General fitness, health and nutrition · Public discussion

Re: Chest pains. Over exercise?

Started by JC Der Koenig · · Last activity · 4 posts · 402 views

Thread details

What we know about this thread

Original section
General fitness, health and nutrition
Published
14 March 2005
Last activity
14 March 2005
Original author
JC Der Koenig
Posts
4
Discussion status
Public discussion
Total views
402
Views / 30 days
0

The navigation and discussion metadata provide context. Posts remain in their original chronological order.

Showing posts 1–4 of 4
Posts remain in their original chronological order.

Text size
  1. It's called retribution.

    --
    You take stupid to a new level. -- MFW

    "Perdu" <[email hidden]> wrote in message
    news:[email hidden]...

    Quoted message said:


    Just found it curious upon raising my level of walking, light jogging,
    jump roping and so on, I've noticed upper chest pains. It quickly subsides
    when I rest up for a minute or so. But it does get painful. It does not
    seem to be in the heart area, and it is on both sides of the front of the
    chest and down the left arm if I really get my heart going.

    I've done very little if any exercise in the past. I don't much care for
    it. But now that I made my peace with it, I am stepping it up. Any
    comments
    on this?

    I'm setting up a doctor's appointment ASAP, of course. And will refrain
    from over working the heart until I get a clear picture. Just wanted some
    ideas, whether or not it happens to others that start off exercising after
    not doing so for so long.
    --
    Best Regards,

    Steve

    Tout est per·du fors l'hon·neur

  2. "Just found it curious upon raising my level of walking, light jogging,

    jump roping and so on, I've noticed upper chest pains. It quickly
    subsides
    when I rest up for a minute or so. But it does get painful. It does not

    seem to be in the heart area, and it is on both sides of the front of
    the
    chest and down the left arm if I really get my heart going.

    I've done very little if any exercise in the past. I don't much care
    for
    it. But now that I made my peace with it, I am stepping it up. Any
    comments
    on this?

    I'm setting up a doctor's appointment ASAP, of course. And will
    refrain
    from over working the heart until I get a clear picture. Just wanted
    some
    ideas, whether or not it happens to others that start off exercising
    after
    not doing so for so long. "

    This is not normal. You should get to a doctor immeadiately and
    refrain from
    any excercise until you get checked out. The symptoms you have,
    especially
    the pain radiating down the left arm, could definitely be heart related
    and need
    to be checked out. I'd be sure to have a cardiac stress test done as
    part of the
    diagnosis.

  3. Quoted post said:
    Quoted message said:

    Just found it curious upon raising my level of walking, light
    jogging, jump roping and so on, I've noticed upper chest
    pains. It quickly subsides when I rest up for a minute or so.

    The key point there is "quickly subsides". My bet is that if
    you take your pulse, you'll find that there is some specific
    rate at which it goes away.

    Quoted message said:
    Quoted message said:

    But it does get painful. It does not seem to be in the heart
    area, and it is on both sides of the front of the chest and
    down the left arm if I really get my heart going.

    Note that the actual location of the pain is not really
    significant. The type of pain isn't either.

    Let me tell you a story, to put that into perspective. An EMT
    or an paramedic is not allowed to touch you without permission,
    which means if you are able to say yes or no, you *must* say yes
    or they can't. If you are unable, they have implied permission
    and can assume you would say yes if you only could.

    So John Doe is sitting at a bar having a beer, and begins to
    experience severe pains in the chest area. Bad enough to double
    him over and cause his face to be a bit pale and drawn such that
    a couple people notice that he is in distress. They ask him if
    he's okay, and he describes the pain. Over his objections, they
    call for an ambulance, which arrives in 3 minutes and 43 seconds
    (cracker jack crew :-).

    John Doe tells the medics that he is having indigestion, and
    doesn't want to have them doing anything that he'll get a bill
    for, so *hands* *off* is the word. John Doe is beginning to
    look like death warmed over too, as his face is pale and his
    forehead is obviously moist.

    The paramedics can't touch him... so they wait. They sit down
    at the bar, and order lemonade. They get half of it down too,
    before John Doe collapses on the floor, unconscious. He has
    just suffered a second, more serious, myocardial infarction
    (MI), commonly known as a "heart attack". He is immediately
    treated, given an electro shock to restart his heart, which was
    just quivering all over (fibrillation). He is transported to
    the hospital emergency room, and soon transfered to a regular
    room where he is wired to an ekg for a "few days" of
    observation.

    John Doe suffers a massive MI three days later an cannot be revived.
    The funeral is 3 days later.

    What's the significance? Several points of interest.
    "Indigestion" is *commonly* what people think they are feeling
    when they have a heart attack. If they are *immediately*
    treated the consequences are greatly reduced. Those
    consequences are that an artery to the heart muscle is blocked
    to at least some degree, and if it is totally blocked the part
    of the muscle that it supplies blood to will simply die. If it
    is a major artery, and a significant area dies... the patient
    is dead. But if it is a small area, and the blood flow can be
    restarted, the muscle can heal up. However, during the first
    few days as it heals there is a very great chance that the
    process will cause the heart to become unstable due to false
    electrical signals that come from the forming of scar tissue on
    the heart.

    That is why refusing assistance in the first place is deadly.
    And it is also the reason that people who have a minor heart
    attack are kept "for observation" for a few days... and
    sometimes die.

    *Don't* *put* *yourself* *in* *that* *situation* *unnecessarily*!

    Quoted message said:
    Quoted message said:

    I've done very little if any exercise in the past. I don't
    much care for it. But now that I made my peace with it, I am
    stepping it up. Any comments on this?

    Yeah. Cool it until you get a checkup.

    Quoted message said:
    Quoted message said:

    I'm setting up a doctor's appointment ASAP, of course. And
    will refrain from over working the heart until I get a clear
    picture. Just wanted some ideas, whether or not it happens to
    others that start off exercising after not doing so for so
    long.

    Once upon a time I had a cardiologist do a workup on me. He
    said I needed another appointment, but with a different doctor.
    The other doctor said it would be okay to put it off for a few
    days, but not more than a couple weeks. He basically told me
    not to lift anything heavier than my left foot until then...

    Of course, the "other doctor" was a surgeon. The fact that I
    could, and did, put it off for two weeks turned out to be
    significant, and very unusual. Few people have that option, but
    I did simply because I'd had a lot of advance warning, and some
    significant training. I spotted what was going on before it was
    too late. But the more common way it works is what had happened
    to my younger brother a few years before me (that was my advance
    warning!). He was told to lay down, and do *not* even so much
    as stand up. They took him directly to surgery.

    Quoted message said:

    This is not normal. You should get to a doctor immeadiately
    and refrain from any excercise until you get checked out. The
    symptoms you have, especially the pain radiating down the left
    arm, could definitely be heart related and need to be checked
    out. I'd be sure to have a cardiac stress test done as part of
    the diagnosis.

    Excellent advice. *Do* *it* *now*. Do *not* put it off for
    even a few days.

    The difference can be very significant. I know a couple dozen
    people who've had a bypass done. When I had mine (1998) they
    *all* told me the same thing: after surgery you will get
    depressed, so be prepared. Except what I noticed was they all
    gave me a time frame too (3 weeks, 1 week, 6 weeks, etc), and
    they were all different! I thought that was odd, but didn't
    understand until much later, when it became clear what had
    happened.

    I had two weeks to prepare for being out of commission for 3
    months. I put my things in order, and basically set myself up
    for a long vacation.

    I had time to cover all the bases, and that is exactly what none
    of those other people had been able to do. So one guy's business
    went to Hell 4 weeks after he had surgery... which he knew was
    happening and couldn't do a thing to avoid, so he got depressed.
    Another guy's situation took 6 weeks, and someone else's took 3
    weeks. That was why they all had different times to depression!

    Me? I had a *wonderful* three month long vacation! I stayed
    for a while with 3 different kids of mine, and didn't come home
    until I had to go back to work. Depression??? I was too busy
    having fun!

    Early detection and treatment helps. The way to ensure that is
    to spend a lot of time talking to doctors about how you will
    know it's time.

    --
    Floyd L. Davidson <http://web.newsguy.com/floyd_davidson>
    Ukpeagvik (Barrow, Alaska) [email hidden]

  4. [email hidden] (Floyd L. Davidson) wrote in
    news:[email hidden]:

    Quoted message said:

    John Doe tells the medics that he is having indigestion, and
    doesn't want to have them doing anything that he'll get a bill
    for, so *hands* *off* is the word. John Doe is beginning to
    look like death warmed over too, as his face is pale and his
    forehead is obviously moist.

    I witnessed this scenario at a restaurant in Bethesda MD about 8 years ago.
    Guy in his late 40s/early 50s having an obvious cardiac incident (obvious
    to me, the manager, the waiters, and the EMTs, anyway), but refused to let
    the EMTs touch him and said he had an upset stomach. Embarassed, he cajoled
    his wife into leaving the restaurant. I still wonder if later that night he
    had a bigger MI, or maybe at some point months or years later. And I wonder
    if he's still alive.

    Cate

Active in the last 60 minutes

Active in this thread

0 users · 0 guests ·0 bots ·0 total

No signed-in users are active right now.

No known search crawlers active right now.