General fitness, health and nutrition · Public discussion

knee surgery

Started by Larry · · Last activity · 3 posts · 524 views

This thread is locked and is currently read-only.

Thread details

What we know about this thread

Original section
General fitness, health and nutrition
Published
13 October 2003
Last activity
16 October 2003
Original author
Larry
Posts
3
Discussion status
Public discussion
Total views
524
Views / 30 days
0
Topics

The navigation and discussion metadata provide context. Posts remain in their original chronological order.

Showing posts 1–3 of 3
Posts remain in their original chronological order.

Text size
  1. My mother is in her 70's and has knee pain. She had skiing accidents
    when she was younger and fell down the stairs so now has knee problem.
    Is there any practical alternatives to surgery. I think doctor
    recomends some kind of surgery which is less debilitating than it used
    to be years ago as she should only be in hospital a couple days. It
    would seem that bone related issues might have less of an effective
    eastern healing approach I would imagine. Would people agree on that ?

    Any good books on bone issues for the layman I'd be interested in. I
    had a stress fracture in my foot, had back problems when I was younger
    and my knee aches a little from disuse while I was on crutches. I
    figure whatever knowledge I can gain might help me in the future.

  2. "Larry" <[email hidden]> wrote in message
    news:[email hidden]...

    Quoted message said:

    My mother is in her 70's and has knee pain. She had skiing accidents
    when she was younger and fell down the stairs so now has knee problem.
    Is there any practical alternatives to surgery. I think doctor
    recomends some kind of surgery which is less debilitating than it used
    to be years ago as she should only be in hospital a couple days. It
    would seem that bone related issues might have less of an effective
    eastern healing approach I would imagine. Would people agree on that ?

    One would have to know the exact nature of your mom's knee problems to even
    offers ideas, Larry. Injuries like damage to the meniscus or the collateral
    ligaments of the knee involves very different treatment than that used for
    severe deterioration of the cartilage from age/overuse accompanied by
    advanced osteoarthritis.

    Some knee problems respond well to manual therapies like PT, massage, &
    hydrotherapy. Some nutritional treatments have shown preliminary success
    with treating mild cases of cartilage degeneration. Conventional meds, like
    NSAIDS (which must be used very cautiously) & Synovisc injections can be of
    help. Of course, there are instances where only surgical intervention
    works.

    In September my 69 year old mom just returned to her full time (very active)
    job after having bilateral total knee replacement surgery in mid-June. She
    had suffered for over 5 years with terrible pain & swelling, trying both
    conventional & alternative treatments with less & less relief. She had no
    cartilage left in either knee & the osteoarthritis was making her consider
    retiring from a position she's had for over 20 years that she adores. She
    finally realized she had exhausted her options & opted for surgery. She
    recently admitted that she's glad she did it, despite an uncomfortable
    recuperation.

    Each case is different. The problem often determines what treatment will be
    of help.

    Michele
    I ENJOY being a cranky [censored].

  3. My mother argues her knee problem requires surgery because it aches in
    bed when she is not walking. My thai chi teachers says knee prob can
    be caused
    by atrophy or not enough usage and that thai chi knee bends might
    help, but my mother's point seems to make sense as far as I can tell.

    "fred & michele" <[email hidden]> wrote in message news:<[email hidden]>...

    Quoted message said:

    "Larry" <[email hidden]> wrote in message
    news:[email hidden]...

    Quoted message said:

    My mother is in her 70's and has knee pain. She had skiing accidents
    when she was younger and fell down the stairs so now has knee problem.
    Is there any practical alternatives to surgery. I think doctor
    recomends some kind of surgery which is less debilitating than it used
    to be years ago as she should only be in hospital a couple days. It
    would seem that bone related issues might have less of an effective
    eastern healing approach I would imagine. Would people agree on that ?

    One would have to know the exact nature of your mom's knee problems to even
    offers ideas, Larry. Injuries like damage to the meniscus or the collateral
    ligaments of the knee involves very different treatment than that used for
    severe deterioration of the cartilage from age/overuse accompanied by
    advanced osteoarthritis.

    Some knee problems respond well to manual therapies like PT, massage, &
    hydrotherapy. Some nutritional treatments have shown preliminary success
    with treating mild cases of cartilage degeneration. Conventional meds, like
    NSAIDS (which must be used very cautiously) & Synovisc injections can be of
    help. Of course, there are instances where only surgical intervention
    works.

    In September my 69 year old mom just returned to her full time (very active)
    job after having bilateral total knee replacement surgery in mid-June. She
    had suffered for over 5 years with terrible pain & swelling, trying both
    conventional & alternative treatments with less & less relief. She had no
    cartilage left in either knee & the osteoarthritis was making her consider
    retiring from a position she's had for over 20 years that she adores. She
    finally realized she had exhausted her options & opted for surgery. She
    recently admitted that she's glad she did it, despite an uncomfortable
    recuperation.

    Each case is different. The problem often determines what treatment will be
    of help.

    Michele
    I ENJOY being a cranky [censored].

Active in the last 60 minutes

Active in this thread

0 users · 0 guests ·0 bots ·0 total

No signed-in users are active right now.

No known search crawlers active right now.