TavliGal said:Quoted message said:Quoted message said:TavliGal wrote:
>I've also done Jazz dance and I enjoyed that, but what I'd really
>love to take is Flamenco and African Dance. They are on my goals
>list, along with some type of Martial Art, I haven't figured out
>which one yet but I seem to lean towards Tae Kwan Do (sp?).
>
>Monica
Why do you lean towards TKD?
Not sure really. I think it's because they have a variety of movements, but
I'm just not so sure about all the throwing. I've recovered from 2 spinal
injuries and I don't necessarily want to tempt fate for a third time. Maybe
you can help me figure it out. I have good strong (but short) legs, strong
arms, I'd like the kicking and arm stuff, maybe not a whole lot of throwing,
but I don't mind body contact overall. That would be the fun part. 😉
I took Judo when I was a kid and I loved the throwing and I think I was
pretty good at it but like I said, I'm paranoid about the spine.
Quoted message said:<snip>
I used to help teach karate to children 8 hours a week after work. I
am a black belt in the Shudokan style and have also studied the GoJu
and [censored] styles and dabled at TKD.
Just clarifying: So, GoJu, Shudokan, and [censored] are styles of Karate?
Yes, GoJu is the "hard/soft" style. Supposedly one of the original
Okinawan styles. It was originated by Miagi Sensie. The movie the Karate
Kid tries to loosely assert that Pat Morita's character is a direct
decendant of the originator of the style. A lot of the training that he
has that kid do in the movie actually makes sense. It was never "sand
the deck" for me though. IT WAS "clean the mirrors. Half an outside
middle block was what was being commited to muscle memory there. Kinda
the core block of the style.
NO THERE IS NO CRANE KICK!
Well actually there are in the Hacksunu (crane) katas, but that is a
different style stolen from GungFu
Shudokan is a composite style which borrows from most of the other
major styles. Especially Shotokan, which was the first style brought to
mainland/mainstream Japan by a man of the name Funakoshi. I feel that
this makes it a good system, although it tends to be a hard/hard system.
Well rounded though. Good for learning to tournament fight.
[censored] is another quick style that tends to be more like TKD with the
jumping and high kicks.
I tried really hard to learn to kick well/high enough to get my oponent
in the head. Once I managed to do it I gave it up for quicker, more
accurate, low kicks to the proper targets.
Quoted message said:Quoted message said:If you find a style of martial art that has a variety in its
forms/kata it can be quite good exercise.
Yes, that sounds good to me.
I would, and this is personal opinion, stay away from TKD then. I find
that the traditional Japanese and Okinawan martial arts have a better
low impact workout to them. A TKD workout is more like running a mile I
think while a karate workout is more like walking three at a good pace.
Quoted message said:
A good instructor will
Quoted message said:sharpen you to a point where I pray that you never have to defend
yourself. TKD is not for me, I prefer to have a sturdy base and stay
on the ground, but there are some folks out there that are proficient
with it.
Same with the sturdy base and being grounded, sounds like something I'd
like. Which style is that?
GoJu, if you believe the eastern mysticism, teaches you to root yourself
into the ground. The stances are more upright and natural then a lot of
the other karate styles. For instance a ZenKustuDaschi (Mind forward
stance) in Shudokan is like a half to three quarter lunge. In GoJu it is
more like a medium sized step. The work is done by locking in your
muscles to a good stance rather then being deep and placing body weight
resistance on your muscles. It also promotes lumbar movement more then
the others.
If you really want a style that teaches balance and stability there is
Aikido. The one that Steven Sagal teaches/uses. The problem with that
for you is that it teaches you to use your balance energy to throw/lock
your oponent using his against him. And in practice for every time you
get to throw someone you can expect to be thrown. It is also very
eastern religion centered and that was something I had a problem with.
Quoted message said:Quoted message said:Now for my short MA rant. There exists in the MA world what is refered
to as McDojos. These are places where the instructor may or may not
have some knowledge, but the main purpose in the place being open is
to seperate you from your money. Often times the folks ploppig down
their money at these places are buying a false sense of being able to
defend themselves.
They can be hard to spot on the surface, but *sometimes* some of the
warning signs can be: having to sign a contract, many many belt
colors, a test every x months mentality, and "other" programs that
don't have anything to do with the particular MA they are teaching.
If you decide to join a school/club make sure that they will allow you
to come to a couple classes for free to see what you think of their
ways. Often the most competent instructors are the one's that are
teaching out of their garage or basement or the local grange.
Sometimes even for free, like my instructor.
One last thing. GoJu is particularly well suited to larger
practicioners where some of the other kinds of MA are more suited to
the little quick mobile guy. Trust me, I am 6'3" and 300lbs.
Good luck, feel free to ask questions if you have them.
Thank you, great pointers. By the sounds of what I say, does GoJu seem like
something I may take too? I'm interested in your opinion. If you need more
info just ask. I ought to look into it though. Thanks again.
Monica
I would suggest almost anyone who is interested in MAs check into a GoJu
school. It is one of the most balanced styles in that locking in blocks
etc. uses the back as much as the chest. A lot of M-artists in other
styles have trouble with overdeveloped chests underdeveloped backs after
a few years unless they do extra work outside of the MA to balance them.
(Lots of punching and extended blocks but hardly anything that works the
back.)
The katas for the most part can be done by someone of just about any
size. Big strong people don't look out of place doing them. There are
some throws in there, but a good instructor can keep you from getting hurt.
Like I said before, I have my personal opinions on TKD. I won't sit on a
diet forum and bash it though.
If you decide that you want to really look at GoJu, or Shudokan let me
know and I will get a vcd of some of the core kata together and send it
to you.
Where are you located?
Lurker
--