Cycling Equipment · Public discussion

Shimano hub noise?

Started by Shawn Amir · · Last activity · 3 posts · 595 views

Thread details

What we know about this thread

Original section
Cycling Equipment
Published
4 August 2004
Last activity
8 August 2004
Original author
Shawn Amir
Posts
3
Discussion status
Public discussion
Total views
595
Views / 30 days
0

The navigation and discussion metadata provide context. Posts remain in their original chronological order.

Showing posts 1–3 of 3
Posts remain in their original chronological order.

Text size
  1. I get a grinding noise coming from the vicinity of my 7700 (9sp DA) rear hub
    during the highest-torque portion of my pedal down-stroke at the end of long
    climbs and only in the largest 2-3 cogs (27, 24, or 21). This seems to
    happen only when the temperature dips to <55F (at elevation) and is cured
    when I start going downhill, which also puts me in warmer temperature. The
    noise seems in synch with the chain speed and is not caused by any
    observable rubbing or rear derailleur miss-adjustment. There are no
    abnormal noises when freewheeling, the hub seems well-adjusted, and there is
    no pawl slippage that I can detect.

    At one point I had the theory that the removable derailleur hanger/dropout
    on my Cannondale was perhaps shifting because of climbing torque and giving
    a slight angle to the rear wheel--braking for the descent would then slip it
    back! So I tightened it and the noise went away...alas my
    self-congratulations were premature as the timing also coincided with the
    weather changing. I got the noise again this Sunday during an
    uncharacteristic cold snap, so there goes my last theory.

    Any suggestions?

    Cheers, Shawn

  2. Shawn Amir said:

    I get a grinding noise coming from the vicinity of my 7700 (9sp DA) rear hub
    during the highest-torque portion of my pedal down-stroke at the end of long
    climbs and only in the largest 2-3 cogs (27, 24, or 21). This seems to
    happen only when the temperature dips to <55F (at elevation) and is cured
    when I start going downhill, which also puts me in warmer temperature. The
    noise seems in synch with the chain speed and is not caused by any
    observable rubbing or rear derailleur miss-adjustment. There are no
    abnormal noises when freewheeling, the hub seems well-adjusted, and there is
    no pawl slippage that I can detect.

    At one point I had the theory that the removable derailleur hanger/dropout
    on my Cannondale was perhaps shifting because of climbing torque and giving
    a slight angle to the rear wheel--braking for the descent would then slip it
    back! So I tightened it and the noise went away...alas my
    self-congratulations were premature as the timing also coincided with the
    weather changing. I got the noise again this Sunday during an
    uncharacteristic cold snap, so there goes my last theory.

    Any suggestions?

    Cheers, Shawn

    Can you find some locals that are willing to do some temporary parts swapping?
    I would try swapping the rear wheel first to help eliminate it as the source... and because it is easily done.
    I would also check the chain and cogs for wear.
    I would clean the rear derailer, making sure that you put the jockey wheels back into their proper positions. Check over the derailer for anything that looks suspicious like sloppy lose pivots or pivots that don't pivot freely.
    Check for run-out and wobble in your hub and freehub.
    Check for lose cogs on your casette.

  3. No easy answers I guess... Thanks for the suggestions Dave, I will do as you
    said.

    Cheers, Shawn

Active in the last 60 minutes

Active in this thread

0 users · 0 guests ·0 bots ·0 total

No signed-in users are active right now.

No known search crawlers active right now.