General fitness, health and nutrition · Public discussion

Diet Does Matter

Started by Tim Campbell · · Last activity · 3 posts · 258 views

This thread is locked and is currently read-only.

Thread details

What we know about this thread

Original section
General fitness, health and nutrition
Published
6 October 2005
Last activity
7 October 2005
Original author
Tim Campbell
Posts
3
Discussion status
Public discussion
Total views
258
Views / 30 days
0

The navigation and discussion metadata provide context. Posts remain in their original chronological order.

Showing posts 1–3 of 3
Posts remain in their original chronological order.

Text size
  1. Re Preventing Cancer: Does Diet Matter?

    Diet does matter. It is a myth to believe that what
    we put in our mouths does not affect us. Every cell in
    the body is made only and completely from the food we eat
    ( with a little help from oxygen). Every mechanism that
    drives our metabolism is comprised of elements that are
    derived from the food that grows out of the earth and
    contains all the known nutrients, pesticides, fertilizers,
    growth enhancers and every other molecule that we put into
    the environment.
    The myth persists, because when we eat a food it
    promptly disappears down our esophagus , however this
    does not mean we can forget about it. Foods are either
    digested or excreted and in both cases are intimately
    involved with very sensitive organs, the gut, then the liver
    and then all the rest of us. If we open the hood of our
    car and throw a monkey wrench into the engine , the first
    time it may be spit out. Constant wrench throwing will
    eventually change the way in which the engine works and so too
    will our bodies when we constantly expose them to molecules
    that were never designed for human consumption.
    We nutritionists have only in the past few decades really
    accepted that nutrients/foods can optimize our health rather
    than just prevent deficiency diseases. Recent failures such
    as Vitamin E probably not preventing heart disease and fibre
    likely not preventing colon cancer mean only that we have
    not yet been asking the right questions. You will become what
    you eat so choose wisely.

    James Friel Professor of Nutrition
    and Pediatrics University of Manitoba
    Winnipeg

  2. Geez, is this guy behind the times or what. Why don't you start with
    "Diet and Health" by the National Research Council? It is about a
    decade and a half old, and it sums up the evidence up to that time.
    There is so much evidence at this point that it's almost a crime that
    nobody in a powerful position has come forward to talk about the role
    of stressors, such as lipid peroxidation, that can occur with a poor
    diet, or in other ways. If this guy characterized the state of his
    discipline accurately, all the nutritionists should have their assets
    confiscated and they should be put to work in coal mines, because it
    would mean that they've accomplished nothing but a reiteration of the
    old "you are what you eat" saying.

    Pathetic.

  3. montygram said:

    Geez, is this guy behind the times or what. Why don't you start with
    "Diet and Health" by the National Research Council? It is about a
    decade and a half old, and it sums up the evidence up to that time.
    There is so much evidence at this point that it's almost a crime that
    nobody in a powerful position has come forward to talk about the role
    of stressors, such as lipid peroxidation, that can occur with a poor
    diet, or in other ways. If this guy characterized the state of his
    discipline accurately, all the nutritionists should have their assets
    confiscated and they should be put to work in coal mines, because it
    would mean that they've accomplished nothing but a reiteration of the
    old "you are what you eat" saying.

    Pathetic.

    Quoted message said:

    Don't bother with the vegetables at all.

    Speaking of pathetic: Are you serious?

    Subject lines do not matter to you. Nor, does the topic of the post
    that you are replying to matter to you. You are here to repeat your
    message ad nauseam regardless of anything. So, why should a quote
    matter?

    You have been against vegetables in at least two of your posts. That
    should be a red flag to anyone remotely familiar with nutrition.

    You are clearly the most dangerous crackpot on these ngs in recent
    years. And, you claim to be a professor at a major university.

    Did you know that academia is the second oldest scam in the history of
    mankind?

    You are cracked. Just thought that you might want to know.

Active in the last 60 minutes

Active in this thread

0 users · 0 guests ·0 bots ·0 total

No signed-in users are active right now.

No known search crawlers active right now.