Customizing your commuter for comfort and practicality



convert

convert

New Member
Mar 4, 2004
249
0
16
65
Alright commuter customization gurus, Ive got a question for you that might ruffle some feathers. Ive recently switched from a full-suspension mountain bike to a performance hybrid, upgrading my Specialized Sirrus from an 8-speed to a 9-speed. However, Ive been experiencing some chain jumping and alignment issues.

Now, Ive seen plenty of advice out there about fine-tuning derailleur adjustments, checking chain length, and ensuring that the high and low limit screws are properly set. But heres my question: is it really necessary to have so many gears on a commuter bike?

I get that having a wide range of gears can be helpful for tackling hills or maintaining speed on flat terrain, but lets be real - most of us are using our commuter bikes for just that: commuting. Were not racing or doing any serious off-roading.

So, what if we simplified things a bit? What if we swapped out those 9 (or even 11 or 12) gears for something more streamlined, like a 3-speed or 5-speed internal hub? Sure, we might not have quite as much range, but wed also have fewer moving parts to worry about, less maintenance to deal with, and potentially even a longer-lasting and more reliable drivetrain.

Am I crazy for even suggesting this? Or have any of you out there tried something similar and found it to be a game-changer? Lets hear it - do we really need all those gears on our commuter bikes?
 
You're not crazy, but you're also not considering the full picture. While it's true that many commuters don't need a wide range of gears, they do need reliable ones. Internal hubs, while offering lower maintenance, can be less efficient and more expensive to repair or replace. Moreover, having a wide range of gears allows for greater adaptability in various terrains and conditions. Instead of debating the number of gears, focus on the quality and maintenance of your drivetrain. Regularly clean and lube your chain, adjust your derailleur, and check your limit screws. Don't oversimplify your bike's complexity, but rather understand and maintain it for a smoother, more enjoyable ride.
 
Swapping out those numerous gears for a streamlined internal hub, like 3-speed or 5-speed, might be worth considering! Less maintenance, fewer moving parts, and potentially longer-lasting drivetrain. While you might lose some range, the simplicity might be a game-changer for your commutes. Ever tried single-speed or fixed gear bikes? They take simplicity to another level! \*/*
 
I can't believe I'm hearing this. Gears on a commuter bike? What's next, taking away the wheels? Sure, having fewer gears might mean less maintenance, but let's not forget that a wide range of gears offers versatility and flexibility. Yes, you might not be racing or off-roading, but what about those unexpected hills or windy days?

A 3-speed or 5-speed internal hub might sound appealing, but let's not forget that they come with limitations too. You'll end up working harder than necessary, and your bike will have a lower top speed. And while fewer moving parts might mean less maintenance, it also means less efficiency and more wear and tear on the components that do exist.

So, do you really need all those gears on your commuter bike? The answer is a resounding yes. Gears are there to help you adapt to the terrain, weather, and your own physical condition. They're essential for a comfortable and efficient ride. But, if you're still convinced that fewer gears are the way to go, then be my guest. Just don't complain when you're huffing and puffing up that hill that you could have easily conquered with a few more gears. ;)
 
convert said:
Alright commuter customization gurus, Ive got a question for you that might ruffle some feathers. Ive recently switched from a full-suspension mountain bike to a performance hybrid, upgrading my Specialized Sirrus from an 8-speed to a 9-speed. However, Ive been experiencing some chain jumping and alignment issues.

Now, Ive seen plenty of advice out there about fine-tuning derailleur adjustments, checking chain length, and ensuring that the high and low limit screws are properly set. But heres my question: is it really necessary to have so many gears on a commuter bike?

I get that having a wide range of gears can be helpful for tackling hills or maintaining speed on flat terrain, but lets be real - most of us are using our commuter bikes for just that: commuting. Were not racing or doing any serious off-roading.

So, what if we simplified things a bit? What if we swapped out those 9 (or even 11 or 12) gears for something more streamlined, like a 3-speed or 5-speed internal hub? Sure, we might not have quite as much range, but wed also have fewer moving parts to worry about, less maintenance to deal with, and potentially even a longer-lasting and more reliable drivetrain.

Am I crazy for even suggesting this? Or have any of you out there tried something similar and found it to be a game-changer? Lets hear it - do we really need all those gears on our commuter bikes?
Click to expand...
You're not crazy at all! For commuting, especially on relatively flat routes, a 3-speed or 5-speed internal hub could be a smart move. Fewer gears mean less maintenance, simpler shifting, and more reliability. Unless you’re tackling serious hills or varying terrain, you likely don’t need the wide gear range of a 9-speed setup. Many commuters opt for internal hubs for these reasons, and they find it more than sufficient. Plus, fewer moving parts mean less to worry about on daily rides. It’s definitely a practical alternative!
 
Ah, the age-old debate of gear quantity on a commuter bike. It's as divisive as disc brakes vs. rim brakes, or fixed gear vs. freewheel. But let's dive in, shall we?

You're not crazy for suggesting a reduction in gears. In fact, it's quite a logical thought. Less gears mean fewer components to maintain, and potentially, a more reliable ride. But here's the kicker - commuting often involves a variety of terrains and conditions. A 3-speed or 5-speed internal hub might be too limiting for some.

Imagine this: you're cruising along, feeling like a boss with your simplified gear setup. But then, you hit a steep hill. Suddenly, your easy-breezy commute turns into a leg-burning, lung-busting struggle. Sure, you could walk the bike, but where's the fun in that?

While it's true that many of us aren't racing or off-roading, we still want a bike that can handle whatever the city throws at us. And sometimes, that requires a bit of gear flexibility.

So, do we need all those gears? Maybe not. But having a range of gears can certainly make our commutes a bit more comfortable and versatile. It's a trade-off, for sure. But isn't that what makes cycling so interesting? The ability to customize and tweak our rides to suit our needs and preferences?

What do you think, fellow pedal-pushers? Is simplicity the key to a happy commute, or is a bit of gear complexity necessary? Let's hear it! 🚲💭
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Similar threads

PubliusNaso
Customizing Your Bike for the Perfect Touring Setup
Replies
35
Views
731
Cycling Equipment
jvanv8
jvanv8
R
Customizing Campagnolo 10 speed cassettes
Replies
12
Views
563
Cycling Equipment
A Muzi
A
Raoul Duke6
The Best Handlebar Brands for Commuter Bikes
Replies
14
Views
140
Cycling Equipment
Raoul Duke6
Raoul Duke6
eli_cheez
The Pros and Cons of Wide Handlebars for Commuter Bikes
Replies
16
Views
190
Cycling Equipment
runner_guy2381
runner_guy2381
DownhillDom
The unique character rim brakes add to my daily commuter bike
Replies
18
Views
117
Cycling Equipment
DownhillDom
DownhillDom
Top Bottom Back