Cycling Equipment · Public discussion

Bottom Bracket Rebuild vs Cartridge

Started by Larry · · Last activity · 2 posts · 410 views

This thread is locked and is currently read-only.

Thread details

What we know about this thread

Original section
Cycling Equipment
Published
27 April 2005
Last activity
27 April 2005
Original author
Larry
Posts
2
Discussion status
Public discussion
Total views
410
Views / 30 days
0

The navigation and discussion metadata provide context. Posts remain in their original chronological order.

Showing posts 1–2 of 2
Posts remain in their original chronological order.

Text size
  1. I'm overhauling a great (1980s) sport/touring Bianchi with Ishiwata
    tubes, and having trouble with the bottom bracket. I took out the
    races (9 ballbearings), cleaned everything with WD40 and elbow grease,
    repacked the BB with 9 new ballbearings (of the correct size) on each
    side and, of course, fresh grease.

    I have adjusted the BB to the point where it no longer spins smoothly,
    yet there is still some (some is too much) play in the spindle. I was
    hoping for spinning smoothly with no slop in the spindle.

    I must be a retro grouch, because I'd prefer keeping this bottom
    bracket to putting in a so-called sealed bearing cartridge. Just think
    of the weight savings of this older technology! Plus, if it gets water
    in it, no big deal. Instead of replacing the cartridge, I can squirt
    some WD-40 in the seat tube to replace the water and then pour in some
    Phils tenacious or even chain saw lube, and be on my way. Rebuild at
    my leasure. But, I've got cartridge BBs on some of my other bikes and
    have had no problems with them. Maybe I should keep it simple, and
    just put in a cartridge?

    I recall that when replacing the 9-ballbearing race with just
    bearings, you could put in a 10th ballbearing. Might a 10th
    ballbearing help?

    What do you think? Can I salvage this BB or should I go for a
    cartridge?

    Thanks,
    Larry

  2. "Larry" <[email hidden]> wrote in message
    news:[email hidden]...

    Quoted message said:

    I'm overhauling a great (1980s) sport/touring Bianchi with Ishiwata
    tubes, and having trouble with the bottom bracket. I took out the
    races (9 ballbearings), cleaned everything with WD40 and elbow grease,
    repacked the BB with 9 new ballbearings (of the correct size) on each
    side and, of course, fresh grease.

    I have adjusted the BB to the point where it no longer spins smoothly,
    yet there is still some (some is too much) play in the spindle. I was
    hoping for spinning smoothly with no slop in the spindle.

    I must be a retro grouch, because I'd prefer keeping this bottom
    bracket to putting in a so-called sealed bearing cartridge. Just think
    of the weight savings of this older technology! Plus, if it gets water
    in it, no big deal. Instead of replacing the cartridge, I can squirt
    some WD-40 in the seat tube to replace the water and then pour in some
    Phils tenacious or even chain saw lube, and be on my way. Rebuild at
    my leasure. But, I've got cartridge BBs on some of my other bikes and
    have had no problems with them. Maybe I should keep it simple, and
    just put in a cartridge?

    I recall that when replacing the 9-ballbearing race with just
    bearings, you could put in a 10th ballbearing. Might a 10th
    ballbearing help?

    What do you think? Can I salvage this BB or should I go for a
    cartridge?

    Thanks,
    Larry

    Larry this is a long shot, but the cage that holds the balls, did you by any
    chance install them backwards? Sounds like you did everything right, and
    you should be able to adjust the BB.
    -tom

Active in the last 60 minutes

Active in this thread

0 users · 0 guests ·0 bots ·0 total

No signed-in users are active right now.

No known search crawlers active right now.