Road Cycling · Public discussion

Winter Jacket

Started by J. VerSchave · · Last activity · 59 posts · 2,031 views

This thread is locked and is currently read-only.

Thread navigation

Jump through the discussion

Go to the original post, the replies on this page, or the latest preserved contribution.

Thread details

What we know about this thread

Original section
Road Cycling
Published
15 November 2004
Last activity
5 December 2004
Original author
J. VerSchave
Posts
59
Discussion status
Public discussion
Total views
2,031
Views / 30 days
0

The navigation and discussion metadata provide context. Posts remain in their original chronological order.

Showing posts 1–20 of 59
Posts remain in their original chronological order.

Text size
  1. I am looking to buy an all-purpose jacket this year for my
    snowboarding and mountain biking activities. I am assuming I should
    get a separate shell and liner.

    Shell
    ------
    - water-proof
    - wind-resistant
    - reflective (scotchlight or equivalent) stripe across the check, back
    and on the sleeves (sometimes I bike in the city and would prefered
    not to get hit by a car)
    - not bulky
    - breathable

    Liner
    -----
    - warm
    - breathable
    - fast drying
    - not bulky

    Anyone have any recommendations for the shell and/or the liner.
    Thanks.

    -jean

  2. (J. VerSchave) said:

    I am looking to buy an all-purpose jacket this year for my
    snowboarding and mountain biking activities. I am assuming I should
    get a separate shell and liner.

    Shell
    ------
    - water-proof
    - wind-resistant
    - reflective (scotchlight or equivalent) stripe across the check, back
    and on the sleeves (sometimes I bike in the city and would prefered
    not to get hit by a car)
    - not bulky
    - breathable

    Liner
    -----
    - warm
    - breathable
    - fast drying
    - not bulky

    Anyone have any recommendations for the shell and/or the liner.
    Thanks.

    -jean

    I would think that you need a warmer jacket for snow boarding than mountain
    biking unless you only drive down hill.

    Ben

  3. [email hidden] (J. VerSchave) wrote in message news:<[email hidden]>...

    Quoted message said:

    I am looking to buy an all-purpose jacket this year for my
    snowboarding and mountain biking activities. I am assuming I should
    get a separate shell and liner.

    Shell
    ------
    - water-proof
    - wind-resistant
    - reflective (scotchlight or equivalent) stripe across the check, back
    and on the sleeves (sometimes I bike in the city and would prefered
    not to get hit by a car)
    - not bulky
    - breathable

    Liner
    -----
    - warm
    - breathable
    - fast drying
    - not bulky

    Anyone have any recommendations for the shell and/or the liner.
    Thanks.

    -jean

    If you wear a helmet an attached hood is annoying.

  4. J. VerSchave said:

    I am looking to buy an all-purpose jacket this year for my
    snowboarding and mountain biking activities. I am assuming I should
    get a separate shell and liner.

    See www.mec.ca, they'll have what you need, as well as lots of
    information explaining the various products.

    Neil

  5. "J. VerSchave" <[email hidden]> wrote

    Quoted message said:

    I am looking to buy an all-purpose jacket this year for my
    snowboarding and mountain biking activities. I am assuming I should
    get a separate shell and liner.

    Liner? Why?

    A good outfit consists of a base layer, a fleece jacket (I have 3
    different ones and that's the only thing that changes according to
    the weather), and a shell.

    There's a Salomon Somatic shell jacket on sierratradingpost.com
    for $140 now, that's what I used for a good part of last season and the
    3 days I was out this season (~30 days total) and I highly recommend it.
    But it doesn't have anything reflective on it.

    Goot points about it are:
    - no liners or any other junk manufacturers like to attach inside
    - no hood
    - very simple and functional design

    The only bad thing is that the front zipper likes to bite parts
    of the shell and get stuck, but it doesn't happen too often to
    be a big issue.

    Basically it's an almost exact analog of the top-dog shells
    like Arc'teryx Alpha SV, but for half the price and no damn hood.

  6. Dmitry said:

    "J. VerSchave" <[email hidden]> wrote

    Quoted message said:

    I am looking to buy an all-purpose jacket this year for my
    snowboarding and mountain biking activities. I am assuming I should
    get a separate shell and liner.

    Liner? Why?

    I think he met shell and seperate insulation layer, like a fleece.

    Anyways, go to the aforementioned Mountain Equipment Coop Site
    (www.mec.ca) and look for the Zik jacket (under men's cycling clothing).
    The hood is zip-off, which is good when you're using helmets. It's
    made of Gore-Tex XCR, the best of the waterproof-breathables. It has
    reflective strips. You could easily use it on the mountain too. You'll
    need to get a fleece to wear underneath it for colder conditions.

    Neil

  7. "Neil Gendzwill" <[email hidden]> wrote in message
    news:[email hidden]...

    Quoted message said:
    Dmitry said:

    "J. VerSchave" <[email hidden]> wrote

    Quoted message said:

    I am looking to buy an all-purpose jacket this year for my
    snowboarding and mountain biking activities. I am assuming I should
    get a separate shell and liner.

    Liner? Why?

    I think he met shell and seperate insulation layer, like a fleece.

    Anyways, go to the aforementioned Mountain Equipment Coop Site
    (www.mec.ca) and look for the Zik jacket (under men's cycling clothing).
    The hood is zip-off, which is good when you're using helmets. It's
    made of Gore-Tex XCR, the best of the waterproof-breathables. It has
    reflective strips. You could easily use it on the mountain too. You'll
    need to get a fleece to wear underneath it for colder conditions.

    I think shells suck. They all trap sweat like crazy, even the "breathable"
    ones. Unless it's raining, I'm wearing fleece with a wind vest, much
    cheaper and tune-able. In the rain, it doesn't matter, you'll get wet
    either way. You just want to keep running water off your body.

  8. Peter Cole said:

    "Neil Gendzwill" <[email hidden]> wrote in message
    news:[email hidden]...

    Quoted message said:
    Dmitry said:

    "J. VerSchave" <[email hidden]> wrote

    >I am looking to buy an all-purpose jacket this year for my
    >snowboarding and mountain biking activities. I am assuming I should
    >get a separate shell and liner.

    Liner? Why?

    I think he met shell and seperate insulation layer, like a fleece.

    Anyways, go to the aforementioned Mountain Equipment Coop Site
    (www.mec.ca) and look for the Zik jacket (under men's cycling clothing).
    The hood is zip-off, which is good when you're using helmets. It's
    made of Gore-Tex XCR, the best of the waterproof-breathables. It has
    reflective strips. You could easily use it on the mountain too. You'll
    need to get a fleece to wear underneath it for colder conditions.

    I think shells suck. They all trap sweat like crazy, even the "breathable"
    ones. Unless it's raining, I'm wearing fleece with a wind vest, much
    cheaper and tune-able. In the rain, it doesn't matter, you'll get wet
    either way. You just want to keep running water off your body.

    If you leave word where you'll be skiing in the backcountry, we can
    collect the body in the Spring.

  9. "Peter Cole" <[email hidden]> wrote

    Quoted message said:

    I think shells suck. They all trap sweat like crazy, even the "breathable"
    ones. Unless it's raining, I'm wearing fleece with a wind vest, much
    cheaper and tune-able.

    You got to be kidding. Or your "unless" should include
    "cold and/or windy". Where do you ski?

    Quoted message said:

    In the rain, it doesn't matter, you'll get wet
    either way. You just want to keep running water off your body.

    Not true. I boarded in the pouring rain last season
    wrapped in good shells (jacket - Salomon Somatic, pants -
    Arc'teryx Minuteman) and all of my layers other than the
    shell were dry after two hours of this misery 🙂

  10. On 14 Nov 2004 17:24:12 -0800, [email hidden] (J.

    VerSchave) said:

    I am looking to buy an all-purpose jacket this year for my
    snowboarding and mountain biking activities. I am assuming I should
    get a separate shell and liner.

    Shell
    ------
    - water-proof
    - wind-resistant
    - reflective (scotchlight or equivalent) stripe across the check, back
    and on the sleeves (sometimes I bike in the city and would prefered
    not to get hit by a car)
    - not bulky
    - breathable

    Liner
    -----
    - warm
    - breathable
    - fast drying
    - not bulky

    Anyone have any recommendations for the shell and/or the liner.
    Thanks.

    -jean


    Spyder

    "I think that gay marriage should be between a man and a woman." -Arnold Schwarzenegger, during the California recall campaign

  11. "J. VerSchave" <[email hidden]> wrote in message news:[email hidden]...

    Quoted message said:

    I am looking to buy an all-purpose jacket this year for my
    snowboarding and mountain biking activities.

    What kind of conditions?

    For cycling, I rarely want more than a long-sleeved wool jersey and a
    windbreaker with maybe a base layer when it's really cold. I've probably
    worn Polertec 200 fleece cycling a couple of times. I can't imagine riding
    someplace where that stuff isn't enough (and I'm not going to icebike.com
    to help my imagination). If raining, a shell on the breathable side of the
    waterproof/breathable tradeoff instead of a windbreaker, and maybe a
    lighter jersey instead long-sleeved wool.

    For boarding (at resorts), I'm not so concerned, since if conditions change,
    I too can change. My MEC Northernlight Pullover works pretty well,
    like a fleece + windbreaker, and doesn't hold water, but isn't the best for when
    you get hot. I've got a Bipolar 300 fleece jacket with full front zip, and side vents
    that's my favorite for boarding as it covers a broad temp range. I'm sure
    boarding-specific stuff has advantages, but that stuff works for me so far.

    My cousin never rides in more than a t-shirt and hooded windbreaker, which seems
    like a true "cotton kills" outfit, but this is resort boarding, and it works for him.

  12. "David" <[email hidden]> wrote in message news:[email hidden]...

    Quoted message said:
    Quoted message said:


    My cousin never rides in more than a t-shirt and hooded windbreaker,

    Oops. I meant a thin hooded sweatshirt. Probably a cotton poly blend.
    Dunno how he does it, but he's been riding a long time, and it doesn't
    seem to bother him.

  13. "lal_truckee" <[email hidden]> wrote

    Quoted message said:
    Quoted message said:


    I think shells suck. They all trap sweat like crazy, even the


    "breathable"

    Quoted message said:
    Quoted message said:

    ones. Unless it's raining, I'm wearing fleece with a wind vest, much
    cheaper and tune-able. In the rain, it doesn't matter, you'll get wet
    either way. You just want to keep running water off your body.

    If you leave word where you'll be skiing in the backcountry, we can
    collect the body in the Spring.

    The idea of wearing the same stuff for cycling and snowboarding is really
    dumb. It's hard to think of any other 2 winter sports with such different
    requirements.

  14. "Dmitry" <[email hidden]> wrote in message
    news:J2dmd.615836$8_6.115135@attbi_s04...

    Quoted message said:


    "Peter Cole" <[email hidden]> wrote

    Quoted message said:

    I think shells suck. They all trap sweat like crazy, even the


    "breathable"

    Quoted message said:
    Quoted message said:

    ones. Unless it's raining, I'm wearing fleece with a wind vest, much
    cheaper and tune-able.

    You got to be kidding. Or your "unless" should include
    "cold and/or windy". Where do you ski?

    Quoted message said:

    In the rain, it doesn't matter, you'll get wet
    either way. You just want to keep running water off your body.

    Not true. I boarded in the pouring rain last season
    wrapped in good shells (jacket - Salomon Somatic, pants -
    Arc'teryx Minuteman) and all of my layers other than the
    shell were dry after two hours of this misery 🙂

    Problem with crossposts. I was talking cycling, not skiing. Goretex is
    great for skiing, sucks for cycling. I've also skied all day in the rain
    with it. Only problem I had was that it is way too slippery on wet packed
    snow. I fell at high speed and continued to go, even accelerating, on my
    back, tobogganing for the woods, head-first. Fortunately the trail was a
    broad bowl, and I banked back into the center. Scared me to death.

  15. Dmitry said:

    "Peter Cole" <[email hidden]> wrote

    Quoted message said:

    I think shells suck. They all trap sweat like crazy, even the "breathable"
    ones. Unless it's raining, I'm wearing fleece with a wind vest, much
    cheaper and tune-able.

    You got to be kidding. Or your "unless" should include
    "cold and/or windy". Where do you ski?

    Quoted message said:

    In the rain, it doesn't matter, you'll get wet
    either way. You just want to keep running water off your body.

    Not true. I boarded in the pouring rain last season
    wrapped in good shells (jacket - Salomon Somatic, pants -
    Arc'teryx Minuteman) and all of my layers other than the
    shell were dry after two hours of this misery 🙂


    I'm with Dmitry. I use a shell and up to three layers underneath plus
    balaclava, if necessary. I carry a daypack that I use to stash layers
    as the day goes on and retrieve layers for the last few runs, as
    necessary. The shell and the 1st layer remain constant, but your shell
    should have good pit vents to give you that warm and fuzzy feeling.

    Skiing with a daypack is a whole other subject, so those of you who are
    about to dis me for skiing with a pack inbounds... bite me!!

    RAC

    RAC

  16. In article <rZbmd.341287$wV.27566@attbi_s54>,

    Peter Cole said:

    I think shells suck. They all trap sweat like crazy, even the "breathable"
    ones. Unless it's raining, I'm wearing fleece with a wind vest, much
    cheaper and tune-able. In the rain, it doesn't matter, you'll get wet
    either way. You just want to keep running water off your body.

    I agree, to an extent. I've got a cheap-o windshell from MEC.
    No pit zips or any other frills, except for a long bum-flap
    that keeps hooking on the back of my saddle whenever I want to
    stand on the pedals. Shells suck, but shell-suck sucks even
    worse. Mine's one of those yellow, "security guard" ones; that
    colour aesthetically sucks even further.

    But for short-haul utility runs in light drizzle where putting
    on the rain cape would be more hassle than it's worth, and in
    cooler temps where the ride is too short to get warmed up by
    riding, the shell does the trick. And it's brightly coloured,
    and it has reflective striping on it, so I'm keeping the
    damn thing.

    Short rides suck, too.

    cheers,
    Tom

    --
    -- Nothing is safe from me.
    Above address is just a spam midden.
    I'm really at: tkeats [curlicue] vcn [point] bc [point] ca

  17. "Tom Keats" <[email hidden]> wrote in message .local...

    Quoted message said:
    Quoted message said:

    and it has reflective striping on it,

    You lose big points wearing something with that [censored] stuck
    on it.

  18. In article <Ofzod.314073$%k.2606@pd7tw2no>,

    Fabrizio Mazzoleni said:


    "Tom Keats" <[email hidden]> wrote in message .local...

    Quoted message said:
    Quoted message said:

    and it has reflective striping on it,

    You lose big points wearing something with that [censored] stuck
    on it.

    No sweat. You can have 'em. The points, that is.
    The last thing I need is 'points'.

    So, how's it going with your new Cuisinart Grind-'n-Brew?

    cheers,
    Tom

    --
    -- Nothing is safe from me.
    Above address is just a spam midden.
    I'm really at: tkeats [curlicue] vcn [point] bc [point] ca

  19. Fabrizio Mazzoleni said:


    "Tom Keats" <[email hidden]> wrote in message .local...

    Quoted message said:
    Quoted message said:

    and it has reflective striping on it,

    You lose big points wearing something with that [censored] stuck
    on it.

    I guess you don't think much of tying AOL cds to the back of your bike
    then...

    --
    Cheers,
    Bev
    *----------------------------------------------------*
    *Are you *sure* there's a hyphen in "anal-retentive?"*

  20. The Real Bev said:

    I guess you don't think much of tying AOL cds to the back of your bike
    then...

    I don't think Flabs has scored high enough on the socio-economic scale
    to be sent any anyway ;-)

    Guy
    --
    May contain traces of irony. Contents liable to settle after posting.
    http://www.chapmancentral.co.uk

    88% of helmet statistics are made up, 65% of them at Washington University

Active in the last 60 minutes

Active in this thread

0 users · 0 guests ·0 bots ·0 total

No signed-in users are active right now.

No known search crawlers active right now.