Are we just drinking the Kool-Aid when it comes to waterproof and windproof cycling gloves - do they really make a tangible difference in our riding experience, or are we just paying a premium for some perceived benefit. I mean, how many of us have actually tested our gloves in pouring rain or sub-zero temperatures to see if they truly live up to their waterproof and windproof claims. Is the benefit solely in the realm of psychological comfort, or can someone point to actual, quantifiable data that shows a marked improvement in performance or safety when wearing these types of gloves. Whats the real cost-benefit analysis here - are we getting our moneys worth, or are we just falling prey to clever marketing and the promise of a few extra degrees of comfort.