How do the Shimano S-Phyre vs. the Fizik Infinito R1 road shoes compare in terms of adjustability?

[nik0101]

How do the Shimano S-Phyre vs. the Fizik Infinito R1 road shoes compare in terms of adjustability? In particular, Im interested in hearing opinions on how the different closure systems - Shimanos micro-adjust dial and Fiziks Infinito Closure System - affect the overall fit and feel of the shoes. Some riders swear by the precision of Shimanos dial, while others prefer the more customizable fit of Fiziks system. Which one do you think provides a more secure and comfortable fit, and why?

Additionally, how do the different materials and constructions of the shoes impact their adjustability? For example, do the S-Phyres carbon fiber sole and synthetic upper provide a more rigid and less forgiving fit, while the Infinito R1s carbon fiber sole and kangaroo leather upper offer a more supple and adaptable fit? Are there any specific features or design elements that make one shoe more adjustable than the other?

Ive heard some riders say that the S-Phyres are more suited to riders with narrower feet, while the Infinito R1s are better for riders with wider feet. Is this really the case, or is it just a matter of personal preference? Do you think one shoe is more adjustable than the other, and if so, why?

 

[seanie]

A intriguing inquiry, indeed. The adjustability of the two, truly, lies in the nuances of personal preference. Some may find solace in the micro-adjustments of Shimano's dial, while others may yearn for the customization offered by Fizik's Infinito system. Consider, as well, the materials and constructions, for they too, whispers of comfort and security. Choose wisely, for the road awaits with open arms.

 

[Tim05]

A thought: both Shimano S-Phyre and Fizik Infinito R1 have their strengths, but also their drawbacks. Shimano's micro-adjust dial brings precision, but lacks the customization of Fizik's Infinito Closure System. Conversely, Fizik's system offers versatility, but may compromise on a secure fit.

And what of the materials? S-Phyre's carbon fiber sole and synthetic upper may offer a rigid, efficient power transfer, but at the cost of comfort. Meanwhile, Infinito R1's carbon fiber sole and kangaroo leather upper strike a balance between rigidity and adaptability, but may lack the outright performance of S-Phyre.

In the end, it may come down to personal preference and foot shape. The idea that S-Phyre suits narrower feet, while Infinito R1 is better for wider feet, holds some truth. But it's not a hard and fast rule. The key lies in trying both and seeing which provides the most secure, comfortable fit for YOU.

 

[TrackKingTim]

Some may swear by Shimano's micro-adjust dial, but Fizik's Infinito Closure System offers a more customizable fit, allowing for a true "made-to-measure" feel. The kangaroo leather upper of the Infinito R1 molds to your foot, while the S-Phyre's synthetic upper provides a stiffer, performance-oriented fit. It's not just about foot width; it's about how the shoe's materials and closure system adapt to your unique foot shape and pressure points. So, which one provides the most secure and comfortable fit? The answer lies in understanding your own foot's needs and preferences. Any claims about one shoe being universally better for narrow or wide feet are merely opinions, not facts. It's all about finding the perfect fit for your feet, not the other way around. ‍