BBC News 28 March 2005:
Statement 1: "Falls and fractures could be a thing of the past if
everyone aged 65 and older were to take extra vitamin D, experts
believe."
Statement 2: "Dr Heike Bischoff-Ferrari ... estimates that taking
daily vitamin D supplements would reduce an elderly person's risk of
falling by at least a fifth."
Statement 3: "Dr Frazer Anderson ... estimated that daily calcium
(1g) and vitamin D (20 micrograms), either alone or in combination,
would mean one fewer person each year per 100 would sustain a
fracture."
Slight difference, eh wot?
The truth is that the interaction of calcium, fluorine and Vitamin D
on osteoporosis alone is a scientific mare's nest, and the North
American dairy industry sure isn't helping us to understand it.
Increasing Vitamin D as you get older probably does help - I aim for
400 IU/day myself now - but there is a lot of dispute about the two
minerals and how Vitamin D interacts with them.