Bike buying advice · Public discussion

Need some advice, can't decide

Started by galpd320 · · Last activity · 4 posts · 1,663 views

Thread details

What we know about this thread

Original section
Bike buying advice
Published
31 January 2007
Last activity
1 February 2007
Original author
galpd320
Posts
4
Discussion status
Public discussion
Total views
1,663
Views / 30 days
0

The navigation and discussion metadata provide context. Posts remain in their original chronological order.

Showing posts 1–4 of 4
Posts remain in their original chronological order.

Text size
  1. Hello group,

    I am new here, but not new to cycling. I do however have kind of a newbie question that is nagging me. I have searched and read a few posts relating to the topic, but none seem to be conclusive for me.

    I have ridden and raced mountain bikes for years and used to sell and wrench mtb and road bikes through high school and college. I do know the differences in most bikes, frames, components, etc. Enough of the BS though, let me get to the question.

    I am looking for a new road bike and thought I wanted the Trek 2100 that my LBS was selling for $1399 (yes it's a great deal). However, I as many others, have seen online, several Motobecane and Windsor bikes around the same price range with much better components, wheels, cranks, etc. The Trek has primarially 105 with an Ultegra rear der. The Motobecanes have full Ultegra with FSA carbon cranks, American Classic wheels, etc.

    The big question is with the frames on these bikes. The frames are made by Kenisis in Taiwan, the same manufacturer that makes frames for many other brand name bikes, and have a lifetime warranty on them. I also have a LBS close by that sell these models and can probably get warranty support from them if needed. They even have prices at that LBS that are competitive with the online price, so I could buy from them if I wanted to be sure of their support.

    I know Trek is a great bike (I've had two of them) and have great customer support. So should I go with them for those reasons and settle for a lower component group (I won't be racing after all, but I would like to brag about my upper level components if I had them 😉 ) Or should I beleive that these Kenesis frames are the same frames as other major brands with different stickers and get a great deal on a superb component group and quality carbon/aluminum frame?

    Sorry for the long winded newbie question and I appreciate any advice.

  2. What's more important to you? Brag or $$?

    Seriously, there's not much to choose between 105 and Ultegra in terms of performance. And you get the support of your LBS by buying there. 😎

  3. DMF said:

    What's more important to you? Brag or $$?

    Seriously, there's not much to choose between 105 and Ultegra in terms of performance. And you get the support of your LBS by buying there. 😎

    You have a good point. I was realy only half serious about the brag :p but as far as money, the bikes are the same price and I have LBS that sell both. You are very realistic in saying that the 105 and Ultegra are not enough of a difference to notice, but I'm worried that I get 105 and want Ultegra a few months down the road just because. I know, it's crazy and unreasonable, I can't help it :o .
    I think, however, I have decided to go for the Trek. My thinking now is that although the frame has a lifetime warranty, the company does not. Motobecane had already gone bankrupt; if it does again, bye bye warranty. Trek will be around for a long time I'm sure.
    There is also a Felt in the same price range I've been eyeballing. That brings up my decision making battle again. Felt....Trek....Hmmmm 😕

  4. galpd320 said:

    You have a good point. I was realy only half serious about the brag :p but as far as money, the bikes are the same price and I have LBS that sell both. You are very realistic in saying that the 105 and Ultegra are not enough of a difference to notice, but I'm worried that I get 105 and want Ultegra a few months down the road just because. I know, it's crazy and unreasonable, I can't help it :o .
    I think, however, I have decided to go for the Trek. My thinking now is that although the frame has a lifetime warranty, the company does not. Motobecane had already gone bankrupt; if it does again, bye bye warranty. Trek will be around for a long time I'm sure.
    There is also a Felt in the same price range I've been eyeballing. That brings up my decision making battle again. Felt....Trek....Hmmmm 😕


    It's always tough to make a decision on buying bikes. I've had the same problem in mountain biking (specifically with the first bike purchase). Currently we're going through the same situation with first road bikes. I'm pretty sold on the Specialized Roubaix Expert Compact Rival, but I know that if I go with a "non-branded" carbon frame I can get a few better components, or a carbon bar added and it'll still be cheaper.

    That being said... I really like the Expert bike.

    What to do... 🙂

    I guess go with your gut instinct! That, and I think everyone is pretty happy with any bike they end up with.

Active in the last 60 minutes

Active in this thread

0 users · 0 guests ·0 bots ·0 total

No signed-in users are active right now.

No known search crawlers active right now.