What are the best bike handlebar bags for commuting?

[bikerjohn]

Whats with the obsession over handlebar bags for commuting? Are they really worth the added weight, reduced aerodynamics, and compromised handling? Ive seen riders with these bags loaded to the brim, and Im convinced its more of a hindrance than a help.

Lets be real, if youre commuting in a city, youre likely not carrying a ton of gear, and if you are, maybe you should rethink your packing strategy. A decent backpack or messenger bag can hold everything you need without turning your bike into a wobbly, top-heavy disaster waiting to happen.

That being said, Im willing to be convinced otherwise. What are the best handlebar bags for commuting, and what makes them worth the trade-offs? Is it the convenience of having your gear within easy reach, or is it just a matter of aesthetics? Do you really need a bag thats specifically designed for handlebars, or can you get away with a regular old bag strapped to your bars?

Lets hear from the handlebar bag enthusiasts out there - whats the best option for commuting, and why should I care? Is it the Ortlieb Ultimate 6, the Apidura Expedition Handlebar Pack, or something else entirely? What features should I be looking for, and how do I know if a handlebar bag is right for me?

 

[teamRiderFTW]

Handlebar bags have their merits, especially for long-distance commuters. They offer easy access to essentials, and some are designed to minimize aerodynamic drag. However, they can be a hindrance in crowded city streets due to the increased width. It's not about the bag, but how and where you use it. Consider your route and needs before choosing.

 

[splatt77]

Handlebar bags can indeed be a contentious topic in the cycling community. While they do have their drawbacks, such as added weight and reduced aerodynamics, some commuters swear by them for their convenience. Having your gear within easy reach can be a game-changer, especially on long commutes or if you need to access items frequently.

That being said, it's important to choose the right handlebar bag for your needs. Aesthetics may play a role, but functionality and durability should be your top priorities. Look for a bag that is waterproof, as this will protect your gear from the elements. Reflective details are also a plus, as they can increase your visibility on the road.

As for whether you need a bag specifically designed for handlebars, the answer is: it depends. Some commuters find that a regular old bag strapped to their bars works just fine. However, handlebar bags are designed with cycling-specific features, such as mounting systems that keep the bag stable while you ride.

If you're still on the fence, consider trying out a few different options to see what works best for you. The Ortlieb Ultimate 6 and the Apidura Expedition Handlebar Pack are both popular choices, but there are many other options available as well. Ultimately, the best handlebar bag for commuting is the one that meets your specific needs and makes your commute more enjoyable.