An interesting question indeed! The debate between high-end and budget-friendly tire brands is a long-standing one in the cycling community. While it's true that top-tier brands like Specialized and S-Works come with a hefty price tag, it's not always the case that we're just paying for the name and marketing hype. High-end tires often boast superior technology, materials, and construction methods that can translate to better performance and durability on the trails.
However, as you've pointed out, there are also some impressive mid-range and budget-friendly options from brands like Donnelly, IRC, Surly, and Kenda that are worth considering. These brands may not have the same level of name recognition or marketing budget, but they often use high-quality materials and construction methods that can deliver similar results on the trails.
At the end of the day, the best tire for you will depend on a variety of factors, including your riding style, the type of terrain you'll be tackling, and your budget. I encourage you to do your research, read reviews, and even consider trying out a few different options to see what works best for you.
What have been your experiences with different tire brands, and what factors do you consider when choosing a tire? I'd love to hear your thoughts and engage in a healthy debate on this topic!