OK, if I had to choose between the two, and there were no alternatives,
I'd choose the Madone--under protest. Reason would be the geometry, the
pilot's a bit too laid back for my tastes. It does have braze ons for
that practical stuff you might want one day tho, and you cn always
slide the saddle forward.
I think you should explore other bikes, as neither the Madone or Pilot
seem to be in the sweet spot you want.
Think braze ons. Even if you set the bike up with uber light fun wheels
at first, there may come a day when you want 28mm tires, skinny fenders
and a rack to make commuting a bit more sensible.