General fitness, health and nutrition · Public discussion

Re: What's your weight. Bottom line.

Started by Roger Zoul · · Last activity · 3 posts · 283 views

Thread details

What we know about this thread

Original section
General fitness, health and nutrition
Published
22 February 2005
Last activity
22 February 2005
Original author
Roger Zoul
Posts
3
Discussion status
Public discussion
Total views
283
Views / 30 days
0

The navigation and discussion metadata provide context. Posts remain in their original chronological order.

Showing posts 1–3 of 3
Posts remain in their original chronological order.

Text size
  1. Are you asking about water weight simply from what you drink every day while
    maintaining a LC woe? Who cares? Just get on the scale at the same time
    everyday and forget about it.

    Or, are you asking about the additional water weight your body will hold in
    your muscle and liver when you consume a large amount of carbs after being
    on LC for a fair amount of time? That is a more real question, IMO, because
    as you graduatelly increase your carb intake you might find yourself
    approaching the higher weight. Or, if you should carb up your wieght will
    increase due to holding water. So, if while on low carb you weigh X, then it
    is very possible that when not on LC you could weigh X+Y, when Y is the
    weight of the water held in your muscles and liver. I consider both of
    those to be real, meaningful numbers.

    Perdu said:

    Probably does not matter much. But there has been much discussion on
    "water weight" and so on, especially during the initial period of
    lowcarb.

    But when you bounce 6 or 7 pounds a day, it is beginning to make no
    sense.

    If someone can vary as much as 6 or 7 pounds a day it becomes
    suspicious. Is it the scale? I had it tested and it's a new Tanita.
    Checked against the doctor's office. All good. My wife is
    consistently weighs in within .5 pounds. Each day.

    Ok. So I do drink a lot of water. Probably not enough, but what I
    call a lot. 60 to 80 oz a day. (I think. Had not measured.)

    So the question is - you weigh between 245 and 251 lbs. What is your
    REAL weight? the first of the morning 245, or the late afternoon 251?

    Before the avalanche - yes I know one should not obsess with
    weighing too many times. Once a week is preferred, by my humble
    research. But even then, how can one know? Gotto arrive at your goal
    and stay there 2 years before you stabilize?

    Let it rip..
    __
    Best Regards,

    Steve

    Tout est per·du fors l'hon·neur

  2. You will always fluctuate. A pint of water weighs a pound so drink a pint
    of water, beer, pop, coffee and you will weigh a pound more than you did
    before drinking it. Eventually it will leave your system but not for a
    while.

    In news:[email hidden],
    Perdu <[email hidden]> stated
    |
    | Pretty much. I have it figured out that the same time weight in is
    | what counts. I'm kind of asking the ACTUAL weight. What is the true
    | weight. Low on water, saturated half up or all the way up. This,
    | using the "tank" you have to hold the water.
    |
    | Once you have balanced out, you will hold X amount of water. As a
    | person who does not fluctuate will. But while you are fluctuating
    | this much, which point is the True weight?
    |
    | You're correct in - who cares. It's just a physiological question I
    | cannot decide. Chicken and Egg kind of thing.
    |
    | Best Regards,
    |
    | Steve
    |
    | Tout est per·du fors l'hon·neur

  3. The chicken came first.

    "Perdu" <[email hidden]> wrote in message
    news:[email hidden]...

    Quoted message said:

    On Mon, 21 Feb 2005 20:15:05 -0500, "Roger Zoul" <[email hidden]>
    Cried out loud... :

    Quoted message said:

    Are you asking about water weight simply from what you drink every day


    while

    Quoted message said:
    Quoted message said:

    maintaining a LC woe? Who cares? Just get on the scale at the same


    time

    Quoted message said:
    Quoted message said:

    everyday and forget about it.

    Pretty much. I have it figured out that the same time weight in is what
    counts. I'm kind of asking the ACTUAL weight. What is the true weight. Low
    on water, saturated half up or all the way up. This, using the "tank" you
    have to hold the water.

    Once you have balanced out, you will hold X amount of water. As a person
    who does not fluctuate will. But while you are fluctuating this much,


    which

    Quoted message said:

    point is the True weight?

    You're correct in - who cares. It's just a physiological question I


    cannot

    Quoted message said:

    decide. Chicken and Egg kind of thing.

    Best Regards,

    Steve

    Tout est per·du fors l'hon·neur

Active in the last 60 minutes

Active in this thread

0 users · 0 guests ·0 bots ·0 total

No signed-in users are active right now.

No known search crawlers active right now.