Well there both nice but it looks like they both have those new crappy intergrated headsets which destroy the frame over time (theres a good review of the major disadvantages of these on the chris king site) For that price I would look at getting a more custom style bike, the sort of thing they sell on the merlin site (http://www.merlincycles.co.uk/acatalog/Merlin_Bikes.html) or keep looking untill you find a bike without those intergrated headsets, perhaps buy a last year model as you can get a better deal that way.