F
Scott wrote:
> [email protected] wrote:
> >
> > First, I don't see how riders are going to apply any significant
> > impulses with frequencies higher than the pedaling rate. And if they
> > somehow did, those would be expected to be essentially identical on the
> > two frames.
> >
> >
> > - Frank Krygowski
>
> The vibrations coming through the frame will resonate in buttisimo
> region of the rider, creating a jiggling effect. Said jiggling often
> magnifies the vibration, and if the rider is not careful, the result is
> a harmonic resonance that causes the frame to vibrate itself apart.
Sorry, no.
It sounds like you're thinking of the rider's mass causing resonance.
But the resonant frequency of a large mass is low, other things being
equal. The presence of the rider is going to reduce the "jiggling" at
the surface of the saddle, not increase it.
Reach into your desk and find a rubber band. Hang something with very
little mass from the rubber band (a tiny ball of crumpled paper,
perhaps) and pluck the rubber band. You should see lots of "jiggling."
Repeat by hanging something massier, like a magazine. Pluck again.
The magazine won't jiggle nearly as much.
- Frank Krygowski
> [email protected] wrote:
> >
> > First, I don't see how riders are going to apply any significant
> > impulses with frequencies higher than the pedaling rate. And if they
> > somehow did, those would be expected to be essentially identical on the
> > two frames.
> >
> >
> > - Frank Krygowski
>
> The vibrations coming through the frame will resonate in buttisimo
> region of the rider, creating a jiggling effect. Said jiggling often
> magnifies the vibration, and if the rider is not careful, the result is
> a harmonic resonance that causes the frame to vibrate itself apart.
Sorry, no.
It sounds like you're thinking of the rider's mass causing resonance.
But the resonant frequency of a large mass is low, other things being
equal. The presence of the rider is going to reduce the "jiggling" at
the surface of the saddle, not increase it.
Reach into your desk and find a rubber band. Hang something with very
little mass from the rubber band (a tiny ball of crumpled paper,
perhaps) and pluck the rubber band. You should see lots of "jiggling."
Repeat by hanging something massier, like a magazine. Pluck again.
The magazine won't jiggle nearly as much.
- Frank Krygowski