Road Cycling · Public discussion

Crank removal driving me round the bend!!!!!

Started by dave1975 · · Last activity · 4 posts · 1,033 views

Thread details

What we know about this thread

Original section
Road Cycling
Published
6 October 2003
Last activity
7 October 2003
Original author
dave1975
Posts
4
Discussion status
Public discussion
Total views
1,033
Views / 30 days
0

The navigation and discussion metadata provide context. Posts remain in their original chronological order.

Showing posts 1–4 of 4
Posts remain in their original chronological order.

Text size
  1. Help!!!!!
    Can any one give me tips on removing a crank from my MTB. the problem i've got is that, my old school MTb seems to have an unconventional setup.
    The first thing i did was remove the plastic cover on the crank which reveals what looks like a nut/bolt, after looking through a how to manual for MTB's, it mentions that if i unscrew the nut, i should find that a whole bolt should unscrew from the crank......BUT it doesn't, the nut comes off cleanliy but leaves a threaded bolt in place. I haven't damaged the bolt or the nut as as both look fine and look like two seperate bits.
    I'm kind of thinking that i probabley need a tool for the job, but has anyone got a clue as to what this setup is called, and what tool i'd need to rectify!!!!!!
    Any ideas would be appreciated.

    Cheers

    D

  2. In article said:

    Help!!!!! Can any one give me tips on removing a crank from my MTB. the problem i've got is that,
    my old school MTb seems to have an unconventional setup. The first thing i did was remove the
    plastic cover on the crank which reveals what looks like a nut/bolt, after looking through a how to
    manual for MTB's, it mentions that if i unscrew the nut, i should find that a whole bolt should
    unscrew from the crank......BUT it doesn't, the nut comes off cleanliy but leaves a threaded bolt
    in place. I haven't damaged the bolt or the nut as as both look fine and look like two seperate
    bits. I'm kind of thinking that i probabley need a tool for the job, but has anyone got a clue as
    to what this setup is called, and what tool i'd need to rectify!!!!!! Any ideas would be
    appreciated.

    Cheers

    D

    Hi,

    You need a "crank puller"...available at any LBS for around $15.00.

    There are 3 types of bottom bracket spindles (that part onto which crankarms are mounted)....square
    spindle with threaded stud, square spindle that uses a bolt, and splined pipe billet. Get a crank
    puller that is designed for use with square spindles...screw in the portion that threads into the
    crank arm, turn the handle clockwise and it will "pull" the crank arm off.

    Regards,
    Bill

  3. dave1975 said:

    Help!!!!! Can any one give me tips on removing a crank from my MTB. the problem i've got is that,
    my old school MTb seems to have an unconventional setup. The first thing i did was remove the
    plastic cover on the crank which reveals what looks like a nut/bolt, after looking through a how to
    manual for MTB's, it mentions that if i unscrew the nut, i should find that a whole bolt should
    unscrew from the crank......BUT it doesn't, the nut comes off cleanliy but leaves a threaded bolt
    in place. I haven't damaged the bolt or the nut as as both look fine and look like two seperate
    bits. I'm kind of thinking that i probabley need a tool for the job, but has anyone got a clue as
    to what this setup is called, and what tool i'd need to rectify!!!!!! Any ideas would be
    appreciated.

    parktool.comFAQrCarm.shtml

    jeverett3<AT>earthlink<DOT>net home.earthlink.net~jeverett3

  4. John,

    I am familiar with the kind of bottom bracket you are talking about. My guess is that you have also
    tried the other side and found a similar situation. What I am going to tell you worked for me, when
    I was helping a friend with this but it is neither easy nor entirely fool proof, (though presumably
    after your frustration you will pitch this bottom bracket and get an inexpensive aftermarket
    Shimano with proper crank bolts ;-) Besides, these bottom brackets in their best days were heavy
    sloppy junk.

    Loosen the nut all the way flush with the top of the threaded stud (hopefully your puller allows
    that nut to stay in place when you secure it into the crank arm- some of those nuts have an
    integrated washer and that won't work). Leaving the nut on isn't necessarily required but you will
    likely deform the stud threads when you drive the remover on top of the stud, which you obviously
    thought about in your post. With the nut there, it helps preserve the stud integrity. Pull the arm
    loose. You can then remove the puller, the nut and washer and the arm should simply lift off. If
    your nut is too large for the puller to go around, perhaps you can find a smaller nut or
    non-integrated nut/washer, with the same threads at ACE Hardware or similar.

    Hope this helps!

    John Everett said:
    dave1975 said:

    Help!!!!! Can any one give me tips on removing a crank from my MTB. the problem i've got is that,
    my old school MTb seems to have an unconventional setup. The first thing i did was remove the
    plastic cover on the crank which reveals what looks like a nut/bolt, after looking through a how
    to manual for MTB's, it mentions that if i unscrew the nut, i should find that a whole bolt should
    unscrew from the crank......BUT it doesn't, the nut comes off cleanliy but leaves a threaded bolt
    in place. I haven't damaged the bolt or the nut as as both look fine and look like two seperate
    bits. I'm kind of thinking that i probabley need a tool for the job, but has anyone got a clue as
    to what this setup is called, and what tool i'd need to rectify!!!!!! Any ideas would be
    appreciated.

    parktool.comFAQrCarm.shtml

    jeverett3<AT>earthlink<DOT>net home.earthlink.net~jeverett3

Active in the last 60 minutes

Active in this thread

0 users · 0 guests ·0 bots ·0 total

No signed-in users are active right now.

No known search crawlers active right now.