After saying I was gonna do it for almost two years, I finally just
replaced the way-too-long-for-me 175 cranks on my singlespeed commuter
road bike with some 170s I got on eBay. The cranks are lovely, and I'd
intended to remove the stock rings and replace them with the 46 I've
been using. But the one thing I didn't know when I purchased them is
that they're designed such that the 52T chainring is fused to the crank
arm.
Combine that with the 17t freewheel on my Suzue flipflop, and I'd be
running a bit too rich for my spinning tastes. So for the time being, I
bolted my old 46 back on as a second ring. But I really want the
simplicity and clean looks of a single ring, so would like to run just
the 52 while roughly matching the 46 X 17 ratio I was running.
Looking at Sheldon's and other gear calculators it seem as though an
18t is gonna be just a bit too big and a 20t a bit too small .... But
after a little bit of looking around, I'm wondering whether those are
my only options: I haven't seen any such animial as a 19t.
Also, coming the long way round to the question posed in the subject,
I've been told that for some types of freewheels (ACS), the smaller
gears (those with 16 or more teeth) thread only on Standard English hub
threads, while the bigger ones (those with 15T or less) only thread
onto smaller, metric "BMX Flip-Flop" threads. Is this true of all SS
freewheels or is it particular to ACS or BMX FWs in general?
All of this leaves me confused as to what to look for when buying a
replacement freewheel. Most of the singlespeed freewheel descriptions
I've seen online don't even mention thread type.
Is my Suzue flipflop considered a "BMX Flip-Flop?" The 17t I now have
on the Suzue is from Shimano. Will all Shimano SS FWs have the same
threading? Can this hub accept an ACS 18 or 20, or should I confine my
searching to a Shimano? If that's the case, does Shimano make a 19t?
Thanks for any help you can provide.