cue Spanky here) Yikes. I saw the Performance
    catalog had a rack system for about half that, but it seems even the gear
    lovers at MTBR didn't think much of this equipment.

    I looked on ebay and saw what looked like some good deals, but I have no
    idea how to tell what I need for my car. Any roof rack experts out there
    that can point me on the path of righteousness?

    Tom

    Yakima! You can get King Cobras for $75 on eBay as compared to twice
    that at retail.

    Where are you moving to? VA is going to miss one of their most loyal
    trail guys.

    --
    o-o-o-o Ride-A-Lot o-o-o-o
    www.schnauzers.ws

  6. tcmedara said:

    I've been using a trunk rack for years and have never had any issues
    carrying the bike(s). I'm moving this summer and want to bring the
    bikes with me to do some riding in various locales across along the
    way. I want a way to carry the bikes, but still have access to my
    trunk. I looked into the price of roof racks and was floored. For
    what I was looking at (Yakima) I was up around $500. (Cue Spanky
    here) Yikes. I saw the Performance catalog had a rack system for
    about half that, but it seems even the gear lovers at MTBR didn't
    think much of this equipment.

    I looked on ebay and saw what looked like some good deals, but I have
    no idea how to tell what I need for my car. Any roof rack experts
    out there that can point me on the path of righteousness?

    Tom

    If you can get up to Richmond, Agee's bike shop on west broad street has the
    best selection of Yakima and Thule racks in stock. Decent prices too.

    I have three Yakima King Cobra racks on my car. They are easy to load (no
    wheel removal required) and hold 45 lb DH bikes with no problem.

    Mike

  7. "small change" <[email hidden]> wrote in message
    news:[email hidden]...

    Quoted message said:

    Yakima is good stuff but you will get nickel and dimed to death getting


    the

    Quoted message said:

    right little parts for your particular car. I"m using a rack we bought 15
    years ago and it's still in great shape.

    We just bought a roof rack for our kayaks off of a fellow mtb'r/kayaker. It
    was in nearly brand new condition after 1-2 years of use and we only paid
    about a 1/4 of what it would cost retail. A great bargain. The whole setup
    would have cost us about $500 if we went retail.

    - CA-G

    Can-Am Girls Kick Ass!

  8. <[email hidden]> wrote in message
    news:[email hidden]...

    Quoted message said:

    Actually, Spanky might have a point on this one. I wouldn't trust my
    bikes to a bargain-basement set of racks. I have Thule, and have never
    regretted spending the extra coin on quality.

    Buy the "fit kit" retail, and get the bike stuff and load bars via
    eBay, or some online discounter.

    E.P.

    We've been using a Thule hitchmount rack for a few years, its been the
    greatest rack we've ever owned. Well worth the extra coin for peace of mind
    and security.

    - CA-G

    Can-Am Girls Kick Ass!

  9. tcmedara said:

    I've been using a trunk rack for years and have never had any issues
    carrying the bike(s). I'm moving this summer and want to bring the bikes
    with me to do some riding in various locales across along the way. I want a
    way to carry the bikes, but still have access to my trunk. I looked into
    the price of roof racks and was floored. For what I was looking at (Yakima)
    I was up around $500. (Cue Spanky here) Yikes. I saw the Performance
    catalog had a rack system for about half that, but it seems even the gear
    lovers at MTBR didn't think much of this equipment.

    Well, think about how much you spend on any other accessory for your
    car. I've always found the impulse to balk at spending $500 on a rack
    for a $20,000 car curious, even if I have felt the same way myself.

    I have used both Thule and Yakima (I currently own a Yakima). Both are
    excellent racks, although each has their good and bad points. Here's
    what happened to my Thule rack:

    http://www.angelfire.com/ab6/corvuscorvax/failure.jpg

    This was not the rack's fault. It was operator error.

    CC

  10. "tcmedara" <[email hidden]> wrote in message
    news:covne.28823$Fv.4329@lakeread01...

    Quoted message said:

    I've been using a trunk rack for years and have never had any issues
    carrying the bike(s). I'm moving this summer and want to bring the bikes
    with me to do some riding in various locales across along the way. I want


    a

    Quoted message said:

    way to carry the bikes, but still have access to my trunk. I looked into
    the price of roof racks and was floored. For what I was looking at


    (Yakima)

    Quoted message said:

    I was up around $500. (Cue Spanky here) Yikes. I saw the Performance
    catalog had a rack system for about half that, but it seems even the gear
    lovers at MTBR didn't think much of this equipment.

    I looked on ebay and saw what looked like some good deals, but I have no
    idea how to tell what I need for my car. Any roof rack experts out there
    that can point me on the path of righteousness?

    If your driving that far, and you feel your going to have the will and
    energy to haul a bike off and on the roof of your car and ride it around, my
    hat's off to you.

    When I moved from OK to CA, I threw mine in a trailer, along with all my
    other junk. If I weren't towing the trailer, I would have had it shipped.
    My bike was cleaner, and I didn't have to worry about the thieves that hang
    around roadside motels.

    Pagan


  11. Quoted message said:

    "tcmedara" <[email hidden]> wrote in message
    news:covne.28823$Fv.4329@lakeread01...

    Quoted message said:

    I've been using a trunk rack for years and have never had any issues
    carrying the bike(s). I'm moving this summer and want to bring the
    bikes with me to do some riding in various locales across along the
    way. I want a way to carry the bikes, but still have access to my
    trunk. I looked into the price of roof racks and was floored. For
    what I was looking at (Yakima) I was up around $500. (Cue Spanky
    here) Yikes. I saw the Performance catalog had a rack system for
    about half that, but it seems even the gear lovers at MTBR didn't
    think much of this equipment.

    Moving, I missed that first time around. You buy whatever you want, and keep
    the reciept as a moving expense.

    ps

  12. "small change" <[email hidden]> wrote in message
    news:[email hidden]...

    Quoted message said:


    Quoted message said:

    "tcmedara" <[email hidden]> wrote in message
    news:covne.28823$Fv.4329@lakeread01...

    Quoted message said:

    I've been using a trunk rack for years and have never had any issues
    carrying the bike(s). I'm moving this summer and want to bring the
    bikes with me to do some riding in various locales across along the
    way. I want a way to carry the bikes, but still have access to my
    trunk. I looked into the price of roof racks and was floored. For
    what I was looking at (Yakima) I was up around $500. (Cue Spanky
    here) Yikes. I saw the Performance catalog had a rack system for
    about half that, but it seems even the gear lovers at MTBR didn't
    think much of this equipment.

    Moving, I missed that first time around. You buy whatever you want, and


    keep

    Quoted message said:

    the reciept as a moving expense.

    I guess it depends on if you can take moving expenses off your taxes. I
    couldn't, because I was in the Army, which paid me for expenses.

    I wonder if buying the rack from a national chain, using it for the move,
    then returning it, would create a bunch of hassle. I certainly wouldn't
    want to spend much money on a one-time thing like that.

    Otherwise, I'd have a tow hitch installed, then get a rack for that. At
    least that way you'd make a tiny bit of money back on resale value of the
    car, and have a rack that can be moved to another car.

    Pagan

  13. Pagan said:

    I wonder if buying the rack from a national chain, using it for the
    move, then returning it, would create a bunch of hassle.

    Ethical much?

  14. MattB said:
    Quoted message said:


    tcmedara said:

    I've been using a trunk rack for years and have never had any issues
    carrying the bike(s). I'm moving this summer and want to bring the
    bikes
    with me to do some riding in various locales across along the way. I
    want a
    way to carry the bikes, but still have access to my trunk. I looked
    into
    the price of roof racks and was floored. For what I was looking at
    (Yakima)
    I was up around $500. (Cue Spanky here) Yikes. I saw the Performance
    catalog had a rack system for about half that, but it seems even the
    gear
    lovers at MTBR didn't think much of this equipment.

    I looked on ebay and saw what looked like some good deals, but I have no
    idea how to tell what I need for my car. Any roof rack experts out
    there
    that can point me on the path of righteousness?

    Actually, Spanky might have a point on this one. I wouldn't trust my
    bikes to a bargain-basement set of racks. I have Thule, and have never
    regretted spending the extra coin on quality.

    Buy the "fit kit" retail, and get the bike stuff and load bars via
    eBay, or some online discounter.

    E.P.

    Good advice. The fit kit is the only part that would be hard to get
    right. I also have Thule and am happy. Haven't lost a bike, ski or kayak
    yet!

    $500 does seem steep. I think I paid a couple hundred but it's been a
    while.

    I bought a Thule setup a couple of weeks ago and paid 250 euros for the
    whole lot (fittings, rack bars and two bike carriers). I think it would
    have been only 200 with one bike carrier.

  15. Pagan said:


    I guess it depends on if you can take moving expenses off your taxes.
    I couldn't, because I was in the Army, which paid me for expenses.

    I wonder if buying the rack from a national chain, using it for the
    move, then returning it, would create a bunch of hassle. I certainly
    wouldn't want to spend much money on a one-time thing like that.

    Otherwise, I'd have a tow hitch installed, then get a rack for that.
    At least that way you'd make a tiny bit of money back on resale value
    of the car, and have a rack that can be moved to another car.

    Pagan

    Actually I'm moving on military orders. However, you can claim any moving
    expenses not otherwise covered. They'll pay me mileage and per diem, but
    anything above that (i.e. out of pocket/non-re-imbursed) can be claimed as a
    moving expense. The rack may just work that way. Hafta check.

    Tom

  16. Ride-A-Lot said:
    tcmedara said:

    I've been using a trunk rack for years and have never had any issues
    carrying the bike(s). I'm moving this summer and want to bring the
    bikes with me to do some riding in various locales across along the
    way. I want a way to carry the bikes, but still have access to my
    trunk. I looked into the price of roof racks and was floored. For
    what I was looking at (Yakima) I was up around $500. (Cue Spanky
    here) Yikes. I saw the Performance catalog had a rack system for
    about half that, but it seems even the gear lovers at MTBR didn't
    think much of this equipment. I looked on ebay and saw what looked like
    some good deals, but I
    have no idea how to tell what I need for my car. Any roof rack
    experts out there that can point me on the path of righteousness?

    Tom

    Yakima! You can get King Cobras for $75 on eBay as compared to twice
    that at retail.

    Where are you moving to? VA is going to miss one of their most loyal
    trail guys.

    Destination: Nebraska. I actually am familiar with the area. The riding
    in the immediate area is actually better than it is in the Tidewater VA
    area. It's actually flatter here, if you can believe it.

    I think I'll do the rack retail/carriers e-bay route. As some have said,
    the rack fit appears to be the trickiest part.

  17. Ride-A-Lot said:
    tcmedara said:
    Ride-A-Lot said:

    tcmedara wrote:

    > I've been using a trunk rack for years and have never had any issues
    > carrying the bike(s). I'm moving this summer and want to bring the
    > bikes with me to do some riding in various locales across along the
    > way. I want a way to carry the bikes, but still have access to my
    > trunk. I looked into the price of roof racks and was floored. For
    > what I was looking at (Yakima) I was up around $500. (Cue Spanky
    > here) Yikes. I saw the Performance catalog had a rack system for
    > about half that, but it seems even the gear lovers at MTBR didn't
    > think much of this equipment. I looked on ebay and saw what looked
    > like some good deals, but I
    > have no idea how to tell what I need for my car. Any roof rack
    > experts out there that can point me on the path of righteousness?
    >
    > Tom
    >
    >

    Yakima! You can get King Cobras for $75 on eBay as compared to twice
    that at retail.

    Where are you moving to? VA is going to miss one of their most loyal
    trail guys.

    Destination: Nebraska. I actually am familiar with the area. The
    riding in the immediate area is actually better than it is in the
    Tidewater VA area. It's actually flatter here, if you can believe it.

    At least it's closer to Colorado!

    Only by a cruel twist of geographic fate.

    Shawn
    CU 1987

  18. "Bill Sornson" <[email hidden]> wrote in message
    news:[email hidden]...

    Quoted message said:
    Pagan said:

    I wonder if buying the rack from a national chain, using it for the
    move, then returning it, would create a bunch of hassle.

    Ethical much?

    Not sure what your question truly is, but since you use the word "ethical",
    it may be you question whether my suggestion is somehow dishonest.

    Many stores allow you to return purchases with no questions asked, except
    maybe to inquire whether it's defective, missing parts, and such. They
    figure you didn't like what you bought, and since they'd really like to have
    you come in and buy something else, they offer liberal return policies.

    As for my suggestion, one can simply buy the rack, try it out, and return it
    if it's not wanted. However, if the buyer likes the rack enough to keep it,
    that's certainly within his rights. It may be he likes hauling bikes up and
    down a car roof, reduced gas mileage, and is overjoyed at the possibility of
    forgetting the bikes are up there when going through a parking garage or a
    drive through fast food joint, thus loosing the bikes, rack, and perhaps a
    chunk of car.

    Does moving change the ethical question? Not really. Being in the
    military, you can't count on much, but you most certainly can count on being
    moved every two to three years. It may be he wants to keep this rack so
    when the time comes to move again, he can do as he plans to do this time.

    If you have any leftover doubts, let me ease your mind with one final
    thought. The big chain stores, as well as those producing their products,
    are doing so because of money, and that's the bottom line. My bike rack,
    which sits on the spare tire on the back of my SUV, is held on with two
    bolts, but is finally secured with cheap nylon straps and plastic buckles.
    This is fine for now, but in a couple years, the straps will fray and
    weaken, and the buckles will get brittle with the exposure of the sun.
    Eventually, the whole thing will come off, possibly on the freeway. This
    may not sound like a big deal while your reading this, but your mind will
    change if you happen to be behind me while we're all doing 80, and it
    finally decides to give way.

    You see, the manufacturer saved about $10 on this $100 item by using those
    cheap straps. They'd rather have that $10 in their pocket than ensure you
    don't end up kissing this thing when it fly's through your windshield,
    possibly killing you, your family, and anybody else who's too close to you.

    Strange enough, neither the packaging or the instructions made any mention
    of checking the spare tire mount for rust, loose bolts, and whatnot. I
    guess they didn't want to scare off their customers.

    On the other hand, the guy at the small bike shop where I got this thing did
    ask, and even helped me mount it securely and safely. Will a big chain
    store do that? Unlikely. What they will do is take your money, check your
    ID so they don't get screwed with a stolen credit card, and move on to the
    next guy.

    While two wrongs don't make a right, dealing with big business on their
    level (money and only money) is the only practical way of trying to come out
    even.

    Pagan

  19. Shawn said:
    Ride-A-Lot said:
    tcmedara said:

    Ride-A-Lot wrote:

    > tcmedara wrote:
    >
    >> I've been using a trunk rack for years and have never had any
    >> issues carrying the bike(s). I'm moving this summer and want to
    >> bring the bikes with me to do some riding in various locales
    >> across along the way. I want a way to carry the bikes, but still
    >> have access to my trunk. I looked into the price of roof racks
    >> and was floored. For what I was looking at (Yakima) I was up
    >> around $500. (Cue Spanky here) Yikes. I saw the Performance
    >> catalog had a rack system for about half that, but it seems even
    >> the gear lovers at MTBR didn't think much of this equipment. I
    >> looked on ebay and saw what looked like some good deals, but I
    >> have no idea how to tell what I need for my car. Any roof rack
    >> experts out there that can point me on the path of righteousness?
    >>
    >> Tom
    >>
    >>
    >
    > Yakima! You can get King Cobras for $75 on eBay as compared to
    > twice that at retail.
    >
    > Where are you moving to? VA is going to miss one of their most
    > loyal trail guys.

    Destination: Nebraska. I actually am familiar with the area. The
    riding in the immediate area is actually better than it is in the
    Tidewater VA area. It's actually flatter here, if you can believe
    it.

    At least it's closer to Colorado!

    Only by a cruel twist of geographic fate.

    Shawn
    CU 1987

    I'm actually going to try and make it to CO this summer. A buddy of mine
    has a vacation house about 1/2 south of Breckenridge. Says there's great
    riding up there. I'm a little intimidated by the altitude. The house sits
    at 11K. Yikes. I'm at about 1.5 ft where I am now!

    Tom

  20. Pagan said:

    "Bill Sornson" <[email hidden]> wrote

    Quoted message said:


    Ethical much?

    Not sure what your question truly is, but since you use the word "ethical",
    it may be you question whether my suggestion is somehow dishonest.

    [... lots and lots of self-justification elided ...]

    Methinks the lad doth protest to much.

    CC

Active in the last 60 minutes

Active in this thread

0 users · 0 guests ·0 bots ·0 total

No signed-in users are active right now.

No known search crawlers active right now.