Australia and New Zealand · Public discussion

Modern MTB questions

Started by Andy B · · Last activity · 5 posts · 545 views

Thread details

What we know about this thread

Original section
Australia and New Zealand
Published
8 March 2004
Last activity
16 March 2004
Original author
Andy B
Posts
5
Discussion status
Public discussion
Total views
545
Views / 30 days
0

The navigation and discussion metadata provide context. Posts remain in their original chronological order.

Showing posts 1–5 of 5
Posts remain in their original chronological order.

Text size
  1. Hi

    I own a 1990 Diamond Back Topanga which has done more km's than I
    could imagine. It's needing some repairs, so am I'm borrowing a bike
    (Giant Rincon) from work for my commute in the interim.

    As I'm considering retiring the Topanga, I've got some questions about
    newer bikes.

    This is the first bike I've ridden with front shocks (RS Suntour XCR),
    and while they're usefull when hitting ruts etc, I find them a pain
    when trying to accelerate fast, as the font end feels like it's
    bouncing all over the shop. Is this a technique thing? I've tightned
    them up as much as possible (adjustment knobs on top), so they're not
    too washy while riding. Can you get shocks that offer more support,
    while still providing a damping effect when it's needed? I've also
    noticed that they take a while to recover from being compressed, so on
    a section that's very rutted out, they'll probably end up compressing
    and not extend before the next rut, so will stay in a compressed state
    untill the road/track smooths out.

    The frame geometary is very different to what I'm used to. It almost
    looks like a girls bike compared to mine, in that the top tube travels
    down from the head. I'm guessing that by having smaller triangles,
    the frame's stiffer. The problem I find with this, is that I end up
    sitting over the back wheel, as the seat post is at an angle, and has
    to be extended about a foot to be the correct height. When I peddle,
    instead of being over the peddles, they're in front of me. To give
    you an idea, when my foot is at the top of the peddling arc, my knee
    is directly above the bottom bracket. I find this neither a
    comfortable nor powerfull riding position. Is this the new way to
    ride?

    Lastly, what price should i expect to pay second had for a 6-12 month
    old bike in good condition, with a new RRP of around $1,500 (In Bris
    if it makes any difference)?

    Thanks for any insight you can offer.

    Andy

  2. "Andy B" <[email hidden]> wrote in message
    news:[email hidden]...

    Quoted message said:

    This is the first bike I've ridden with front shocks (RS Suntour XCR),
    and while they're usefull when hitting ruts etc, I find them a pain
    when trying to accelerate fast, as the font end feels like it's
    bouncing all over the shop. Is this a technique thing? I've tightned

    Yes and no. Better shocks will tend to have a "locked" effect
    for normal pedalling action but still absorb bigger hits. You
    might find that you are expending too much energy shaking
    the bike around on takeoff - hence the shock bounce. Try
    taking off hard without bouncing the shocks. Instead of
    planting your feet and letting your body move forward in
    opposition to the hard pedalling, try bracing your arms and
    stomach to hold your upper body rigid while taking off. This
    should reduce shock bouncing and give you faster takeoff.

    Quoted message said:

    Can you get shocks that offer more support,
    while still providing a damping effect when it's needed?

    I would say so - the range of suspension forks these days
    is HUGE. AFAIK Suntour forks aren't "up there" if you
    know what I mean. I will happily accept a correction on
    this point. Marzocchi, RockShox, Fox and others are the
    brands to look for. Or, just go rigid - cheaper, lighter,
    faster (on road). :-)

    hippy

  3. *time for a long-time lurker to wade in with a first post* 🙂

    Can't comment on the frame geometry issue. (The Rincon is a MTB, not
    hybrid.) Could be an issue of size/fit or maybe just not what you'r
    used to. The top tube travels down from the end often to give you a bi
    more 'crotch room' for when things get technical, and yes, it ca
    stiffen up the frame a bit more

    In terms of suspension, I think you've probably been given a ba
    impression by the Suntours, which are by no means a sophisticate
    fork... I commute most days about 30plus kms on a dual-suspensio
    mountain bike and don't find it a problem, but then it is a XC oriente
    machine and I'm fairly lightweight, which helps. Yes, you do ge
    suspension bounce on climbs, but this can be minimized as Hipp
    indicated, by smoothing out your motions. It never cancels it ou
    completely (well, maybe on some of the new whiz-bang MTBs it might), bu
    can be brought under control. I notice my front and rear suspensio
    moving a little from time to time but not to the point of annoyance, an
    it's more than compensated for when you slam into that pothole or nee
    to jump that kerb, etc

    -

  4. Quoted message said:

    To give you an idea, when my foot is at the top of the peddling arc, my
    knee is directly above the bottom bracket

    Compact frames do -not- have shallower seat angles as you described. I
    anything you will find the newer compact frames have slightly steepe
    seat tubes compared to bikes 10+ years ago

    Your right about the frame being stiffer but that is slightly offset b
    the long, extended seatpost

    The difference between a 73 and 74 degree seat tube (most bikes us
    these angles) makes is about 1cm, which isn't much. It would be hard t
    find a bike frame that would push you way over the rear wheel unless i
    was very small or big according to your size. I would say whoever rod
    the bike you tried had the seat a fair way back and it was obviously no
    adjusted for yourself

    Its best to look at the end of you knee when the pedal and crank arm
    are horizontal, being forward in the 3 o'clock position -not- at the to
    of the peddling arc. Adjust your seat forward or back until your knee i
    directly over the center of the pedal. This is the method most peopl
    use. Never use the saddle to adjust the reach to the handlebars

    -

  5. One bike and one bike alone - the new 2004 Specialized EPIC. Took one for a
    ride a couple of weeks ago and it is simply awesome (for a stock bike).
    Rides like a hardtail when you want it to and takes any bump, lump or jump
    you can throw at it. Only downside is the $3800 price tag.
    The front shocks (Manitou?) have a lockout on them that works a treat and
    I'd be happy to have them on almost any bike.

    Oh, and I just like the bike I don¹t have any agenda or work for a bike
    shop.

    On 9/3/04 9:56 AM, in article
    [email hidden], "Andy B"

    Quoted message said:

    Hi

    I own a 1990 Diamond Back Topanga which has done more km's than I
    could imagine. It's needing some repairs, so am I'm borrowing a bike
    (Giant Rincon) from work for my commute in the interim.

    As I'm considering retiring the Topanga, I've got some questions about
    newer bikes.

    This is the first bike I've ridden with front shocks (RS Suntour XCR),
    and while they're usefull when hitting ruts etc, I find them a pain
    when trying to accelerate fast, as the font end feels like it's
    bouncing all over the shop. Is this a technique thing? I've tightned
    them up as much as possible (adjustment knobs on top), so they're not
    too washy while riding. Can you get shocks that offer more support,
    while still providing a damping effect when it's needed? I've also
    noticed that they take a while to recover from being compressed, so on
    a section that's very rutted out, they'll probably end up compressing
    and not extend before the next rut, so will stay in a compressed state
    untill the road/track smooths out.

    The frame geometary is very different to what I'm used to. It almost
    looks like a girls bike compared to mine, in that the top tube travels
    down from the head. I'm guessing that by having smaller triangles,
    the frame's stiffer. The problem I find with this, is that I end up
    sitting over the back wheel, as the seat post is at an angle, and has
    to be extended about a foot to be the correct height. When I peddle,
    instead of being over the peddles, they're in front of me. To give
    you an idea, when my foot is at the top of the peddling arc, my knee
    is directly above the bottom bracket. I find this neither a
    comfortable nor powerfull riding position. Is this the new way to
    ride?

    Lastly, what price should i expect to pay second had for a 6-12 month
    old bike in good condition, with a new RRP of around $1,500 (In Bris
    if it makes any difference)?

    Thanks for any insight you can offer.

    Andy

Active in the last 60 minutes

Active in this thread

0 users · 0 guests ·0 bots ·0 total

No signed-in users are active right now.

No known search crawlers active right now.