General fitness, health and nutrition · Public discussion

the Inuit paradox

Started by TC · · Last activity · 3 posts · 501 views

Thread details

What we know about this thread

Original section
General fitness, health and nutrition
Published
26 April 2005
Last activity
26 April 2005
Original author
TC
Posts
3
Discussion status
Public discussion
Total views
501
Views / 30 days
0

The navigation and discussion metadata provide context. Posts remain in their original chronological order.

Showing posts 1–3 of 3
Posts remain in their original chronological order.

Text size
  1. http://www.sciencentral.com/articles/view.php3?article_id=218392410&cat=1_3

    Native Diet
    Search

    As you dig into your Thanksgiving leftovers, take a lesson from our
    neighbors to the far north?not all fat is created equal. This
    ScienCentral News video has more.

    Good Fat

    Thanksgiving marks the beginning of the Season of Eating, a time when
    many of us go off our diets. But the Inuit people of the Far North did
    not have a choice of diets. They led a subsistence way of life.

    Patricia Cochran, an Inupiat who grew up in Nome, Alaska and is now the
    executive director of the Alaska Native Science Commission, grew up
    living off the land. "As I say in our areas in Alaska, our Safeway
    store is when you open up your door," she says. "That's where we go
    shopping, that's where we find our food. We really did grow up in a
    very traditional way, living off the land, learning how to hunt, how to
    fish?we had everything from marine mammals to small birds to roots and
    berries, and herbs, a lot of fish, and in my particular area, reindeer
    was an important part of our subsistence foods as well."

    "The Inuit people are numerous groups of hunter-gatherers," says Loren
    Cordain, a professor in the Department of Health and Exercise Science
    at Colorado State University and author of the book The Paleo Diet.
    "It's not a single group. There are many, many cultures and they lived
    in many many parts of the Arctic. There was no single Inuit diet, other
    than the fact that none of them had a whole lot of carbohydrate or
    fresh fruits and vegetables."

    image: ABC News
    Scientists studying the Inuit in the 1970s found that as a group, they
    suffered much less than their European counterparts from certain
    diseases, such as coronary heart disease, rheumatoid arthritis, and
    diabetes mellitus. Yet their diet was very high in fat from eating
    foods like whale, seal, and salmon. Discover Magazine called this the
    "Inuit Paradox."

    The solution to the paradox may lie in the fact that not all fat is
    created equal. "[The Inuit] ate a lot of marine animals, like walruses
    and seals, whales and so forth, and the blubber of these animals is a
    very high source of monounsaturated fat,"says Cordain. "So if you
    contrast the Inuit diet to the Western diet, it actually turns out to
    be lower in saturated fat?very high in fat, but high in healthful fat,
    monounsaturates and polyunsaturates, high in a specific type of
    polyunsaturates called omega-3 fatty acids that come from the marine
    food chain."

    Cordain says that while the Inuit diet is not optimal, there are a few
    things we can learn from it. "Let's take the good of the Inuit, the
    lean protein, the good fats?minimize refined cereal, the refined
    sugars, and increase the fruit and vegetables in our diet," he says,
    adding that the single most important thing we can do in our diets is
    increase the omega-3 fatty acids, which are found in many oily fish.

    For Cochran, food is as much cultural as it is nutritional. "The food
    is an important part of who we are, and our relationship to the land
    and the Creator is an important part of who we are," says Cochran. "Our
    foods, our traditional foods, the wild foods that come from Mother
    Earth, are the things that nourish us, not only our minds but also our
    bodies and our souls. They are really all connected. I think a lot of
    people could learn from the fact that our communities have been around
    for centuries and there's a reason that our communities have been
    around for centuries. We are a very healthy, resilient, adaptable
    community and we have been able to live in the harshest environments
    anywhere on the planet and to not only survive, but really to thrive in
    those conditions. There's no question to me that that is an important
    lesson for the rest of the world to experience."

    ---

    Yet another "paradox". How can so many peoples around the world eat so
    poorly, according to the USDA pyramid, and still be healthy and the US
    people who follow the USDA be so obese?

    TC

  2. This "report" is the usual incredible garbage. I investigated these
    Eskimo claims a few years back, and what I found is that on the
    "traditional diet," high in omega 6 PUFAs, these people rarely lived
    beyond the age of 40. On such a diet, the risk of bleeding to death
    from minor blunt force trauma is incredible. Bleeding time is
    increased dramatically, even compared to European peoples who eat quite
    a bit of fish themselves (the Danish). Yet our great "experts" fail to
    mention that those who eat lots of coconut or palm product not only
    live long, despite rudimentary "health care systems," but have very low
    rates of "chronic disease." Go to the World Health Organization and
    see the statistics for yourself. You also hear about the great
    "Mediterranean Diet," yet when you look at the statistics at the WHO
    site, you don't really see anything to get all that excited about. For
    example, compare the cancer rates of Italians to Americans. The key
    mechanism is stress to cells, and while UV radiation and other things
    are problems, dietary polyunsaturated (in conjunction with too much
    iron and not enough antioxidants) are the underly reason for the high
    "chronic disease" rates in nations like the USA. Lipid peroxidation
    even causes cholesterol to be changed into the only real "bad" form,
    known as oxysterols, which do indeed "clog arteries." LDL is not "bad"
    as long as it is not oxidized, and HDL is not "good" if it gets
    oxidized.

  3. montygram said:

    This "report" is the usual incredible garbage. I investigated these
    Eskimo claims a few years back, and what I found is that on the
    "traditional diet," high in omega 6 PUFAs, these people rarely lived
    beyond the age of 40.

    Where did you get this number from?

    On such a diet, the risk of bleeding to death

    Quoted message said:

    from minor blunt force trauma is incredible. Bleeding time is
    increased dramatically, even compared to European peoples who eat


    quite

    Quoted message said:

    a bit of fish themselves (the Danish).

    Why?

    Yet our great "experts" fail to

    Quoted message said:

    mention that those who eat lots of coconut or palm product not only
    live long, despite rudimentary "health care systems," but have very


    low

    Quoted message said:

    rates of "chronic disease." Go to the World Health Organization and
    see the statistics for yourself. You also hear about the great
    "Mediterranean Diet," yet when you look at the statistics at the WHO
    site, you don't really see anything to get all that excited about.


    For

    Quoted message said:

    example, compare the cancer rates of Italians to Americans. The key
    mechanism is stress to cells, and while UV radiation and other things
    are problems, dietary polyunsaturated (in conjunction with too much
    iron and not enough antioxidants) are the underly reason for the high
    "chronic disease" rates in nations like the USA. Lipid peroxidation
    even causes cholesterol to be changed into the only real "bad" form,
    known as oxysterols, which do indeed "clog arteries." LDL is not


    "bad"

    Quoted message said:

    as long as it is not oxidized, and HDL is not "good" if it gets
    oxidized.

Active in the last 60 minutes

Active in this thread

0 users · 0 guests ·0 bots ·0 total

No signed-in users are active right now.

No known search crawlers active right now.