Recumbent bicycles · Public discussion

knee/leg pain

Started by Niteynite1 · · Last activity · 3 posts · 8,239 views

Thread details

What we know about this thread

Original section
Recumbent bicycles
Published
16 October 2003
Last activity
17 October 2003
Original author
Niteynite1
Posts
3
Discussion status
Public discussion
Total views
8,239
Views / 30 days
0

The navigation and discussion metadata provide context. Posts remain in their original chronological order.

Showing posts 1–3 of 3
Posts remain in their original chronological order.

Text size
  1. OK, here's my story and if it sounds familiar, it's because I'm posting this on several
    recumbent boards:

    I am riding an Easyracers EZ SC-1 (heavy). For the first 500 miles, my only physical complaint was a
    little numbness around the tailbone, relieved by stopping and walking around for just a couple of
    minutes every 10-12 miles.

    The day after I passed 500 miles, I encountered a new problem. I was in the first mile of a ride on
    Sunday, Oct. 5, when I felt a little muscle twinge in my left leg, just below the groin. I rode on,
    figuring I would lose it as I warmed up. Before I reached my 20-mile mark and the turnaround of my
    planned 40-miler, the discomfort had spread to the inside back of my left knee. Whenever I got off
    and walked a few minutes (see dead butt problem above), I felt no problem, only when I pedaled.

    After finishing the 40-miler, I was a little sore in that leg for a day or two. A combination of
    work schedule, weather and traveling meant I did not get back on the bike until today, Thursday,
    Oct. 16. Within two miles, I was feeling the dull pain behind my knee again. I rode 20 today and the
    pain never went away, but it never got too bad, either.

    Any ideas and/or suggestions? I should mention the bike is still stock. I have not changed anything,
    including not yet taking the clipless pedals off my road bike and putting them on the 'bent.Also,
    I'm 57, 5-9 and pretty overweight.

    This may or may not have any relevance here, but I see comments about pedal extenders and knee pain.
    Is this the kind of knee pain some have experienced and alleviated with extenders? I know nothing
    about them and how they work, but remembered that as I was riding today. Since I haven't put on the
    clipless pedals, I am free to move my feet around the pedals and tried pedaling from the outside
    edges of the pedals (i.e., as if I had extenders) and felt no difference in the pain.

    The pain is uncomfortable, but tolerable. It has not been sharp, and feels deep within the leg.
    Since I was able to keep riding for 40 miles with it the first time, it is obviously not
    incapacitating.

    Any/all suggestions appreciated.

    Thanks

  2. Hey Niteynite - There are no simple answers to knee pain and most who respond will have a different
    take on this. Typically, pain in front of knee means your seat is too close. Pain behind knee might
    mean that your seat is too far away. How long has it taken you to ride your first 500 miles? I'm
    asking because your groin pain sounds like an overuse injury and I suspect you are also feeling it
    behind your knee because some of the big leg muscles that extend the hip and knee attach in both
    areas. Recumbents are deceiving - it is easy to push yourself to ride lots since the position is so
    comfortable, especially when you are generally deconditioned. Suggestions: 1) check distance to
    pedals and adjust so that your heel reaches the pedal with your leg extended and your butt back in
    the seat. 2) Is your groin pain worst with maximum hip flexion on your pedal return or extension
    when your leg is straightest? Adjust your seat back to minimize your pain range. Probably more
    upright will help given your low bottom bracket bike. 3) Short rides, easy warm up, spin don't mash,
    ice to whatever hurts when done to decrease swelling. Easy does it until pain disappears, then
    gradually increase ride duration and intensity. 4) Avoid radical changes in your pedal biomechanics
    (extenders or clipless) until your pain resolves. Caveat - Your complaints could stem from pain
    originating in your hip and radiating south. If tha is the case, you'll need hands on evaluation and
    help. As with all well intentioned usenet advice, your mileage will definitely vary so take all of
    this with a grain of salt. But go easy. And hopefully someone else can comment on stretching. Jon
    Shinefeld Philadelphia, PA

    "Niteynite1" <[email hidden]> wrote in message
    "]news:[email hidden]...

    Quoted message said:

    OK, here's my story and if it sounds familiar, it's because I'm posting


    this on

    Quoted message said:

    several recumbent boards:

    I am riding an Easyracers EZ SC-1 (heavy). For the first 500 miles, my


    only

    Quoted message said:

    physical complaint was a little numbness around the tailbone, relieved by stopping and walking
    around for just a couple of minutes every 10-12


    miles.

    Quoted message said:


    The day after I passed 500 miles, I encountered a new problem. I was in


    the

    Quoted message said:

    first mile of a ride on Sunday, Oct. 5, when I felt a little muscle twinge


    in

    Quoted message said:

    my left leg, just below the groin. I rode on, figuring I would lose it as


    I

    Quoted message said:

    warmed up. Before I reached my 20-mile mark and the turnaround of my


    planned

    Quoted message said:

    40-miler, the discomfort had spread to the inside back of my left knee. Whenever I got off and
    walked a few minutes (see dead butt problem above),


    I

    Quoted message said:

    felt no problem, only when I pedaled.

    After finishing the 40-miler, I was a little sore in that leg for a day or


    two.

    Quoted message said:

    A combination of work schedule, weather and traveling meant I did not get


    back

    Quoted message said:

    on the bike until today, Thursday, Oct. 16. Within two miles, I was


    feeling the

    Quoted message said:

    dull pain behind my knee again. I rode 20 today and the pain never went


    away,

    Quoted message said:

    but it never got too bad, either.

    Any ideas and/or suggestions? I should mention the bike is still stock. I


    have

    Quoted message said:

    not changed anything, including not yet taking the clipless pedals off my


    road

    Quoted message said:

    bike and putting them on the 'bent.Also, I'm 57, 5-9 and pretty


    overweight.

    Quoted message said:


    This may or may not have any relevance here, but I see comments about


    pedal

    Quoted message said:

    extenders and knee pain. Is this the kind of knee pain some have


    experienced

    Quoted message said:

    and alleviated with extenders? I know nothing about them and how they


    work, but

    Quoted message said:

    remembered that as I was riding today. Since I haven't put on the clipless pedals, I am free to
    move my feet around the pedals and tried pedaling


    from the

    Quoted message said:

    outside edges of the pedals (i.e., as if I had extenders) and felt no difference in the pain.

    The pain is uncomfortable, but tolerable. It has not been sharp, and feels


    deep

    Quoted message said:

    within the leg. Since I was able to keep riding for 40 miles with it the


    first

    Quoted message said:

    time, it is obviously not incapacitating.

    Any/all suggestions appreciated.

    Thanks

  3. Quoted message said:

    Suggestions: 1) check distance to pedals and adjust so that your heel reaches the pedal with your
    leg extended and your butt back in the seat.

    I am just learning this stuff, and still consider myself a newbie (1
    1/2 years bent). I'm 53 yo, well marbled, 5'9", ride an R40 SWB.

    I wanted to very tentatively add to Jon Shinefeld's very useful previous msg; Consider his suggested
    adjustment of pedal distance a "starting place". It will be harder to know if it works for you since
    you are already experiencing pain, but I'd suggest ride it that way a while, long enough to get
    comfortable with it. Do you now have a feeling that it should be longer? Shorter? Do you find
    yourself sliding a tiny bit forward in the seat while pedaling? Maybe you need a shorter pedal
    distance. Only change it by a tiny bit each time, like 1/8", or
    2/16", then give it a chance. Put a hundred or so miles on it, then re-evaluate.

Active in the last 60 minutes

Active in this thread

0 users · 0 guests ·0 bots ·0 total

No signed-in users are active right now.

No known search crawlers active right now.