Is there any conventional wisdom on jackets vs smocks?
I'm on the verge of buying a paclite thing, but am torn between Berghaus jacket and smock.
Weight and pack size is quite important to me, enough to make me think the special offer Berghaus Paclite Pro at Cotswold is too heavy and bulky, despite being rather attractively priced at £99.
I like a lot of ventilation, and am going to be doing a bit of running around in the garment.
This *had* led me to favour the increased ventilation of the jacket, but I recently read something suggesting that a smock will have increased breathability 'cos of no seams.
* The air of uk.rec.walking was filled with the delicate perfume * of violets, as Tom <[email hidden]> descended on a shaft * of golden sunlight, and announced:
Quoted message said:
Weight and pack size is quite important to me, enough to make me think the special offer Berghaus Paclite Pro at Cotswold is too heavy and bulky, despite being rather attractively priced at £99.
The Berghaus Paclite Pro (the 99 pounds oe as advertised by Cotswold) is 460 grams and packs into its stuffsac making a ball about 150mm in diameter. I bought one last week and weighed it on a lab balance.
On 18 Sep 2004 21:21:50 GMT, Jim Ford <[email hidden]>
Quoted message said:
Quoted message said:
Weight and pack size is quite important to me, enough to make me think the special offer Berghaus Paclite Pro at Cotswold is too heavy and bulky, despite being rather attractively priced at £99.
The Berghaus Paclite Pro (the 99 pounds oe as advertised by Cotswold) is 460 grams and packs into its stuffsac making a ball about 150mm in diameter. I bought one last week and weighed it on a lab balance.
Is there any conventional wisdom on jackets vs smocks?
I'm on the verge of buying a paclite thing, but am torn between Berghaus jacket and smock.
Weight and pack size is quite important to me, enough to make me think the special offer Berghaus Paclite Pro at Cotswold is too heavy and bulky, despite being rather attractively priced at £99.
Study both the Paclite Pro jacket and the smock carefully. Particularly the design of the hoods.
When I last looked at them (last summer, when they were quite new in the shops), the jacket had a different design of hood to the smock. I thought the jacket hood design to be significantly inferior to the smock if you intend it to work in a typical wet day on a UK hill. That would be enough for me to make the decision between the two garments.
Having tried some smock clothing recently (fleece top, pertex windproof, paclite waterproof), I don't see any huge advantage of jackets, except for the additional pockets which most jacket designs include.
- Nigel
-- NC - Webmaster for http://www.2mm.org.uk/ Replies to newsgroup postings to the newsgroup please.
* The air of uk.rec.walking was filled with the delicate perfume * of violets, as Tom <[email hidden]> descended on a shaft * of golden sunlight, and announced:
Quoted message said:
On 18 Sep 2004 21:21:50 GMT, Jim Ford <[email hidden]>
Quoted message said:
Quoted message said:
Weight and pack size is quite important to me, enough to make me think the special offer Berghaus Paclite Pro at Cotswold is too heavy and bulky, despite being rather attractively priced at £99.
The Berghaus Paclite Pro (the 99 pounds oe as advertised by Cotswold) is 460 grams and packs into its stuffsac making a ball about 150mm in diameter. I bought one last week and weighed it on a lab balance.
Yes, that's exactly what I meant :-)
Tom
But it's lighter than my other Gortex jacket - 707 grams!
Is there any conventional wisdom on jackets vs smocks?
I'm on the verge of buying a paclite thing, but am torn between Berghaus jacket and smock.
Weight and pack size is quite important to me, enough to make me think the special offer Berghaus Paclite Pro at Cotswold is too heavy and bulky, despite being rather attractively priced at £99.
I like a lot of ventilation, and am going to be doing a bit of running around in the garment.
This *had* led me to favour the increased ventilation of the jacket, but I recently read something suggesting that a smock will have increased breathability 'cos of no seams.
Any thoughts?
I like a well ventilated smock. So much so that when going through exactly the same dilemma earlier this year I bought a Paramo Velez. I don't want to be a Paramo bore but this really is a superb garment and with superb ventilation is very comfortable - certainly more so than Paclite IMHE.
I like a well ventilated smock. So much so that when going through
exactly
Quoted message said:
the same dilemma earlier this year I bought a Paramo Velez. I don't want
to
Quoted message said:
be a Paramo bore but this really is a superb garment and with superb ventilation is very comfortable - certainly more so than Paclite IMHE.
I've got the Paramo Velez but I recently bought the Paclite smock. The Paclite certainly does not replace the Paramo but it's ideal for days when I'm spending most of the day walking in a base layer and carrying my waterproof.
On 18/9/04 10:06 pm, in article [email hidden], "Tom" <[email hidden]> wrote:
Quoted message said:
I like a well ventilated smock. So much so that when going through exactly the same dilemma earlier this year I bought a Paramo Velez. I don't want to be a Paramo bore but this really is a superb garment and with superb ventilation is very comfortable - certainly more so than Paclite IMHE.
Yeeesss, looks nice in all sorts of ways, but on my sums I could wear three paclites and still be lighter than a Paramo......
